“I’m gay, and think your column is crap. Couldn’t you just write about something more positive, like Neil Patrick Harris? I’ll give you a gay reading list if you want. You focus on making well-meaning people feel guilty, and complain too much. I don’t think guilt is a particularly effective approach for creating change. Cheers, Irked”
Darling Irked,
Thanks for your message.
To begin with, this is emphatically not an LGBT column. It’s a queer column. And not queer as in the composite for sexuality/gender diverse communities, but queer as in against normal. I’m not that interested in NPH – I think boring stuff like that gets enough airtime already. If you want to read a gay column, why don’t you write it?
I will pass on the reading list, thanks.
I think there are many ways to bring about change. In the past, LGBT communities have often focused on Pride. While Pride has its uses, it has also resulted in lots of ugly corporate, assimilationist, GAYS AND LEZS ARE MODEL CITIZENS TOO! kind of crap. I don’t do that.
My approach is more confrontational, less apologetic. It’s not that I can’t fit in, it’s that I don’t want to. I’m a one-of-a-kind kinda gal. I don’t care if some people are offended, or put off, or — goddess-forbid —challenged by what I say. They can kiss my glittery ass.
I do love causing a bit of guilt among straights, cis-folks, and white middle-class gays and lesbians, but I actually prefer causing a whole lot of shame. I want privileged homos and heteros to get their knickers in a knot because I think that some of the things I write about are shameful and need to change. I think shame is a really powerful tool for creating social change, whether it is a “Shame on you!” kind of thing or a slower “Ugh, shame, my bad, I got that wrong”.
Often I am encouraged by mainstream cis-gays and lesbians not to complain, not to make a scene, not to exist. Often I think these people are so busy focussing on trying to be the affable, apologetic fag-next-door that they fail to engage in some much needed resistance.
P.S. Irked baby, I have a book for you too. It is called Why Are Faggots So Afraid Of Faggots?
— xox H.R.H Dame La Dida.
Straight Up
-
Straight up | Issue 27
I’m sure many of us have noticed that queer columns often plumb archives of feeling which include anger, sadness or pride, or some combo of these. Which is fair enough, I think, since queer/trans people have lots to be angry, sad, and proud about. However, for this column I thought I’d lead with a different kind of feeling: gratitude. I want to single out awesome people who make my (queer) life possible. First, I wanted to say thanks to the visibly queer people who make the streets safer for me to walk on every day. Often I feel like I stick out, so it can be hard to walk past a group of bored teenagers or drunk students. That’s why it’s awesome to have others who queer public space just by being there; the gyrls with shaved heads and pierced noses, the bois with super tight jeans, cravats and lip gloss, the genderqueers and androgynous folks who make people look twice, the gay boys holding hands, the butches in hot boots. Not only do I feel a sense of safety in numbers, you are also generally hotter than anyone else. Thanks to all the volunteers in the queer/trans community in Dunedin and NZ wide. The organisers of parties, the people who work in the community or as online bloggers and activists, the educators. Thank you to the folks who run youth groups, or open up their homes and let people in. I am grateful that people in queer and trans communities volunteer so often, and I know sometimes the thank yous can be slow in coming. Thanks to allies. Our hetero and cis-gendered friends, family, and lovers. The self-identified fag-hags, trans-hags, and les-bros: thanks for standing up for us, so we don’t have to defend ourselves ad nauseam. Thanks for thinking about hetero/cis sexism. Thanks for calling other people out on their dumb shit so I don’t have to. Thanks to the staff on campus who have joined the Otago University Queer Friendly Staff Network. Thanks to accepting Christians, Muslims, and people of other faiths who make it possible for queer/trans folk to continue our spiritual practices. Most of all, thanks for getting that sometimes many of us do talk about queer stuff a lot, and thanks for understanding that we do it because many of us don’t get a fair go. And thanks to Critic – for creating space for queer and trans issues this year. <3 La Dida xxoxxx!
-
Straight Up | Issue 26
In this one short sentence, I will possibly extinguish what’s left of my queer cool cred: I’m a country fag, and I like it. I am not hard country. I’m more the soft, lifestyle block, grow-heirloom-roses kind. I like the smell of silage, flower shows, and shingle roads. I like to have space to move, breathe, and think. It’s not that I dislike cities; I just don’t love them. This admission can be met with incredulity in some queer* scenes - where being rural (or worse, choosing it, liking it, and not wanting to leave) is profoundly counter-cultural. Often it seems that in NZ, like elsewhere, the city is constructed as the “natural” environment for modern queer life. The city is imagined as a place of community, ripe with non-conformity and sexy queer potential. Whereas the rural is just butt-fuck nowhere. Or supposedly no butt-fuck at all. This is what someone waaaay smarter than me has called the metro-normativity of queer/trans scenes – a collective investment in the idea that The City is a better, queerer and generally more fabulous place, and that rural life is backwards and avoidable. But newsflash, honey! Rural living has awesome queer possibilities too. Living rurally is not necessarily a hotbed for hostility. And we country queers are not all self-hating, backward victims of fashion (and geography) who long to escape to some urban centre for shopping, loving, and community. In my experience, queer rural life can be awesome. Lots of my queer/trans community are accessible online, and I don’t feel disconnected. Country life can also be important to us. I have made the decision not to live in the city because living close to my family is something I prioritise right now. Country folks can also be hot as - I have an undeniable and persistent desire to have all kinds of sex with the country-butch salesman who works at CRT. I am sure it’s got something to do with the moleskins, blue check shirts, and steel caps. I appreciate that for many queer and trans folks leaving rural and provincial spaces is a really good decision. When I was younger, I couldn’t wait to leave them myself. But now that I am back, I guess I see it as less black and white. There are many paths to a loving, luscious, meaningful queer/trans life, and country life may be the path some of us take.
-
Straight Up | Issue 25
6.45 am Wake up. Shit. Face creased from sleeping on top of Foucault.
-
Straight Up | Issue 24
This week I met my former high school principal while I was speaking at a seminar. I had been fantasising for years about what this moment would be like. In my fantasy I would do something outrageous that would make her deeply uncomfortable. Or, perhaps equally outrageously, I would tell the truth about how unsafe my school was for queer and trans folks like me (and lots of other people who weren’t rural, heterosexual, white, able-bodied, cis-gendered men). I had fantasised about telling her how angry I was that acceptance of this attitude came straight from those at the top (through action and inaction), and filtered its way down to teachers and students. I wanted to tell her I consider what I have achieved since high school to be in spite of what my school offered me, not because of it. I have fantasised about scratching my name off the head boy’s plaque, setting fire to things… yes, I am angry about this. Honestly, I think I am lucky to have survived high school. I wonder how many other queer kids did not survive. I also wonder how many others live with post-traumatic stress and mental ill-health as a result of their high school experiences. While I wanted to scream, weep, vomit on my principal’s shoes, and generally make a scene, in the end I didn’t. I wore my faggiest pants, shook her hand (as limply as possible), and carried on. The thing is, queer and trans bulling is not just a problem at my old school. It is a global problem. Ban Ki-Moon recently described homophobic bullying as a “moral outrage, a grave violation to human rights, and a public health crisis”. Unsafe school environments undermine fundamental human rights to education, health, safety, dignity, and freedom from violence and discrimination. I hope that once the marriage equality debate is over there will be just as many people marching through the streets, and signing petitions to say that young people’s daily experiences of violence and harassment are unacceptable. Marriage is not the answer to appalling realities of queer/trans teen suicide, self-harm, mental ill-health, alcohol abuse, risky sex and so on. Addressing the social contexts in which young people live, study, and work (including bullying) is part of the answer to this.
-
Straight Up | Issue 23
It seems like rape has been all over the news recently, and often in ways I find problematic. I don’t want to write about Julian Assange or Hell pizza; others have done a brilliant job of tearing those two issues apart already. Instead, I want to look at rape from an intersectional queer perspective. In the past, I have heard people say that rape isn’t a “proper” queer issue. I felt so sad when I heard this that I couldn’t bring myself to respond, so I am going to say it here, loud and clear: rape is a queer issue. Rape is a queer issue because queer and trans* people can be survivors and/or perpetrators of sexual violence. Rape is a queer issue because rape culture – the attitudes and practices which normalize, excuse or condone sexual violence – can be perpetuated by people with an investment in the queer and trans communities. Rape is a queer issue because the logic that delegitimises the experiences of survivors, and blames them for their own victimisation, is eerily similar to the logic that blames queer and trans folks for bringing beatings and bullying upon themselves. And above all, rape is a queer issue because the single-oppression framework doesn’t work. I have been a friend, lover, and family member of survivors of sexual assault. In 2009 I became a survivor of attempted sexual assault myself. The reasons I disclose this information are twofold: 01 | I want to bust the myth that adult people with the junk I have cannot be sexually assaulted. We can. 02 | I am both queer and a survivor. I want others in my community to know about the pain it causes me to participate in community spaces where rape jokes, victim-blaming, and standing idly by are tolerated. I want my community to know the pain of absences, like absent discussions about what consenting to sex really is, and the absence of any information on how to talk about perpetrators of sexual violence (they aren’t all strangers who hide in bushes; they can be our partners, friends, colleagues, and family members). The bottom line for me is that any queer community that I am a part of must be against rape culture. It must be, because I refuse to separate questions of gender, sexuality, and queerness from questions of rape and sexual assault. I want to participate in spaces and movements that are committed to interrogating gender and sexuality norms, while also challenging rape culture. Rape is a queer issue.
-
Straight Up | Issue 22
This week I was pleased to see Jonah Lomu on my TV screen raising awareness about the Live Below the Line campaign, which seeks to raise awareness about the experiences of the approximately 1.4 billion people worldwide who live in extreme poverty. The New Zealand equivalent of the extreme poverty line is about $2.25/day — less than an average cup of coffee. With this campaign fresh in my mind, this week I thought I would consider the place of sex, sexuality, and gender minority people in the developmental imagination. But first it is important to clarify that even broad concepts like “sex, sexuality and gender” are not necessarily identical across cultures – the SSG framework works for many people in the global North, but not necessarily everywhere else. It is also important to point out that culturally-specific identities like, for example kathoei or tom/dee in Thailand, are not simply reducible to their English language translations of trans-woman and lesbian.They have their own histories and meanings. Much of my development experience has involved researching the experiences of sex, sexuality, and gender minority development workers in Thailand. Similar to New Zealand, in Thailand much of the funding for sex, sexuality, and gender minorities is earmarked for sexual health promotion. While sexual health, particularly the prevention of HIV/AIDS, as well as the treatment and care of people who are HIV+ is incredibly important, it is not the only issue that these communities have identified as important for their development. The development practitioners I spoke with in Thailand were tired of the gaze of the development industry being so firmly fixed on their genitals. They were more interested in holistic approaches to development that placed emphasis on their community’s wellbeing. People I spoke with called for development donors and policymakers to address important legal issues, such as human rights protection and marriage equality. They noted the importance of projects like community building, anti-discrimination campaigns, and efforts to address negative social family and self-perception. Wider health concerns were also identified, including addiction, mental health, and transition-related care. Sex, sexuality, and gender minority people have needs that are complex and culturally located. For my money, any queering of development must go beyond simply programming “LGBT” into the development lexicon and rolling it out along with other mainstream indicators. The development industry must ask fundamental questions about who they imagine is being “developed” and why some types of wellbeing have been privileged over others.
-
Straight Up | Issue 21
From the moment Louisa Wall’s Marriage Equality Bill popped up on Facebook, I began preparing myself for the worst. The first thought that elbowed its way into my consciousness was not a celebratory “Oh yay, marriage – finally!”, it was a defensive “Shit, how ugly is the debate going to be?” That defensive feeling has lingered as the weeks have dragged on. Perhaps this is attached to my personal ambivalence towards marriage, and my discomfort that some queer people speak as if this is the final frontier of queer liberation. Or maybe I am defensive because I can clearly remember the horrors of the Civil Union debate in 2005, the Enough is Enough march, the hurtfulness of overheard conversations at university and on the bus, and the rise in intimidation on the streets that often mirrors the violent rhetoric of politicians and conservative pressure groups. It is probably a combination of these two factors. I’ve also been thinking about the impact of this negative rhetoric. Some people in our communities can be negatively affected by the unhelpful or hateful discourse of the “defend marriage” brigade. No matter how you feel about the cause, if you or any of your friends are feeling yuck after watching the news about it, I feel like it is OK to say, “I need to disengage, I can’t watch any more of this.” Personally, I have done exactly this. For me, this has meant a careful strategy of news consumption –I have gone on a media diet, and only choose to read/watch news that doesn’t give equal weighting to people who refuse to engage in the conversation respectfully. People like Colin Craig, whose contempt for people like me is fairly obvious. It is like any conversation: there has to be mutual respect for it to work. I hope the bill passes, and that then we can look forward to really interesting conversations about the kind of change that is needed to ensure the equality, dignity and liberation of all queer and trans folks in New Zealand. I was pleased to see The Queer Avengers opening up beyondmarriage.org.nz. I’d love to begin talking about issues that are more central to my life as a (gender)queer person, like safety from bullying in schools, or targeted campaigns to address concerns like alcohol abuse, mental illness, or homelessness in our communities.
-
Straight Up | Issue 20
Mama - how do you stay so fabulous? What’s your secret? – Grrrrl Thursday Oh Grrrrrrrl! There is no secret, Mama is an open book. Staying fabulous is more of an art than a science. For me it involves a lot of perfume. Seriously. Perfume lifts a grrrl up. And with perfume, more is always more. Regarding my lifestyle, I gave up going to war on my fat body not so long ago. I limit the amount of time I spend with people who like talking about their war with fatness, cause it both makes me sad and is terribly dull. I love cheese, and I attribute 30% of my fabulosity to cheese alone. Indeed, if I have a child I shall call them Blue. I adore exercise, but because “exercise” is such an ugly word I call it movement. Movement connects me to my body and makes me feel good. Movement is not about trying to lose weight; movement is about movement. I try to stay away from liquor. It is a nasty, addictive poison, and turns a lady into a bore. All the money I save on not buying liquor goes directly into expanding my facemask and lip balm collections. As for style, whenever I am leaving for the day I always take off one piece of jewellery and then put on four more. Excess = success. I sometimes dress in a way that makes me feel like I am nourishing my inner diva. Other times I dress to survive a hostile world. Royal blue is my colour, and I wear it often. I endeavour not to judge the aesthetic orientations of others, cause a lady knows what’s best for herself. I try to find a hairdresser who treats me like a queen. Indeed, I seek royal treatment from all those who look after me. I try to extend the same courtesy back to them. On the home front, used coffee grounds are great for exfoliating your hands, just make sure to take off all your rings first. Coconut oil applied at night makes skin clear and fresh, and is also good as a mouthwash. If you don’t already know how, I recommend getting someone to show you how to contour. If I can give you any advice about cleaning, it would be to polish your chrome taps. Nothing says kitchen fabulous like shiny chrome.
-
Straight Up | Issue 19
In this column I thought I’d give myself some space to reply to words people have called me, and I suspect many other queer/trans folks too. These are words some of us internalise and begin to use to describe ourselves. I am writing this column because often I haven’t been able to respond when someone has used these words against me, or I haven’t been in a space where I can see why it is important that I don’t use them against myself. “I can’t deal with this. You’re too emotional.” Guilty as charged. Often I find people say things like this when they want to excuse themselves from engaging deeply with an issue, or someone’s experience of pain arising from an issue. They also use it to shut down people whose responses are deemed “too emotional”. This is a strategy that has often been used to shut down women and people of colour. For example: yes, I might be pissed off at being treated like shit and want to talk about this, and yes, it might be an emotional conversation. “Calm down, you’re overreacting.” Similar to the above. Why is it my responsibility to be calm? A better question would be: why you are so uncomfortable with me being angry or upset? What does this expectation for cool, calm dialogue conceal? Who does it privilege? “You’re so PC.” Every time I hear this one I automatically reframe the sentence in my head as: “I authorise myself not to be mindful about how what I say and how I say it impacts on others.” This rhetorical strategy is insidious. It loops any opposition back to silence, which will of course be automatically delegitimised because it is PC. “You’re disgusting.” This reveals more about the speaker than the person being addressed. “You’re such a kill-joy.” This is one of my personal faves. If I am a killjoy simply for pointing out that one person’s version of happiness doesn’t actually make me happy at all, or actively depends on my silence or oppression, then I am happy to own that! I am deeply suspicious of the ways in which expectations to be HAPPY all the time suffocate opposition and keep current power arrangements in place.
-
Straight Up | Issue 18
This week I’d planned out my column days in advance. I’d written it quickly – the time I had was squashed beneath piles of other things. When I returned to it today, I noticed something. My words were flat. The piece was stodgy, and I just wasn’t into it. I’d tried to write about something I felt was worthy, rather than something I was really engaged by. And it showed. So, I have shelved that other column and have decided to listen to my gut, and write about something that I can really connect to. This column is speaking not only to queer and trans folks, but to anyone who works on projects for social justice. It’s about self-care. Not so long ago, I was working on projects that were important to me. They were so important, I guess, that I acted as though they were more important than me. I became merely a vessel to carry out that kind of work. Often I’d work too hard, and I’d come home with no energy, fall asleep, wake up, and then keep going. I was really “productive”, if you measured this by the hours I worked. But this pattern of making change was really unproductive personally. It also meant that the quality of my work, the thoughtfulness that making change really requires, was lacking. I had a slow awakening that this model didn’t work for me. I realised that the important work I do around queer liberation is important because queer people are important. Queer people like me are important. And we are not important at some hypothetical moment in the future. We are important and gorgeous and fucking amazing, right now. For me, loving myself doesn’t mean I go and buy myself crap from a gift shop. This week I did lots of things that were self-loving. I did exercise, not because I want to lose weight, but because I enjoy the feeling of my body in movement. I ate good food, and didn’t count the calories I consumed, because I believe in nourishing my body. I went to therapy, yoga class, made a date with a friend, put on a facemask, and listened to Missy Elliot as I brushed my wigs. I did all this, ‘cause I am important. And as a side-effect I get myself in a better place to do more work. In a world that would prefer queer and trans people were quiet, invisible and/or dead, loving ourselves and practising self-care is more than a good idea. It’s fucking revolutionary.
-
Straight Up | Issue 16
Recent life experiences have taught me something interesting: Christchurch is the progressive centre of the South. It seems wherever I go these days Christchurchians go out of their way to welcome my return to our fair city with my favourite nom de slur: faggot. This word is routinely hiffed at me from speeding cars as I am walking alone at night, or even more delightfully out of an ugly Holden rolling past as my partner and I hold hands at the traffic lights, on his birthday. It often comes out slowly, like the speaker savours having my rude word all over his tongue (I say his, as I am yet to be addressed in this way in public by a woman). I am doing something right. Obviously my faggotry is flaming. There are two things I notice when people yell homophobic shit at me. The first I notice in myself. It is a feeling of fear mixed with defiance. I often respond by blowing kisses or giving the fingers, or both, if my partner doesn’t stop me. Yet inside I am shaken that my quiet Sunday stroll through the central city has been interrupted. I am afraid. What if they turn around and come back for us? My lover has had a full bottle of beer thrown at him in the past… I also notice the witnesses. The people who watch this verbal assault and act as though nothing happened. It is as if their day has not been affected one bit by our shared experience. Not once have I had a person wander over to check in about how I am feeling, or comment that the haters are douchebags. Often the cars are moving so fast that I can’t see their registration number (they’re so tough they have to speed away). But if you get a chance I suggest you note it down (this message is not only for queerbos, but everyone). The Police are interested in hearing about people being threatened, harassed or intimidated. Even if they don’t press charges, a phone call to the owner of the car might stop them doing it again. The thing is, I really like the word faggot. Not when it is spat at me by homophobes, but as a word I own and use for myself. The bestest thing, that makes me warm and gooey, is that when these dicks yell “faggot” at me they don’t know how right they are. Yours with unrepentant faggalicious excess,
-
Straight Up | Issue 15
“So, I always thought queer was a nasty word.” The well-meaning middle-aged cis-woman leans in, her head cocked to the left. “Can you explain it to me? What do you mean by queer?” She has a kind face, and her body language indicates she wants to listen. Often as a queer activist/educator I feel a pull, a responsibility, to spend time talking things through with people like her. But today I don’t. Sandwich in my hand, I am yet to eat my lunch. The room is crowded with people yarning, and I am tired after a day at a conference. Also, this question bores me. I must have answered it 458 times this year alone. I say, “Hey, cool you’re interested, sounds like you need to do some reading about it. I’m off-duty at the moment, but there are heaps of resources if you Google it”. I sip my tea and watch her face shift. I can see she is confused that I haven’t complied, hurt that I haven’t answered her seemingly simple question. She is possibly wondering why I am so mean and probably thinking I should be grateful that she’s asked me about a topic I am obviously invested in. She thought she was doing the right thing. A similar thing happened last week when I was contacted by a reporter and asked for comment. In spite of my ego, I said no. I said no because the story they wanted to tell and the story I wanted to tell were really different, and I didn’t trust they’d use my words appropriately. Even the most generous educators need to be selective about where they invest their energy. Personally, I’m trying not to get drawn into conversations that will be a lot of hard work and offer little in return. Why should I go through the hassle of educating you if I am not especially invested in our relationship? Sweet pea, please don’t mistake me for Wikipedia. I need to eat my lunch just like everyone else. And in advising this woman to do some research, I have already done half the work. Maybe when she has read something she can come back and we can have a more reciprocal and respectful conversation. Being picky about where I invest my energy is something I am learning to do. I think it is important to choose when to say “no”, “not today”, “not now”, and “maybe later once you have done some work of your own”.
-
Straight Up | Issue 14
In case you missed it, the big news this week was the launch of Rainbow Youth and Outline’s new campaign WTF, which stands for both “What The Fuck” and “Where’s The Funds”. If you haven’t checked it out already, you really should. WTF features a number of well-known New Zealanders, including – OMG! – Lucy Lawless, calling for wider reflection on the crap experienced by queer and trans folks. It asks for donations to help organisations deal with this problem more effectively. I know many of the people involved in producing the video, and want to thank them for all their hard work. At the time of writing the video had already received 71,000 views, and been covered in gay media worldwide. It has definitely succeeded at getting people yakking. The thing that irked me about the straight media coverage of WTF was the tendency to reduce hetero/cissexism to incidences of random street violence or similar, as though that is the main concern for queer/trans folks. For me, this violence is only symptomatic of a wider sick culture, which ultimately wants queer/trans kids and (gender)queerness in general to disappear. I would love it if the media would instead highlight the fact that it is our culture of heterosexism which needs to change, not just the thugs that exemplify it. That requires deep and sustained intervention in many spheres of life. In other news, Jim Parsons, that cute dork from The Big Bang Theory, came out. I get really annoyed by well-meaning heteros saying things like “Who cares if he is gay? It won’t stop me watching it!” Well… I CARE I CARE I CARE I CARE. I care because mainstream media provides precious little visibility of queer/trans folks, so when someone decides to make an announcement like that, it makes me a little bit happy. I get annoyed when cis-straight people say things like that, or the old chestnut: “I don’t see gender/sexuality. People are people.” Um, WTF. Yeah you do. We all do. Don’t tell me you don’t see me, and my gender-giftedness and lustiness. For me, what would be way cooler is if you would say something like: “Woah babe, I see your gender in all its glory, it is gorgeous and you are amazing!” What do you think of the WTF campaign or celebs coming out? Email me at dameladida@gmail.com. xox – Dame La Dida
-
Straight Up | Issue 13
If anyone has followed this column you will realise that it has been a rough time in my family of birth A family member has been very unwell, and I have become their primary carer. Throughout this time I have been thinking a lot about family, what it means to me – and what queer/trans folks have done to redecorate the concept of kinship. Alongside my family of birth, who live in Christchurch, I have queer kin of choice residing in many different countries. These are people who may have entered mine and my partner’s lives as friends, lovers, colleagues, acquaintances or co-conspirators - but now we have developed sustained and durable bonds that resemble family relations. Queer kin are my cousins, brothers, sisters, sister-brothers, mama’s and daddies. I have grandfolks, and aunties. My queer kin will make me an auncle (of furbabies or the furless kind). We might live together, holiday together, have children together, maybe even share accessories (you know I don’t share scarves with just anyone). When I am at the end of my life, I hope my Q Fam will be there with me, alongside my birth family. This is not unique to me and my Q Fam. Alternative models of kinship exist for many queer/trans folks. Sometimes they arise because of troubles within our birth families, from a lack of acceptance or understanding. Sometimes they are an act of survival – being together is the best way to navigate through a hostile world. For many of us these families aren’t a reaction to our families of birth, we develop queer families because they enrich our lives. Period. The thing I want to get across is – this is an active choice I have made: I am not interested in replicating the failed model of the precarious and isolated nuclear family. This model of creating a life doesn’t work for me, I want more. I guess queer kinship is something that cis-hetero’s could take from us queerbo’s – what possibilities for family relations exist outside of blood? Is it really your dream to emulate the kind of family relations you grew up with? Could you dream it otherwise? I guess in the end this column is a simple act of appreciation. Thank you to all of my family who have been here while times have been tough. – La Di Da
-
Straight Up | Issue 12
So Obama has outed himself as a supporter of marriage equality. I am not really queuing up to shake his hand for this. Really, that should have been a given, if there was to be any consistency with the rest of his message. I have written previously that gay marriage is not my priority – it is the most obvious (and in my opinion one of the least important) frontiers for change. I put my energy into trying to make sure I don’t attend another funeral for a dead queer person by improving access to, and outcomes in education, healthcare and social welfare. I see marriage as bound up with gaystream corporate and assimilationist agendas that make me sad. I see marriage as a site laden with the violence and oppression of children and women. And, while I’d love some of the benefits that marriage brings, I don’t understand why we in queer/trans movements would stop from demanding full citizenship for all (why should only married people be able to visit sick partners, adopt, split their incomes for tax purposes?). Is this really a priority? Who is left out? How much difference will a pretty tiered wedding cake make to homeless trans kids? I am happy to have the marriage “debate” – I just wish that there was some balance to it. Not all queer folks long for marriage – so balance doesn’t simply mean lining up a socially conservative right-winger, and a pro-marriage homo to have a predictable no/yes argument. One thing that sticks with me out of all this is the dominance of the US in the queer/trans cultural-political landscape. Often in Aotearoa we view the US as the centre – meanwhile remaining disconnected from important events in the majority world, or at home. I despair that in current gay marriage activism in New Zealand, organisations like “Legalise Love” make more reference to rights struggles in the United States than the examples the Māori civil, political and cultural rights struggles afford us. Rather than our own heroes it is characters like Harvey Milk, and scenes like Stonewall that hog the limelight. I find this a) boring, b) offensive and c) an opportunity missed. I find it sadder still that I myself can’t identify a whole swag of local queer/trans/takataapui heroes (even though I know they are out there). At the same time as Obama was making his (rather weak) comments, awesome news came from Argentina. Access to transition related healthcare became a human right. This is news I am excited by, and the kind of change I want to see more of. – La Di Da
-
Straight Up | Issue 11
My friend Sam had this awesome idea last year. Instead of buying decorations for his Christmas tree, he and his partner decided to make sparklies of their own. Rather than plastic angels and itchy tinsel, Sam created special queer/trans Christmas decorations. His Christmas tree kind of became a pine-scented altar to famous, and not-so-famous-but-inspirational queer/trans folks (and allies). I thought this was an excellent idea, and something that I could do with in my living room all year round (but pine trees are so messy…). So today I’d like to reflect on the figures who would make it as baubles on my own Chrissy tree. The first person who would definitely be there is Project Runway’s Tim Gunn. Oh Tim. Not only are your gorgeous suits irresistible – you give me strength by allowing me to bear witness to your gentle, caring, nice-smelling masculinity. I’d also include a contestant from last season – Mondo – because he is the most adorable human I have ever seen. The next person I think of is Oscar Wilde (played by Stephen Fry to catch two babes with one bauble). I was nourished on Oscar’s writing as I was growing up. He was the one queer author I could easily identify on our bookshelf at home. I carried around that book in my bag for years. In recent years Stephen has also made it onto the bookshelf. Next would be Missy Elliot. There is something irresistibly genderqueer about Missy. She would be a musical decoration, so every time someone moved nearby Get Ur Freak On would play. One whole branch of my tree would be taken up by thinkers like Kate Bornstein, Jack/Judith Halberstam, Judith Butler and Gloria Anzaldua; people who have prompted me to question, and ultimately change the ways I live my life and practice my politics. The angel at the top of my tree, in a glittery silver body suit (that she had to be sewn into) is Cher. A cliché I know, but I can’t think of any other queer icon/elder who would be more pissed off if she wasn’t on the top of the tree. I am intimidated by Cher. And I like it. I guess any exercise like this will always be a challenge – all of these people probably hold beliefs with which I would disagree. Still, for who and what they are they inspire me. – La Di Da
-
Straight Up | Issue 10
This week’s column is about Intersexions, a documentary that premiered in Auckland last week. The film is a collaboration between my dear friend Mani Mitchell and Mark Lahood. It shares the stories of a number of intersex folks across the world, interwoven with Mani’s story. Mani is a part of a generation of people who were non-consensually surgically and hormonally assigned after birth. Intersex is a composite term for over thirty conditions that originate pre-natally. In brief, an intersex person may have atypical chromosomes, genitals that are not typically assignable (inside or external), or sex development differences. Often intersex folks are left right at the end of the LGBTQQI… acronym – which is why I wanted to put them first today. It is estimated that there are over 2000 intersex New Zealanders. Many of them will have had surgeries as babies to ‘correct’ what are perceived by medical experts to be ‘abnormalities’. What this really amounts to is doctors deciding to make people who have different kinds of bodies/genitals ‘normal’. In most cases these procedures are performed at birth, but some have gone on throughout childhood. In some cases what we are talking about is simply a baby having a large clit, or a small penis (people with clit’s might agree, that having a bigger one could be rather excellent. Now imagine what it would be like if someone removed it from you without your consent.) It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that doctors taking it upon themselves to hack off parts of babies genitals is a bad idea. Many intersex people lost sensation in those parts altogether as a result of these surgeries. Others live with pain or incontinence. These procedures are now largely discredited. Intersex activists have argued these surgeries are more about assuaging the discomfort of society (is it a boy or a girl?) than that of intersex folks. Yet up to five nonconsensual surgeries still occur each day in the USA. If I am ever blessed to have a gorgeous intersex child, I will tell the doctors to leave it up to them to decide what they want to do with their body. Mani said it best, “whatever body I was born with can’t be shameful.” I know one thing for sure - you wont create a happy ‘normal’ child by mutilating their genitals. Finally, I want to shout out to Mani and all of the amazing intersex activists of the world, who are using their own often-painful herm-stories to make change. Xox (Herm is a personal pronoun some intersex people have adopted in order to make living as intersex visible). – Dame LaDida
-
Straight Up | Issue 9
Before anyone assumes anything. I am a (gender)queer guy who also loves vaginas. I think they are amazing and powerful. After all without the gifts of generations of women none of us would be here in the first place. I really hate the rubbish that some gay bois express around women’s bodies/people with vaginas. I have overheard/participated in horrific misogynistic conversations in my time. I can now clearly say that I think it is really important that as queer masculine people we step up and show that we have learned the lessons of our own struggles. The denigration of all bodies must stop. We must start by honouring the sacredness of everyone’s genitalia. (And FYI when I say everyone that means trans and intersex folks too.) Besides vaginas I love cocks and ears and fingers and arse-holes. I love that bit of your arm that is on the opposite side to your elbow. I love frenula and perieums. I love hairy bodies. I love the clothes that go on and come off bodies, the ways they are perfumed and cared for. I love sex toys and porn. I love gorgeous, generous plump bodies and currently am living with/loving a person with a hot skinny body. I love the transformative potentials of sex when we talk about it (or have it) publicly. Not being able to talk about sex in public can contribute to people feeling that the sexy things they do alone or together are shameful, embarrassing or unnatural. It can lead to certain people being left out of wider understandings of ‘being sexy’ or even possessing a sexuality altogether, like young people, and older people and people who live with disabilities. Not talking about sex and sexuality can lead to people making uninformed decisions about their bodies - whether this be decisions around their sexual health and reproduction, or around the kinds of relationships they do or don’t get into/out of. What I really want to do is shout, and sing and dance and celebrate all of the different bodies in the world, and the diverse ways that these bodies come together intimately and pleasurably. I want to celebrate the bodies that reproduce, and those that don’t. I want to honour the decisions of the people who have abortions, and those who don’t. I want to high-five the people who decide that sex is not for them, at this time, or into the future, and those who want to have it all the time. Most of all I want to fly a plane up into the sky over Dunedin on a clear and windless day and bomb this city with ‘love your body’ stickers and quality lubricant. Dame La Di Da
-
Straight Up | Issue 8
The last few months have been really stressful. I have been constantly worried about a member of my family who has been in and out of hospital since the end of 2011 suffering from chronic medical conditions as a result of her addiction to alcohol. I have been anxious – worried about how the rest of my family is coping. I have been worried about whether she is eating right, having showers, remembering to take her pills. I have been strategising with friends and family about how to encourage her to seek treatment, to get well. In the last two weeks I have moved from Dunedin to Christchurch, suspended my PhD, left behind my partner, my house, my jobs and my pets in order to help out my family. It has all been really, really hard. Last night she awoke from a nap with breathing difficulties. I took her directly into A & E. After checking in with the nurse we were ushered into the waiting room. She looked frail and unwell. She had forgotten her bottom false teeth giving her the appearance of someone defeated. I sat biting my lip, hoping they would let us see the doctors soon so she could lie down and rest, be looked after. As soon as we sat down I overheard the word “gay” being used lazily as a term of antipathy. The vending machine behind us was gay because it didn’t have many options. As was the amount of time they had been waiting… I am used to this. “Gay” has been a word that people have used to put me down since my childhood. It’s not a word I identify with myself, but it indexes some parts of me. Now, I am an adult who works as an activist and educator around gender and sexuality. I anticipate that people will often interrupt my enjoyment of public spaces in this way. I fantasise about responding sarcastically, and occasionally have, depending on how safe the situation feels. I guess most people experience waiting rooms as safe spaces; for me they are often spaces laden with fear and discomfort. How are people reading my queer body? Will they say something that makes me or the people I am waiting with feel afraid or uncomfortable? People using this language sensitises me to these feelings. To those of you who believe that saying “that’s so gay” (or colluding with others who do) is not homophobic, or doesn’t hurt people, I disagree. Last night such talk made a hard situation feel that much harder. Please, next time you hear someone use “that’s so gay” in this manner, do something about it. It shouldn’t always be up to queer folks. Say something like “that’s not ok”, or “can’t you find a more accurate word than that?” Your conversational activism might have a bigger impact on people like me than you think.
-
Straight Up | Issue 7
The questions I have been pondering this week are: To what extent is desire political? And what are the ethics of proclaiming desire? I am thinking about this with reference to online dating in particular, which is a super common way for queer folks to meet. It has been a while since I have forayed into Internet dating and unlike loads of people who write about it, I don’t want to hate on online loving. I actually think dating sites can be awesome ways to find hook-ups, friendship and love. What does concern me are my observations and experiences of prejudice on gay dating sites. The sad reality is that within the queer* community we often repeat the mistakes of our hetero cousins: Body and gender policing, ageism and racism to name a few. This issue has been prominent in the gay community in particular over the last year, partly due to a new blog (Douchebags of Grindr) that names and shames individual faggz on their prejudiced shit online. I am reluctant to proliferate this stuff, but it is important to know what we are talking about: “I’ve blocked more Asians than the Great Wall of China.” “Not into femmes, fatties and furballs.” “Vanilla and spice, no chocolate and rice.” From my perspective desire (and proclamations of desire) have political consequences and ethical obligations. Lots of us begin dating with narrow notions of who we’re into and who we’re not. Many of us find that these change over our lifetimes. Sometimes we need to do some personal work to better understand and question these prejudices. Basically babes, that means that it is not cool online (or anywhere else) to proclaim your preference to only fuck the skinny butches of the Aryan race. If you find yourself choosing sexual partners of a certain background, perhaps you could treat this as an invitation to ask yourself why. Where have your ideas about who is hot/not come from? Do they stand up to scrutiny? For those of you who are happy to keep on excluding people based on narrow criteria like cultural background, age or body shape – you should know that a lot of us find prejudice incredibly unattractive. Finally, in an exercise in positive discrimination: To old fat femme Asians – I think you are super hot. Feel free to sashay your pepper haired, limp-wristed, chub self over and flirt up a storm with me. Also feel free to send me sexy pics or free stuff to dameladida@gmail.com
-
Straight Up | Issue 6
“Queer” is often used as a composite term for sex, sexuality and gender non-normative communities in Aotearoa. It is commonly used as an alternative to “LGBT” in order to be more encompassing of identities/behaviours outside this acronym. Questions about queer often come up from both outside and within “queer/trans” communities. I thought I’d attend to some common ones from my experience. Why do we use the word “queer” when it has such a painful history? There are many answers to the question. One response is that using “queer” reclaims the power from those who might otherwise use it against us. By owning the word ourselves, we remove (most of) its sting. Now for some, the word “queer” is a term they associate with pride. This reclamation has been a part of a deliberate political struggle to find pride in identities/behaviours once associated with shame and pain. In a similar way some people have reclaimed words like slut, faggot, dyke and others. I’m gay and I hate the word “queer”! Fair enough. Many LGBT people do not identify with the word “queer”. For some the word is too confrontational or carries too much historical baggage to be recuperated. For others, they simply have another word that fits better. Unlike gay/lesbian, the word queer does not fix sexual identities. It appreciates that these may shift and change, or be complex and messy. Many gay/lesbian/bi people object to the anti-normal orientation of “queer” – seeking for their identity to be seen as “legitimate” like heterosexuality. Some trans people may not identify with the word “queer” at all, as they experience their sexuality as straight. Can queer be an identity in itself? Yep. A number of people don’t only use “queer” as an umbrella term, and actively identify their sexualities as queer. For some of us this means that our sexuality leaks out of the boxes of “straight”, “gay”, “bi” or “lesbian”. For instance, how might someone explain fucking men, women, transmen and genderqueers? Or a woman who has been in relationships with women for 30 years but falls in love with a man? Identifying as queer allows these people to register their more complex realities of living and loving. The most important point is, assume nothing. Some people might love using queer, others might hate it. It always pays to ask.
-
Straight Up | Issue 5
In case you missed it, this week’s NZ trans-queer news was over the “glitter bombing” of feminist writer and commentator Germaine Greer. The action was undertaken once again by the Wellington-based Queer Avengers, who tipped glitter all over the seated septuagenarian, who appeared stunned in the photos taken afterwards. The “bombing” was in response to comments Greer has made as recently as 2009 about the “delusion” of trans women who she stated, “seem to … be some kind of ghastly parody, though it isn’t polite to say so”. Greer’s comments are a part of a wider picture, a hardy strand of transphobic feminism that has been rooted in place for decades. Feminists like Greer refuse to acknowledge that trans women – women who were assigned as male at birth, but have since transitioned – are women. I agree with the avengers, transphobic feminists seem to have failed to learn the lessons of their own struggle. Really transphobic feminism is at its best when it is being deconstructed in feminist theory textbooks. If I am honest though, I remain uncomfortable about bombing of any kind. Part of me would prefer to talk (even with the obtuse and intransigent) at all times. There is something in holding to a process even as we agitate for change. Perhaps we could find common ground, or at least agree to disagree, but make sure that Greer appreciates the harm her comments cause, to (trans)feminism(s). On the other hand, a quick sprinkling by the glitter fairies delivers a shock to Greer, and draws mass media attention to the issues that trans women across Aotearoa continue to negotiate. It doesn’t cause any permanent damage, and definitely improved Greer’s drab outfit. On balance, I think I side with the bombers, but continue to hold my discomfort. While Germaine Greer does contribute to the negative climate of hate and misinformation that exists around trans people, for me a more pressing issue that has come up recently is the experience of trans folks in NZ prisons. I went to a prison lately to do some education work, and was shocked by what I heard. Ladies – imagine for one moment being put in a men’s prison, strip-searched by male guards, subject to harassment and sexual assault by fellow inmates, continually referred to using the incorrect pronoun “he”. There has been a petition going around about this issue – I encourage you to sign it. If nothing comes of the petition, perhaps Minister of Corrections Anne Tolley could be the next target for some glittery action?
-
Straight Up | Issue 4
Hey Hetero, try harder! I have done loads of sexuality/gender identity awareness trainings in my time. Unfortunately they are often repackaged as “diversity” training because some people find sexuality/gender identity too embarrassing or political to say. Fact is, sunshine, when I do workshops I am explicitly talking about queers and trans folks, and our issues. Many of us (read: queer/trans people) get pissed off with this burying of queer/trans experience under the bland word “diversity”. This strategy of making queer/trans education palatable for hetero consumption is risky. It evades confrontation and erases the specificity of queer/trans experience, making us just one of many cultural groups who should now be “celebrated” for the differences and “colour” we add to white bread heterosex-ciety. This is tokenism and it gets us nowhere. Secondly, people underestimate how challenging this training can be to run. It is actually really hard to stand up in front of a bunch of strangers and come out over and over again. To talk about your painful experiences, and get nothing back. Then, following that discomfort, you open yourself up to a myriad of questions, some of which cross the border into offensiveness. The fact is I don’t enjoy doing queer/trans awareness training. I am called to do them because the alternative (no training) is worse. Please don’t tell me I am “brave” for being open about myself. I am not brave; I am generous and hopeful, or angry and anxious to make change. The thing that really gets me is when the audience just wants to play with new words. They act like cats with a dead bird, batting it around the room. It is as if my identity, and those of my communities, is the latest curio to add to your vocabulary. In my recent workshops I have stated that that just knowing words is not enough. When we go over labels in gratuitous detail we don’t have enough time to get to the actual point of the workshop: how cis-heteros need to appreciate some uncomfortable realities, and make changes in their own lives, communities and work-spheres. So hetero, next time you go to a queer/trans awareness training, try harder! How about you take note of the words you don’t know, and go Google them later. Better still, how about you focus on the issue at the core of the workshop: How you are going to change and act as an ally for us in making the world a more inclusive and fabulous place.
-
Straight Up | Issue 3
Oh that’s it. (Cracks knuckles, removes rings). I’m mad. This piece is in solidarity with the Wellington based group the Queer Avengers who protested outside the Dominion Post Wellington offices last week. Their protest was organised in response to an article “Why I feel for the kids of ego-trippers” written by columnist Rosemary McLeod. I know, I know. Haters gonna hate. But I expected more of Rosemary, she has ice cool hair and collects vintage linen. I thought she would be a total (trans)fag hag and up with all of this stuff. But alas, no. Boiling it down the article is an exercise in meanness and ignorance directed toward trans people. McLeod herself admits she is a “bit lost” in this territory. Next time she wanders into queer/trans issues, I suggest she brings a map, or at least consults a local. Throughout her article, McLeod continually imprisons the masculinity of the trans man she peaks of (who has just given birth) within quote marks. That is rude, and mean. I do not want to give her shitty article a profile it doesn’t deserve, but I will respond to some of the most offensive parts to stop the rot her article spreads. The most obvious stuff. A trans man is someone who was assigned female at birth and has since transitioned. He may have surgery, or undergo hormone treatments, or not. He may start playing rugby or become a ballerino, or not. He may be queer or straight, or bi, or asexual, or any other sexual orientation. It is not OK to purposefully use incorrect pronouns for a transman. The correct pronoun is he not he/she. Most reasonable people can work out that you refer to people in the ways in which they want to be seen in the world. It is not OK to speak about a trans persons genitals as a “penis thingy”. It is not OK to tell someone what their gender identity really is, as if you could ever know this better than they do themselves. It is not OK to assume that when transmen give birth they are simply doing so to become famous. Shocking as it may seem some queers and trans folk simply want to reproduce. Our fertility is really none of your business. I have lots of insults I have been storing up to spit at you Rosemary. But I have decided not to print them. I will end this article with grace and dignity – something you denied the trans folk in your article.
-
Straight Up | Issue 2
I have been up in Auckland for the last couple of weeks, which has been sunny and fabulous. I managed to head to the Big Gay Out, which was cool despite the inclement weather, and the fact that John Key was voted sexiest male politician. That poll must be rigged, cause John Key rates below zero on my sex appeal radar. Give me Gareth Hughes any day, or even David Parker, who seems to have a cheeky side and twinkly eyes. Jacinda Adern was crowned sexiest female, but I would have gone with Maryan Street – she has that hot silver-haired dominatrix thing going on. But I digress. My most memorable moment was my cheek-to-cheek kiss malfunction with a gay politician – where we each got half a mouth (I think?). This left me simultaneously dizzy, turned on and mortified for the rest of the day. I also got to check out Queerlesque at DNA, which was an awesome celebration of queer bodies in performance – something that we don’t get to see enough of in Dunedin. My main reason for heading up to Auckland was to help host the first ever Queers in Tertiary Education Hui. It brought together around fifty educators, community leaders and students to discuss the concerns facing queer and trans folk in higher education in NZ. What was most heartening was the national interest in what we do here at Otago. Our campus is the only one nationwide to have a paid staff member providing information and support for queer and trans students. Hopefully this absence will not last too much longer, with staff from Auckland, Victoria and Canterbury preparing the groundwork for similar services in their institutions. Ultimately our vision is to have a network of queer/trans resource centres across the country that can provide support and information for queer and trans students and staff, as well as advance campaigns for our communities. The value of services like these is that with a little they always do a lot. Queer support, for example, reaches out to hundreds of students at Otago every year despite its modest budget. If you want to chat about this further do contact me at dameladida@gmail.com. For general social enquiries contact uniqotago@gmail.com, and for support and information contact Neill and Jamie at OUSA Queer Support at q.support@ousa.org.nz
-
Straight Up
So, the first queer column of 2012 is about marriage. No surprise there. The happy dyad of gay marriage and adoption reform seem to dominate queer media, community and social spaces at the moment. I hear it all the time: “gay marriage is the next step/last frontier”, “it’s the rights issue of our time”. Bullshit. That’s the thing about marriage – it is so gay. It is the issue of white fags and dykes who crave the status and privileges of cis-heteros. It comes at the expense of the concerns of oppressed queer and trans people who are occupied with trying to make liveable lives for themselves and others. For me, marriage doesn’t even make it on to the “top 100 issues for social change” list (which I am happy to share should you be interested). Why would we, as a broad queer and trans community, dream of focusing so much energy on the tacky plastic bauble of marriage when so much of the potential of queerness is in troubling the state and how it defines/controls with whom we love, live and fuck? If we do want to talk about legislative change why aren’t we talking about including trans people in the Human Rights Act? If we want to talk about serious issues why don’t we talk about rape culture? Or body fascism and fat phobia? Or the economic exclusion of poor queers? Why don’t we talk about the harms of alcohol abuse and drug dependencies within our communities? Why don’t we talk about how sometimes it is fucking hard to be queer, trans, takataapui, genderqueer, mahu, vakasalewalewa, palopa, fa’afafine, akava’ine, fakaleiti, or fakafifine. That shame doesn’t neatly translate into pride. That sometimes we hate ourselves and hate our bodies – and that this is not OK and needs to change. Darling fagglings, you can have your marriage – it’s just called a civil union – be creative with it. Girl, if you want to get dressed up in white, have a big cake and live the Hetero dream like mummy and daddy, by all means do it. Just don’t talk to me about it. I have more important things to do. And don’t speak on my behalf telling others that this is really all queer folk want. I can speak for myself. And I want much more.