Carys Goodwin
Politics Editor
Articles by Carys Goodwin
89 articles found. Displaying page 8 of 8.
-
NewsIssue 4 16/03/2014
Greatest Hits / Greatest Shits | Issue 04
Greatest HitsIt was very tempting to award Greatest Hit to John Key for choosing 20 September as the election date, as a few Critic staff were recipients of healthy iPredict payouts (myself included); but in the interest of providing students with something a little better than “should’ve got on the insider trading buzz,” the award goes elsewhere. It’s therefore not the man in blue who gets the prize; it’s the idea of a blue zone. Over the weekend, the Greens proposed that the Government set up a blue zone in Christchurch to allow homeowners of flood-damaged properties to get the hell out. Based on the red zone, the $140 million idea is one that would help the poor citizens of Christchurch deal with this latest setback. Notable mention: the Baywatch-style shot of David Shearer and his dog during Paul Henry’s MP pet therapy segment. Greatest ShitsIt seems it only took two days for the Beehive to kick-start the election drama, and while much of it was shit-worthy, there is one particular instance that undoubtedly takes the Greatest Shit cake: milkgate. It was revealed that Judith Collins, our ever eloquent and graceful Justice Minister, took an “official trip” to China with her husband and had dinner with a few too many Chinese big shots. Costing over $30,000 in taxpayer money, this conflict of interest resulted in a snap debate in the House on Wednesday. Highlights include classic Winston racism and Gareth Hughes insinuating that Collins is “rancid milk.” John Key is “disappointed,” and while at the time of writing Judith has not yet resigned, there is still time.
-
News
Issue 4 16/03/2014Critic tackles election year | Issue 04
Finally, the election date has been announced: 20 September. Bring on the policy releases, campaign ads, catchy slogans, and the inevitable rhetorical fuck-ups. It’s time to cut through the empty statements about student support and “the best education ever” and see what’s actually in writing. This week? Student loans and allowances organised from “most support” to “least support” (support being a financial composite of both fees and the funding we currently call living costs). For brevity’s sake, the parties included are the eight currently in government, but if you know of another party that has a stellar education policy (or disagree with my interpretation), feel free to write an angry letter or direct a passive-aggressive tweet in my direction. Green PartyWhat’s the story? The Green Party’s policy framework surrounding student financing is, unequivocally, the most comprehensive. So much so, in fact, that it has its own dedicated policy document accessible exclusive of tertiary education. There are three main tracks outlined relevant to this week: a debt write-off scheme that trades a year of full-time work for a year of debt dissolved; a universal student allowance with a step-by-step plan on how to achieve this; and a fee-free tertiary education system. (All the while, current loans will still be interest-free and a higher repayment threshold will be implemented). Pro, in a nutshell: If you’re looking for a party that aims to support your education, this is the one. The Greens want to make your learning and living free. Con, in a nutshell: There are questions that must be raised about feasibility. First, there would need to be a serious reshuffling of government funding; second, it would take longer than one election cycle to institute the level of overhaul required; third, the Greens would need to be a major party in the first place. Overall: Great policy, difficult to implement. 8/10 Maori PartyWhat’s the story? Like the Greens, the Māori Party place a huge emphasis on reasonably priced education. They propose reducing fees to a “nominal level;” a universal student allowance; and that student loan repayments only must be repaid after five years and once you earn 1.5x the average wage. They will still be interest-free. Pro, in a nutshell: The Māori Party is dedicated to keeping education affordable. Con, in a nutshell: It’s not as comprehensive as the Greens and it does not specify an action plan in order to get there. Overall: Good, supportive policy, but no plan on how to implement. 7/10 MANA PartyWhat’s the story? The MANA Party is committed to the transition from tertiary education to job creation, as well as enfranchising Māori youth. In terms of policy, while they focus on these main aspects, they do propose to reduce and remove all tertiary fees. No explicit mention of adjustment to the current allowance/living costs loan scheme. Pro, in a nutshell: They want free education. Con, in a nutshell: Unclear whether they support a universal student allowance or not. Overall: Clearly supportive of students and community, but financial support not explicit. 6.5/10 Labour PartyWhat’s the story? There’s one thing more “tricky” than David Cunliffe, and that’s the Labour website. By navigating past the “Are You In” title page and hunting within the various tabs until I finally landed on “resources,” I managed to find Labour’s latest Policy Platform. It does reference education, but largely it’s just positive rhetoric, and doesn’t make explicit reference to loans and allowances. Being a major party, this is a bit of a concern. Pro, in a nutshell: The rhetoric is positive. It talks of reducing inequalities and affordability, which seems to be a good direction. Con, in a nutshell: Where’s the detail? Let’s hope a tertiary policy package is next on the release list, because currently there is little to nothing for us to sink our teeth into. Overall: Labour’s website is impossible to navigate, and Cunliffe’s voice whispering “Are You In?” will haunt my dreams. 5.5/10 National PartyWhat’s the story? Even though National’s website is better than Labour’s, their policies are still available by clicking on hilarious ClipArt-meets-PowerPoint buttons. At least their PDFs are easy to find. The tertiary policy document, rather than echoing the rhetoric of the above parties, scarily speaks of “value for money” and “accountability” – as though students are commodities. Interestingly, the document is largely in the past tense, and it brings to light all of National’s current achievements. I won’t repeat the overhaul details, as they’ve been heavily discussed since Steve Joyce had his way, but National is proud of enhancing borrower responsibility. Unfortunately, the structure of this scheme means many fall through the cracks – mostly postgrads. Pro, in a nutshell: They want to tackle student loan debt, and have been active in finding ways to chase up ex-students both domestically and overseas. They also pledge to keep student loans interest-free. Con, in a nutshell: If you require considerable financial support, this is the party that plans to strip it down. Overall: Plans to make students accountable, but is heading in the direction of less financial support. 4/10 ACT PartyWhat’s the story? Well, they talk of education, but not about tertiary. Rather, they enter into the nebulous world of non-government organised education, which sends warning bells on the financial front. We’ll have to wait to see if this develops. Pro, in a nutshell: Their education page exists. Con, in a nutshell: It says nothing about tertiary education. Overall: Forgotten by ACT. 2/10 NZFirst PartyWhat’s the story? Nothing. There is literally nothing. Pro, in a nutshell: The webpage exists, and is accessible via search: http://nzfirst.org.nz/policy/tertiary-education Con, in a nutshell: There’s nothing on it. Overall: Nothing. -/10 United Future PartyWhat’s the story? More nothing. Currently United Future is revising their policies. Pro in a nutshell: There is a subheading titled “Tertiary” and another with “Funding and Achievement,” so there’s that. Con in a nutshell: Nothing to work with. Overall: Nothing. -/10
-
NewsIssue 3 09/03/2014
Greatest Hits / Greatest Shits | Issue 03
Greatest HitSometimes it’s easy to get so caught up in the humdrum of menial political drama that we forget we don’t actually live in a hilarious equilibrium of MP DJs (looking at you, Jacinda) and in-the-house banter. We do have a global context, and we have a proud history of attempting to stand up for the little guy. In recognition of this, the first Greatest Hit goes to Parliament’s unanimous support of Murray McCully’s motion to “express deep concern at the Russian Federation’s violation of Ukrainian sovereignty and territorial integrity.” As the potentially disastrous situation unfolds, it’s good to know our Parliament recognises the need to give support, even if only in words. Greatest ShitChoosing a very first Greatest Shit was a challenge, as New Zealand politics has been particularly fun-filled this past week. We’ve seen the NZ Taxpayers Union accuse Mojo Mathers of wasting taxpayer money (she attended an interview in person because she’s deaf); Judith Collins had her antics in China questioned; and Cunliffe came under the spotlight for his secretive trust funds. While all of these were hot contenders, the winner comes in the form of Clare Curran. The Labour MP accidentally emailed a confidential set of policy documents to National’s Amy Adams (although it was later revealed that apparently a staffer made the mistake). The documents included proposed Internet caps, a Digital Bill of Rights, and a plethora of Kiwi-prefixed plans that are largely uninteresting if not for proving the longevity of National’s ‘Iwi/Kiwi’ campaign. Amy had apparently been accidentally included before, commenting “they invited me to a strategy session just after Mr Cunliffe became leader so I'm starting to get a complex.” Looks like the GCSB won’t end up having much of a job if Clare keeps at it.
-
News
Issue 3 09/03/2014Critic tackles election year | Issue 03
As I'm sure you all know, or at least have realised from the sharp increase in red, green, and blue-clad Tent City occupiers, it's election year – and a particularly important one at that. Our current Government has often been accused of overlooking student issues, and whether you agree with this or vehemently support any reforms, it's important to get involved and make your choice known. Thus, Critic presents a page of political coverage, designed to give you guys bite-sized pieces of political fuckery every week and help you make your decision before you hit up the polling booth. National Party: Michael WoodhouseQ1: What’s the one main thing you want to do for students? I want every student to have the best experience from their time at Otago. This is not just about learning but includes connection with the city, good health, accommodation and transport, etc. All MPs, list and electorate, can assist when there are difficulties and I enjoy my regular contact with students even when their issues are challenging. Q2: Why is this going to be good for students? The better students’ experience at Otago is, the more value they will get from their (and the taxpayers’) investment in their education. That must be good for both students and New Zealand. Q3: If you were stranded on a desert island and allowed the company of one member of the opposition, who would you choose? I’d want the MP to be with a bit of a “MacGyver” (students probably don’t know this character so the modern equivalent would be Bear Grylls). Eric Roy would be the obvious choice but he’s a National MP. I’d go for Te Ururoa Flavell. Good company and knows how to build a bivouac and catch a fish or two. Q4: We can't help our love for Shoot Shag Marry, but in light of potentially compromising responses we've devised a parliamentary alternative. So: reject, (re)elect, realign? Who do you want gone, who do you want in parliament, and who do you think is in completely the wrong party? Your choices are Winston Peters, Peter Dunne, and Colin Craig. They’re all centre/right MPs – not fair! I’ll exercise my freedom of choice and say: Gone – Hone Harawira. No good will ever come of his politics; In – Ritchie McCaw. We need a loose forward for the Parliamentary rugby team. Wrong party – definitely Shane Jones. I reckon he regrets not going with the Blue team when he started out in politics. Q5: Give us a snappy one-liner for our Twitter-happy readers? Is David Cunliffe in deep cover for the National Party? Green Party: Metiria TureiQ1: What’s the one main thing you want to do for students? Make sure that all students have enough to live on while they’re studying through a universal student allowance. Q2: Why is this going to be good for students? It means that students can actually focus on studying, rather than the stress of trying to make ends meet. Lack of financial support is one of the biggest barriers to people studying, so a universal student allowance would also open the door for many students who wouldn’t otherwise see tertiary education as an option. Q3: If you were stranded on a desert island and allowed the company of one member of the opposition, who would you choose? Louisa Wall: it’s hard ‘cause there are a bunch of Labour women that I love hanging out with, but I reckon if anyone could build us a boat and row us off the island, she could. And she’s bloody funny. Q4: We can't help our love for Shoot Shag Marry, but in light of potentially compromising responses we've devised a parliamentary alternative. So: reject, (re)elect, realign? Who do you want gone, who do you want in parliament, and who do you think is in completely the wrong party? Your choices are Winston Peters, Peter Dunne, and Colin Craig. Reject: Colin, (re)elect: Winston, realign: Peter Q5: Give us a snappy one-liner for our Twitter-happy readers? Critic, come back here and tidy this bloody room! Freakin’ kids, making a mess, drinking my beer, yous got no damn respect! Labour Party: David ClarkQ1: What’s the one main thing you want to do for students? Ensure that tertiary education is as affordable for anyone who aspires to graduate with a university degree. Q2: Why is this going to be good for students? The 23 per cent drop in the number of students claiming a student allowance in Dunedin this year shows that the Government's policies are pricing New Zealanders out of education. Post-graduate students are no longer eligible to receive a student allowance, nor are students studying towards a degree that takes over 200 weeks to complete. The policy has a dramatic effect on students aspiring to be our next generation of doctors, teachers, researchers and other professionals. Couple this with the fact that there are few jobs available for students, and we see many simply cannot attend university because of their financial situation. This is unacceptable to me. Education must be accessible; students shouldn’t be spiralling into debt just to afford the basics of life. Making education access equitable is important because it is important every New Zealander has opportunity to better their lot, and the lot of people they care for. Q3: If you were stranded on a desert island and allowed the company of one member of the opposition, whom would you choose? Maurice Williamson. Thoughtful, if random, he would be entertaining company. He has more personality than the entire National Front Bench combined. Who knows, we may prosper if he finds the ever-elusive pot of gold at the foot of a big gay rainbow. Q4: We can't help our love for Shoot Shag Marry, but in light of potentially compromising responses we've devised a parliamentary alternative. So: reject, (re)elect, realign? Who do you want gone, who do you want in parliament, and who do you think is in completely the wrong party? Your choices are Winston Peters, Peter Dunne, and Colin Craig. Reject: Colin Craig. Conspiracy theorists and ultra-right-wing special interest groups have no place in NZ politics. (Re)elect: Winston Peters. In most instances, despite flourishes of rhetoric, he does the right thing. He also knows how to laugh at himself – a commodity all too rare in politics. Realign: Peter Dunne. Why not? It’s happened plenty of times before. With more positions on most issues than the Karma Sutra, the perennial man of rubber could surely survive another re-tread. Q5: Give us a snappy one-liner for our Twitter-happy readers? Failed vet Steven Joyce is trying to silence student voice on Uni Councils. #LabourWillGiveYouYourVoiceBack @CriticTeArohi @DavidClarkNZ
-
Features
Issue 10 05/05/2013The Boston Marathon
University of Otago student Carys Goodwin is on exchange at Boston College. In true Otago style, she was engaging in some mid-afternoon drinking when she heard about the bombings just five miles away. She gives a first-hand account of the aftermath. It was my mum who first informed me about the Boston bombings. At first her vague but frantic text had me confused, as I wasn’t sure my day-drinking habits warranted quite that much concern; but after loudly asking the people around me what had happened, it came to light that “oh there was an explosion at the finish line.” The flippancy with which it was said meant that most continued knocking back their afternoon PBRs, and after a few minutes there was an intense frisbee game being played outside to the croaky wailing of Adele. Not being one for extreme sports, I took to my iPhone and began to browse news headlines. For lack of a non-clichéd expression, my stomach dropped. At that stage, the New York Post was falsely reporting that 12 people had died, and amid a flurry of Facebook messages from people checking I was still alive I expressed to my friends something along the lines of “shit guys, this is real serious.” We halted. The music cut off, as the owner of the phone struggled to get through to his dad in Australia; a girl nearby burst into tears; and I texted everyone I knew with friends or family nearby. It’s often pointed out that people of our generation can be with a group of people and still be glued to their phones – but in a crisis, it is invaluable to be able to contact everyone instantly. I can’t imagine the fear of those who couldn’t get through to their loved ones due to network difficulties. The party died fairly quickly, and I joined one of the last groups to wander through the eerily empty school before it was put on lockdown. Shivering from a combination of fear, sudden sobriety, and cold, we took refuge in a hall of residence and crammed too many people around the TV. It was the first footage I’d seen, and it was shocking; I had walked past the Walgreens from one of the most widely-shared videos just two days prior, happily examining a free hummus sample and thinking about where I could buy a new pair of jandals for the summer. That sort of familiarity is not something I’ve experienced in a crisis, and it’s not comfortable. We couldn’t watch the news for long, as I think we all felt an urge to be safe in our flats, so we left, taking the least crowded way home. Although I knew my flatmates were safe, it was still a relief to see them in their normal places, all with that dizzying not-quite-drunk-but-can’t-be-sober demeanour as we discussed the events. Obama came on at 6:10pm, and while the authorities clearly had no idea what had happened, I liked knowing that the White House was thinking about us. The evening was spent reading the news, Facebook, Twitter, and any form of social media that would provide something fresh for me to absorb. It wasn’t the end to the day I’d expected, but my flatmates quietly decided that even though it ended in tragedy, “this was the best Marathon Monday ever.” Through wide eyes and constant checking of our closed road, we gave each other a run-down of the day’s antics, having been split up after our third party. Boston College, you see, sits on the twenty-first mile, and Marathon Monday is the biggest drinking event of the BC year. Taking place on Patriot Day, it’s a chance to excessively celebrate Freedom! with 9am shots of the world’s worst vodka in as many pieces of fluoro Nike apparel as you can acquire. It has the same anticipation as Hyde Street, and the same convergence of thousands of drunk students on one street. Imagine a Hydelanders after-party, then imagine a bomb going off on George. It’s the closest comparison I can make, and I was lucky not to know anyone injured or affected strongly by the blasts. But there were rumours and stories, warnings and conspiracies, messages and emails. I knew people who knew people, and it was enough for the atmosphere to be tense and sombre. A few comments in particular stuck with me. There was the classmate of mine, who was scared for a friend she couldn’t get hold of, and told me, “it was really not real. I threw up a couple of times before we found out he was safe. Everything was like a movie. When he finally called, it was ‘I love you I love you I love you,’ but it wasn’t even relief, it was more like everything was so surreal still that it didn’t register until I saw him a couple of days later.” Then there was my flatmate, who when an aerial-view map appeared on the TV, pointed to a building and said mildly, “my mom works there.” And the Irish exchange student who ran the marathon and, if it weren’t for an old knee injury, would have been in the immediate vicinity. This is the second time I’ve really realised the gravity of living in the strongest, most politically targeted country in the world; the first was when North Korea had a hissy fit. What it feels like is an almost ineffable sense of doom. It’s not quite strong enough to be fear, but more jarring than discomfort. It is not a feeling I’ve ever had back home. The response has been interesting. Of course, this being the USA, there is the inevitable horror of racist retaliation. The story of the Saudi student tackled to the ground in the immediate aftermath of the bomb; the worrying email sent to all BC exchange students expressing support for those feeling targeted. It was a relief to find that the suspects weren’t Middle Eastern extremists, because the backlash to the wider community would have been disgusting. However, there was an incredible amount of good to outweigh the bad. Boston College itself had a bit of limelight, as its church, St Ignatius, opened its arms in true Jesuit fashion to the runners diverted from the race. There was also a Facebook event planned called “The Last Five Miles,” during which people would walk from BC to the finish line. Unfortunately it was unable to take place, as there was concern the city would not be able to handle the 12,000 people who clicked attending. One initiative I particularly liked was in response to the Muslim backlash – a banner hanging in the quad saying “Don’t meet hurt with hate – love Islam.” BC has undoubtedly been a tower of strength, balancing appropriate urgency with an outpouring of support for those involved; a real sense of community that represents the student solidarity I know and love at Otago. The Watertown shootout, and the events that transpired, were almost a relief. To be fair, I was busy making my way to Coachella Music Festival in California (shameless boasting here), but I was glued to the Internet waiting for updates as we set up our tents. The sense of finality with the capture, and the lifting of another BC lockdown, left students with such a reprieve from fear that there was a massive on-campus party. It’s those celebrations, and the huge number of Instagram #wearebc #bostonstrong pictures, that are what I wish I could end this story with. But I can’t, because the reports haven’t stopped. Despite the realisation that it’s often attention that leads psychopaths to go on killing sprees, the media is now turning its focus to the men behind the crimes. I’ve learnt more about them than I would ever wish to, heard more speculation about their motives and drive than could possibly be necessary. The media has been flooded with anecdotes and pictures, with John Kerry speaking about the younger brother’s trip to Russia and a friend claiming “he was such a good person” on a Wednesday night-time news show. It’s over, but I wish it would be let go. Remember Martin and the other dead; remember Carlos and the double amputee Jeff. Share the anecdotes and recoveries and experiences, and share the pictures of people as they start to smile again. But don’t remember the killers, and don’t share their stories. They don’t deserve it.