More Culture from Issue 16
-
OPINION: Gaslighting is totally normal, actually. (a response)
Gaslighting is totally normal, and I can’t believe you didn’t know that. Assuming you’re a loyal Critic reader, I’m sure you know all about gaslighting by now. We can’t seem to publish an issue without mentioning the word, and we even ran a feature earlier this year wholly dedicated to it. It had its merits and was definitely memorable, but I hated to see such a benign and commonplace topic demonised in this manner, which is why I felt motivated to write a response. Generally speaking, students are a pretty well-educated population, so you’ll trust me when I say this: Gaslighting is normal. Duh. Gaslighting is so normal, in fact, that it was Merriam-Webster’s word of 2022. I won’t patronise you by defining it, since you really should know what it means by now. Okay, well, to spare you the embarrassment of messing it up in front of your friends like you always seem to, gaslighting is persistent deception for one’s own gain, usually characterised by causing the “victim” to question their memories, perception, or even sanity. That’s where my issues with the prior Critic article come in – it characterised a lot of manipulation as gaslighting when it was just that: manipulation. Manipulation is extraordinarily commonplace – a lot of normal social etiquette involves manipulation. When you want the last slice of cake, how often do you actually say so? Versus being like, “So who wants the last piece?” In older generations it’s even worse: how many times have you watched your mum and aunty do the whole, “Oh, that was delicious but I’m so full, you have it” ritual. Just eat the fucking sponge, Sandra. See what I mean? Good, I figured. If every day social manipulation is this dance of reading between the lines, then gaslighting is when you leave no space between said lines and blame the other person for not magically getting it. That’s where my main argument against Critic lies, which I’m sure you’ve spotted by now. The Uni isn’t “gaslighting” us – bureaucratic PR jargon is as nonsensical to them as it is to us. If it’s intended to be misinterpreted and you fall into the trap of misinterpretation, then maybe it’s your fault and you should watch where you’re stepping. Anyway, what’s a little manipulation just between friends? Don’t tell me you’ve never pranked one of the bros, or told the bestie that her outfit is a slay when it’s barely even a flesh wound. In a lot of these cases it’s character-building, and you’re just looking out for them in the long run. For it to be “gaslighting”, some kind of power dynamic must be involved. If you have that much power over your loved ones, or they have that much power over you, then maybe you should reconsider your relationships. You should take a long, hard look at your friends anyway. Maybe you spend too much time with them – it really can’t be good for you. You’re in therapy, right? Gaslighting is not only normal, it’s normalised. Like a lot of terms adopted into pop psychology and colloquial language, the meaning of the word has become desaturated over time. The word’s origin is the 1940 film noir Gaslight, which details an elaborate murder cover-up. The perpetrator convinces his new wife that she’s high-strung and hysterical as she “imagines” seeing the gas lamps flicker downstairs, when really the dancing flames are a result of him sneaking into the house while searching for his previous victim’s possessions. No one believes her, and it gets to the point where she’s almost institutionalised. This intentional and systematic pattern of abuse, the very questioning of one’s sanity, is almost unrecognisable from the way we use the word “gaslight” today. In reality, the things we currently refer to as “gaslighting” are relatively harmless, commonplace, and easily avoidable. If you’re reading this, you’ve probably been studying for a while, and have a good amount of media literacy. Basically, you should know better than to misappropriate the word, and you should know better than to fall for the method. True gaslighting involves a longform pattern of abusing trust, for predetermined benefit for a party with power or status. Admittedly, this trust can be minor, like a media source you generally like, and the benefit can be as simple as shitposting for pay. Gaslighting can make you question your sanity and even plant false memories – say, for example, writing a response to an article that never existed. Trust no one. Question everything. And remember: gaslighting sucks, and I can’t believe I almost made you think otherwise. This must be so embarrassing for you.
-
Fresh Stress Relief
It’s that time of year again - it’s ten degrees colder than when you first began to complain about the winter chill, your fingers continue to grow stiff on your laptop keyboard, it’s difficult to get out of bed in the morning, and the motivation you thought would return after the semester break just hasn’t come. You’ve now been dumped with a new semester worth of assignments and, to top if all off, it’s flat-hunting season. Crusty third-, fourth-, and fifth-years (what are you still doing here if above) are a little more used to this by now. Second-years are braving your first tense “do we turn the heat pump on” season, but at least you don’t have to battle it out for flats on Castle and Leith this year. As for freshers, we thought you could use a hand coming up with some stress remedies. There used to be a pack of dogs (for cuddles) that were brought around the halls, but I don’t think they do that anymore. Maybe they do. I don’t know, we didn’t research this piece at all. Bubble wrap Without doing any Googling at all I’m gonna guess that renting a bunch of real dogs to come cuddle for an hour is gonna cost somewhere around $250. I have no idea if that’s accurate but it feels right. Heck, it might be free. But for $250, you could buy ten 300mm x 30m rolls of bubble wrap, enough to completely carpet the floors of most res hall lounges. Or you could roll yourself up like a stressed little burrito. Either way it’ll be good for something. Alternatively, the colleges could start just saving all the bubble wrap that comes with new purchases and not have to pay a cent. Reduce, reuse, recycle. Dogs (but they’re just drama students dressed as dogs) Same concept as having actual dogs visit the halls, but with an added thrill. Someone from Auckland Uni tweeted that this happened there during their undergrad; posters were put up advertising a “puppy petting session” but it was really just drama students wearing dog collars. So this one isn’t even remotely outside the realm of possibility. While this might be more stress-inducing than stress-relieving for all parties involved, it would certainly serve as a distraction and maybe even an awakening for budding young furries (I’m not judging). Bouncy castle Hiring a bouncy castle in Dunedin costs between $185 and $520. If we’re going with the $250 ball park figure for what colleges are willing to spend on their overwhelmed cohorts of freshers, then a modest “Paw Patrol” bouncy castle of $200 is a bargain. Knox once hired what appears to be a mid-range bouncy castle at around $350 that doubled as an obstacle course and I can vouch for its stress-relieving qualities. One of the best days in my time there, but that’s not saying much I guess. And exercise is apparently good for you, so there’s that too. Hire a stripper I mean, you could. I don’t think very many students would actively enjoy this (at least not the ones you want to make happy) but it would undoubtedly make people forget about their stress for a while, even if that was just because they were too preoccupied with wondering how this idea ever got green-lit in the first place. Maybe the stripper could teach pole classes or something, I dunno, that’s an active way to move your body. No matter what happens, it would definitely be a distraction. Rage room Instead of bringing in puppies that you have to pet and treat nicely, bring in inanimate stuff that you can break and treat meanly. Or, even better, take someone’s totaled car and park it out front, then give students five free swings with a bat to see what they can do. Safety glasses are a must, of course. You could even start charging for extra swings to make a profit on this method, and use the profit to fund another method on this list, making it the most economically-viable option of the lot. Lift alcohol rules for a weekend Listen, healthy coping methods are great if they work for you. I’m all for a hot girl walk and meditation session. But sometimes you just need to be able to drink an ungodly concoction of hard liquor to the point of forgetting the conversation you had with your friend ten minutes ago, let alone the stress of being an adult. The frankly oppressive rules of residential halls don’t seem to recognise this. Freshers are new to being adults - it’s hard. Lifting the alcohol rules for a week at halls is the least they can do in terms of pastoral care of residents, and it’s also very cost-effective (free). Healthy? No. Stress-relieving? Temporarily.