-
Culture
Prime Minister Chris Hipkins: On the Tertiary Sector, Student Life, and Protesting
Prime Minister Chris Hipkins represents one thing: hope. At least, hope for rangas and hope for people from The Hutt that, despite the circumstances they were born into, they too can achieve their dreams. While he now has the biggest job in the country, it wasn’t long ago that Chippy was just another hipster arts student at Victoria University, protesting the issues that the tertiary sector is still very much facing. He was so deep in student politics, he even got arrested at a protest back in the day. Prior to receiving a grand tour of the Critic Te Ārohi office (including describing our Luxon cover as “traumatising”), Chris had been downstairs at Auahi Ora delivering a talk on the tertiary sector where he was met with protestors from Protect Otago Action Group (POAG). Among the crowd was that unicycle-riding, guitar-playing monkey. As well as the sign-toting protesters, the space was filled with other concerned members of the community, all seeking answers on Otago University’s financial situation and the proposed cuts. While he got a good grilling, with questions ranging from “why can’t you just fix the budget hole” to concerns over the price of vegetables, Chippy said he couldn’t blame the academic community for how they’re feeling right now. “The questions are fair and legitimate, and I’d be disappointed if a university campus wasn’t a place for that, and it’s not the worst I’ve encountered,” he told Critic. This is despite someone yelling, “Okay, coloniser!” at one point. Back in the day, Chippy was the President at Victoria University Students Association, at the forefront of protesting increases of fees. “We were in an environment where cost [of tuition] was going up, we were paying a couple of thousand and then it went up to 5k or 6k and continued going, so a lot of people got involved at that time,” he said. Chippy also mentioned that during his time as a student politician, “It was about fees more so than support, and once the fee cap came in, the attention turned to other issues in the early 2000s, such as the cost of living,” he said, nodding to Labour’s 2005 campaign to remove interest on student loans. “I had a great time, I loved it, and one of the things I like about student politics is the enthusiasm for good robust educated opinion and debate, and campuses should be places for that.” It certainly was. Otago University is currently in a financial shitstorm, and since the time of interview, Victoria University has announced that it, too, is facing large deficits and program cuts. At the Auahi Ora forum, Hipkins reiterated that he wants all Kiwis to have access to tertiary education, and that our universities should be world-leading. However, his response to repeated questions about funding was that there will “never be enough” regardless of increases in the budget. On the question of whether or not the government can just “fix the budget hole”, Hipkins said that “everywhere” is asking for more funding, such as the healthcare sector and the welfare sector, further reiterating that no amount of money will be enough. When asked if the government would consider a bail out of struggling universities, Chippy said that this wasn’t something the government would do due to wanting universities to maintain financial autonomy. “When I was at Vic, we went through a similar process where they were in deficit and the council was having to make decisions around this, and that did include some unpopular ones, such as no longer teaching Russian,” he said. “No one likes to see that happen, but there is a supply and demand there, as if demand is low, as long as we have to subsidise departments, then the subjects that people do want to study aren’t getting the level of support they need. So the institutions should make those decisions, not us.” Chippy also noted that universities are in better financial shape than polytechs, who were well and truly broke without government assistance. On the quality of accommodation on offer for students, Chris said that the government had been working to change this with the introduction of healthy homes standards. He also noted that students face fixed costs when it comes to rent, and that ability to meet those costs is limited - something he empathised with having spent around 60% of his income as a student on rent - therefore showing why it's necessary to keep increasing student loan payments. We were only given a mere 15 minutes with the man himself, so it was time to wrap things up. With the general election set to take place on October 14th of this year, we decided to ask him: What can students get out of voting for Labour come time to cast their ballots? “You will get a government that is going to continue investing in tertiary education,” he said. Pressed for more details, he replied, “I know that there are specific things that students will want to know where we stand, but we will set this out before the election… It's a choice between a government led by a party that wants to invest and one that wants to cut.” That being said, right now it feels like cuts from all sides.
-
Columns
Moaningful Confessions: She Pea on my Nut till I Butter
Hope you don’t have a peanut allergy because this one is about to get saucy. So it’s about a year ago, maybe two, and I’m in a UniFlat. We’re doing flat dinners so everyone cooks once a week. And there was an international girl who was living with us who I was really into, but she had a boyfriend back home - you know the drill. Let me tell you how hard I tried to break them up. Like honestly, everything I could think of. And we would always have these late talks over some drinks and we’d sit all close to each other and shit and pretend like we didn’t want to fuck each other’s brains out - or at least that’s what she was pretending. I was pretty obvious about it. Flash forward to the end of the semester, she’s about to go home in a few weeks, and something cracked. It was after a pad thai peanut sauce dinner, my go-to, which I would like to think contributed somehow to what was about to unfold. Surely it was all about the sauce. I have no idea. After dinner, as per usual, everyone else went off to do their own thing and we were left on the couch. By this point we were already “snuggling platonically” and I could get in a few “friendly” boob grabs on accident, because this was all totally normal and not crossing any lines. But tonight was different. Tonight it was getting spicier. We were talking about how she didn’t want to leave, and how there were so many things she’d regret not doing if she left so soon… and then it happened. All at once. My hands were in her clothes, her hands were in mine, and since nobody had washed after dinner, the whole ordeal just absolutely reeked of peanut sauce. We tumbled off the couch and laughed to each other before making deadly serious eye contact and resuming the act. I tried to pick her up but I’m not actually very strong so we went upstairs together. Back in my bed we desperately tried to hide our creaking and moaning from the flatmates, because God forbid these people that we’ll never see again know about her long-distance transgression. It didn’t work. I’m sure they could hear, but I didn’t care. I’d waited months to finally have this moment, and I was going to enjoy every second of it. Her peanut-streaked skin was the most delicious thing I’d ever licked, and when I finally busted a nut (pun very much intended) it was the most glorious sensation I’ve ever experienced. We kept sleeping together for the rest of the semester, three or so times a day, making up for lost time. She went home and broke up with her mans, and to this day, I cannot smell peanuts without becoming incredibly horny.
-
Columns
Local Produce: Soul Chai
While you’re retiring from kick-ons in the early hours of Saturday, Daniel Fitzpatrick is up and brewing the perfect cure to nurse your hangover and winter blues. Critic Te Ārohi caught up with Daniel to spill the tea on his farmers market venture, Soul Chai. As Soul Chai, Daniel brews fresh, warm chai at the farmers market each Saturday. “Everything is done on the day. Normally, about six o'clock, I'm grinding up spices. Seven o'clock, it's all in the pots and boiling away. Eight thirty, we're ready to serve.” There are two flavours, original and coconut, and we can confirm that they are both delicious. From Monday to Friday, Daniel works as a town planner. He majored in Geography in his undergrad, then completed a postgraduate diploma in Environmental Management. Though the early Saturday starts can be rough, spending his morning serving chais and yarns at the market makes for a good balance after a week in the office. Soul Chai was initially started by his friend, Sophie Richards. She and Daniel began developing the chai stall in the final year of her BCom, after she spent some time travelling in India. Dan and Sophie worked on Soul Chai together for a period before she left Ōtepoti for a job in Auckland. It’s been a year since Daniel took over running the stall. Even before Soul Chai, the weekly farmers market trip was the usual for Daniel. “I was coming to the farmers market for a solid year before I got a stall here. It’s really cool going from being someone who would shop at the stalls, to having your own stall.” Already knowing some of the vendors made Soul Chai’s beginnings at the market easier. There’s also a lot of support between vendors, who are encouraged to use each others’ produce in making their own produce. For Soul Chai, this means using milk from Holy Cow, a small dairy farm out in Port Chalmers. “It’s a really great community. Everyone’s trying to support each other and wants everyone to succeed.” In the future, Daniel plans to roll out his chai in loose leaf bags so people can brew their own at home. He’d also like to add a permanent third flavour, a cacao-infused chai in collaboration with CoKo Lounge. If you’re already a long time enjoyer of Soul Chai, you may remember they’ve collaborated before, last year back when CoKo Lounge were also part of the farmers market. There’ll also be some future fundraising days, the profit from which Daniel plans to donate towards Dog Rescue Dunedin, a local charity that rehomes dogs. “I’ve had a couple of gigs where we’ve put around $300 straight to the puppies,” he says. Soul Chai is also a business sponsor for Dog Rescue. “Aside from using this money to buy beer, I can help out in the community with it. It’s really fun.” There are a lot of reasons why the farmers market is a much more wholesome experience than shopping at some chain supermarket. For Daniel, it’s about “knowing where your food is from and who it’s made by,” a topic he focused on throughout his studies. “You come down here, the food is organic. You know that it's been planted with love and looked after. And it’s cheaper.” Supermarkets really have us believing local, sustainable and cheap is impossible. Be sure to pop down to the Dunedin Farmers Market, every Saturday morning till noon at the Dunedin Railway Station. Pro tip: a cup of Soul Chai is the perfect hand warmer for your wander.
-
Columns
Chargrills: Mexi-Bowls
It’s cold. You know where it’s not cold? Mexico. Let’s pretend we’re there. Close your eyes for a moment. Imagine the feeling of sand between your toes. Imagine the background noises of the United States attempting to overthrow yet another Southern democracy. Perfect. That’s the stuff. Serve with a marg x 500g chicken breast or Quorn Oil Can of diced tomatoes Drizzle of sweet chilli Options to fill the bowl Grated carrot (2) Diced tomato Edamame beans (they’re cheap!) Canned corn, cooked in a pan without oil until charred Lettuce Cooked rice Grated cheese Could also add or swap to Capsicum diced Canned beetroot Quinoa, cooked Roasted chickpeas These mexi-flavoured build-a-bowls are a great dinner option. To prepare the chicken it needs to be cut into small chunks, cooked in oil, and then combined with a can of diced tomatoes and a drizzle of sweet chilli. Cook this on medium heat until the canned tomatoes become less watery and you're good to go - it’s really that easy. Now it's just about adding some other fillings to get a bowl together. World's your oyster. Canned corn and edamame are great cheaper options but make sure to get a grain of sorts to get those carbs in.
-
Features
Vape Laws: A Breath of Fresh Air?
The other night, I found myself and my five flatmates talking about how bad vaping was and everything the government should be doing to address it – all while we passed around my friend’s big, blue, bubble-shaped vape filled with grape ice juice. “It’s liquid in your lungs!” exclaimed one flatmate, as she inhaled another puff. “We think of it as water vapour, but it’s way worse than that.” “Can I have B’s?” asked another, solidifying her place next in line for a toke. The irony paints a perfect picture of the predicament Dunedin students, and a lot of young New Zealanders, have found themselves in. Like a baby in the womb whose mother smoked durries while you were still cooking, it feels like we haven’t been given a choice over our addiction. Our young, teenage minds were infiltrated by big corporations who capitalised on the innate vice of addiction. Amelia* called her addiction to vaping “stupid”, saying she wished she’d “never done it to begin with.” She only started because her friends did. Jade* initially “hated” vaping in her first year, but when she saw that Vaper’s Nest had a deal on, she thought, “Fuck it, I’ll get two because they’re so cheap.” That’s when she started getting addicted. Only a few years ago, vape companies targeted many students in residential colleges with offers of free disposable vapes delivered right to them. These insidious marketing tactics have ensnared an entire generation. According to Dr Luke Bradford, Medical Director of the Royal New Zealand College of General Practitioners, vaping among university-aged students is “essentially approaching pandemic levels.” According to a survey by the Ministry of Health, young people aged 18-24 had the highest daily rate of vaping, increasing from 5% in 2019/20 to 22.9% in 2021/22. In Dunedin, vaping has become a cultural phenomenon. “Everyone else is doing it,” remarked one student who started vaping when she came to Dunedin. “It’s like a security blanket,” said another. “A lot of people who are addicted to vaping are addicted to the ritual of it,” says Amelia. In other words, we actively choose to engage in the habit of vaping because it has been deemed socially acceptable - and perhaps socially necessary - by our peers. The Australian government recently introduced measures to curb vaping, including making vapes prescription-only. This necessitates a conversation here in New Zealand, where vaping is even more prevalent. What is our government doing about it, and should they be doing more? The Labour government has recently introduced new regulations that are to come into effect in August. Firstly, they are limiting the sale of disposable vapes. All vaping devices sold will need to have “removable or replaceable batteries”. Secondly, locations within 300m of schools and marae will be off limits for new vape retailers. According to Minister of Heath Dr Ayesha Verrall, this is to “put vapes as far from the minds and reach of children and young people as possible.” Thirdly, flavour names such as “cotton candy” and “strawberry jelly donut” will be replaced with generic names that accurately describe the flavours, such as “berry”. With these new measures, Dr Verrall says the government aims to strike a balance between preventing young people from starting, and having vapes as a cessation tool for those who want to give up smoking. But will they work? University of Canterbury Professor Mark Wallace-Bell thinks they will. “I think it will make a difference and reduce the rate of vaping among young people,” he says. Wallace-Bell oversaw PhD research into the vaping habits of 18-24 year-olds, and sees these kinds of measures as “long overdue”. However, Janet Hoek, a professor of Public Health at Otago, believes that “what they’ve announced at the moment doesn’t go far enough… we now know that we have a really huge problem, and no one’s taken accountability for it.” Hoek says the government should have just banned disposable vapes full-stop. “We know that they’re really affordable, we know that they’ve targeted young people through their design and colours and packaging,” she says, “so why not just get rid of them?” Dr Kelly Burrowes, a senior researcher in Bioengineering, also sees the flaws in the new regulation: “[The government] say vapes must have a rechargeable or removable battery, but actually some of the disposable vapes are rechargeable.” Instead, she suggests the rule should ban vapes that aren’t “refillable”, rather than “rechargeable”. Health experts aren’t satisfied with the 300m rule, either. “Any existing outlet is not covered by the new regulation,” says Hoek. “It also doesn’t address the growing problem of outlet density,” she says, including the “store within a store” practice, where dairies create an internal, specialist store from which they can sell vapes. These Russian-doll vape shops won’t be covered by the new regulation. Dr Burrowes estimates that there are roughly 10 new vape stores opening every week in New Zealand. There are currently 1300 specialist vape retailers in the country. According to Hoek, “[the regulation] stops a bad problem from getting slightly worse, but it does nothing to address the fact that the problem’s already there.” Dr Bradford also thinks that changing the flavour names won’t work. “Whether it’s called ‘berry’, they’ll still find out which one they like and smoke it,” he says, “because at the end of the day, it’s still flavoured.” Hoek says the government should reduce the flavour variety. The government’s new regulations will likely have preventative effects, but may be less effective in addressing the prevalence of vaping that already exists among young people. Jade*, who is addicted to vaping, say they would still vape without those yummy flavours. “I don’t think it would stop people like me from vaping, but it would stop new people vaping,” they say, “people like nicotine, it’s an addiction.” The general consensus among health experts and students is that the government could be doing more to address the pandemic levels of vaping that Kiwi youth are experiencing. However, some want to protect their freedom to choose. “I should be able to decide whether or not I vape,” says Ben*, “same as with drinking alcohol, it’s my body.” Some students think that vaping should just be made illegal. “I’m definitely addicted to vaping, but I think I would stop if it was made illegal,” says Holly*. Caleb thinks vaping should “absolutely not” be legal, given it’s a substance “that’s more addictive than cocaine and targeted for children.” While that bold claim from Caleb might not be entirely true, vaping does pose a significant public and long-term health risk. A UC study into e-cigarette use found an apparent increase in students vaping in smoke-free spaces, indicating that vaping could be a source of considerable harm to public health. There are both physical and mental health impacts on students as well. According to Hoek, “[vaping] causes mental health stresses and problems for young people when they’re dependent, and they realise that they’ve got this practice that they can’t get rid of.” So many students wish they’d never started, like Amelia, who sees her addiction as “stupid” and something she’s now “stuck with.” Perhaps banning vapes outright would be a way of tackling this issue head on and help students curb their addiction. However, a lot of health experts advocate for vapes as an effective tool for helping people who smoke to quit. This was, after all, the original purpose of vapes. “When NZ becomes smokefree in 2025, people are going to need alternatives,” says Hoek, “so vaping products have a potentially important role to play as a reduced harm alternative for those people.” Wallace-Bell sees it as a “bit of a stretch policy-wise” to make vapes illegal, one which “might come with some unintended consequences.” Students were concerned about the potential for a black market to spring up were vaping to become illegal. “I don’t think it should be banned,” says Emily*. “Prohibition hasn’t worked in the past. People are going to jail for small marijuana charges, we wouldn’t want the same thing happening with vapes.” Vaping has become such an integral part of many young Kiwis’ lives that some students believe it cannot be tackled by simply making it illegal. “We are way too late for it not to go underground if they banned it,” says Caleb. “The problem is so big that it would require so much effort to make [vapes] illegal,” says Josh, “plus, vaping hasn’t been around long enough to use long-term side effects to warn people.” However, Dr Burrowes and Dr Bradford both point out that, while vaping is less harmful than smoking, it still carries risk. Dr Burrowes says, “No one really knows what the health effects of inhaling those flavourings will be… there are still some harmful chemicals in there.” According to Dr Bradford, “There has been nothing except pure air that mankind has ever chosen to inhale chronically that has been good for their health.” Instead of banning vapes outright, some experts think New Zealand should follow Australia’s footsteps in making vapes prescription-only. “We will probably follow Australia,” says Wallace-Bell. “It’ll be packaged like a medicine as opposed to something attractive [which] will make a big difference [to] young people using it.” However, Dr Bradford sees a risk of weighing down the health system if we move to prescription-only policy. “We’re already under a pressured health system,” he says, “and if we’re taking away important clinic time for prescriptions of vapes, that’s not ideal when we’re already struggling to service our sick patients.” Other solutions for harm reduction policies to target vaping in young people include going to plain packaging, zero marketing, and health warnings - similar to what has been done with smoking which has appeared to work. “People aren’t going outside the library for a ciggy,” says Jade, “like, that would be weird.” Taking away the socially acceptable aspect of vaping would likely reduce the rate of vaping among Dunedin students. Vapes are highly accessible and affordable, particularly in Dunedin. “Most of the vaping I’ve done has been in Dunedin,” says Amelia. “[Elsewhere], they’re not as accessible.” Therefore, students saw merit in reducing the number of vape retailers in Dunedin, including by taking them out of dairies. Dr Bradford thinks vapes need to be moved back to their original purpose, which was to help tobacco smokers quit tobacco. “So we need to get rid of the candy store-like appearances of vape shops,” he says. Instead of simply renaming the flavours, students and experts both see merit in getting rid of the flavours altogether. “They need to chill with the crazy flavours, it just promotes people to start,” says Emily. “When I was younger, if the only flavours [available] were tobacco and menthol, I probably wouldn’t have started.” The government should also look at increasing the price of vapes, says Wallace-Bell. He notes the “worrying trend” of young people who have never been smokers taking up vaping as a result of “very good marketing” and “high accessibility”. Increasing the price of vapes would curb this trend, making them less accessible to students (except maybe the rich ones). Both health experts and many students feel that the government’s current regulations do not go far enough, even though many of these students are currently addicted to vaping. Dunedin life lends itself to vaping culture, a vortex which many students have been caught in. While making vapes completely illegal is likely not the answer, the government could be doing more to reduce the accessibility of vapes for young people, and implementing harm reduction policies to help those who already vape. “Right now, I don’t know how to stop,” says Emily. “If more regulations were to come in, it might help me to finally quit.” It’s not what we want, but it’s what we need. Jade reckons that “people deep down would be happy” if the government implemented more restrictions. “With something like vaping which is so prevalent in Dunedin,” says Emily, “people wouldn’t just go along with it straight away. But they’d get over it pretty quick.” *Names changed.
-
Culture
How to Take Your Landlord to Court
Dunedin’s rental rates are rising faster than any other university town in the country, but the quality of the homes is not exactly a sterling standard. Since people come and go every year, it can be easy for a property owner to neglect a home for years on end, always promising to do work for the next year’s tenants, and then rinsing and repeating the process. We sat in on a few Tenancy Tribunal cases to see what happens when students stand up to the status quo. The Tenancy Tribunal is located on the first floor of the District and High Court on Lower Stuart Street, which is not a scary building, we promise. As far as going to court goes, it’s pretty casual and accessible. It only costs a crisp $20 to file for the Tribunal, and after filling out some paperwork you’re well on your way to sweet, sweet justice. Anyone can just rock up to a random Tribunal hearing and see what’s up. If that sounds like a boring waste of time, you’d be right. But in the name of journalism, we took one for the team and went to court at 10am on a Wednesday morning. Critic sat through two Tribunal hearings as a fly on the wall, each lasting an hour. The first ended in mediation and the second was, according to the magistrate, “very confusing”. You’re telling us. Despite being pretty dry, Critic Te Ārohi learnt some useful tips for anyone wanting to take their landlord and/or property manager into a small room with bright fluorescent lights and lay out how much of an asshole they’ve been in a court of law. The most important thing to remember is not to interrupt the magistrate; they’re the one making the decision at the end of the day, so it’s probably not a great idea to piss them off. Also, don’t interrupt your landlord and/or property manager, no matter how much of a dick they are; both parties have an allotted time to speak before giving the other party time to ask questions and for the right of replies at the magistrate’s discretion. One student told Critic Te Ārohi, “We got told to shut up a couple of times actually because we got too passionate about it.” But then, so did their property manager. Another important thing to remember is to bring printed copies of the evidence you want to submit (things like the signed tenancy agreement, email receipts or bank statements). It’s useful to bring three copies, one for yourself, one for the other party, and one for the magistrate. Be specific and concise; the hearing only lasts an hour and the magistrate likely has a tonne of other hearings back-to-back to get through. So get your facts straight and make sure you have a clear timeline of events complete with specific dates things happened or were said. Finally, don’t expect to get a result on the day; it typically takes a couple weeks for the magistrate to reach a decision and email the outcome. Critic Te Ārohi sat down with a couple students to go deeper and understand what happens behind the scenes of the Tenancy Tribunal process. Zion and his flat of six took their property manager from KITT Property Management (KITT) to the tribunal over around 20 serious issues with their flat in North East Valley last year. Things were off to a not so great start when Zion found rubbish along with a car left from the original tenants on the day he moved in. But that was only the beginning; the stove only had one working hob, the dishwasher was broken, the washing machine was broken, the dryer was broken and there was a patch of mould one metre squared in the middle of the hallway. Also, KITT is based in Christchurch (an immediate red flag). In summary, it was a “shit flat”. After around three months, Zion issued KITT with a 14-day notice. “They're like, ‘Oh maybe we should actually do something about this,’” said Zion. So they went ahead and fixed the gutters and a couple other minor issues. Zion then submitted another 14-day notice, prioritising exactly what needed done to have a habitable flat. After three weeks of “nothing” (Critic Te Ārohi is no expert, but that sounds like over 14 days), Zion threatened to take them to Tenancy Tribunal. So KITT did what any reasonable property management company would do: they went ahead and painted the front of the house (and got a little on the tenants’ cars for good measure). This was the “final straw” for Zion. Three months later, after doing the paperwork and paying $26 from the flat account, Zion and his flatties made it to the Tribunal. “We went to court as a flat, all dressed up,” said Zion. After laying out all the cold hard facts, “we won,” said Zion. KITT Property Management was ordered to pay $2,500 in damages and fix the broken appliances. Split 6 ways, it worked out to be $400 each in “prize money”. But Zion told Critic Te Ārohi: “Honestly, I would have paid $400 at the start to have all the stuff fixed and not have to deal with that… it's awesome but I just wanted a dishwasher working at that point.” Collectively, Zion and his girlfriend put in around 60 hours of admin - not a great hourly rate. He said that the Tribunal process “took a lot of hours, making it almost more stress than what it's worth but it’s the only legal way to get them back.” Ultimately, “don’t get into bed with something that fucks you over,” said Zion. Liam thought their flat on Harrow Street would be demolished the day after he moved out. The flat was not compliant with the healthy homes standards at all; the heat pump was in the hallway, not a main living space, and did “fuck all”, the gutters were broken, the windows were drafty and filled with condensation, there were mushrooms growing in the hot water closet, and there was mould throughout the whole flat. The “cumulative effect of all of this made it a really bad place to live,” said Liam. “Of the five of us living there, three developed IBS which is known to have environmental triggers. But luckily for the landlords, if they have consent for the property to be demolished within 12 months, it is exempt from the healthy homes standards. So legally, they’re technically fine.” But, plot twist: Liam noticed the flat remained standing and the landlords had advertised the flat again - for this year. Liam is prepared to take the fight to the Tenancy Tribunal and is confident of their chances. “The law is quite clear,” they said, “it really depends on those nitty-gritty details.” The property manager has already gotten two adjournments, the latest being given the day before the hearing. While this has dragged the process out, it has also given Liam more time to prepare. The property manager also asked Liam to go to private mediation to “discuss what has actually transpired and the legality of it,” indicating they want to settle outside of court. This all indicates that “they’re scared,” said Liam. To top it off, Critic Te Ārohi sat down with Janet, current head of the Disputes Tribunal and referee for 15 years on the Tenancy Tribunal. Janet described the Tenancy Tribunal as the “front door to civil justice”. The Residential Tenancies Act requires the property to be “reasonably clean and tidy” and “reasonably maintained”. Again, we’re no expert, but it seems unlikely that many flats in North D fall within this description. Janet went as far as to say that “Castle St could be cleaned up for $20”. You heard it here first folks; if you’re flatting on Castle (or anywhere really) and have a scummy landlord that you think is taking advantage of you, take them to Tenancy Tribunal. The worst that can happen is you lose $20 which, split between all your flatties, isn’t much. Zion agreed: “If you hold people accountable they’ll stop taking advantage of you.” Critic Te Ārohi collated someful helpful tips and tricks for students who find themselves in similar situations to Zion and Liam. Take a look at the Residential Tenancy Act and take note of the specific relevant section numbers and specifically how your landlord or property manager has breached it. Reach out to OUSA student support services. Keep everything in emails; if it’s a phone call or in-person conversation with your landlord, get it in writing. You could say: “My flatmate asked what we talked about and I forgot so can you please email me a summary?” Take photos of everything. Better yet, do a full walk around video of the flat. It costs around $20 to apply online for Tenancy Tribunal (and you get it back if you win). Despite the law offering numerous cushy protections for private property interests (cringe), you, as a tenant, actually have some rights. The only problem is that reading legal documents is a massive ceebs. Thankfully, Critic Te Ārohi has got your back, so here’s your one-stop-shop for renting red flags and tenancy rights; you just have to enforce them. What’s more, it only costs a crisp $20 to file for Tenancy Tribunal (and you get it back if you win). Renters United is a national advocacy organisation that campaigns for better renters rights in Aotearoa. They were the ones behind ‘The Peoples Review of Renting’, a report which helped lead the way for the healthy homes standards. The group is entirely run by renters. Jordie, president of Renters United, told Critic Te Ārohi, “Our previous president bought a house and that automatically kicked him out of the organisation.” The current renting situation is pretty cooked. Jordie told Critic Te Ārohi that the biggest issue is “paying for something and not getting anything in return.” Instead, what you do get is mostly negative; “it makes you sick, it is probably in a location that doesn't work for you,” and to top it all off “it's more than a third of your income,” said Jordie. Murdock said that the rent of his last flat in Ōtepoti has gone up “400%” in 20 years. As good as $4 lunch is, wages certainly haven’t gone up that much. As a result, “students are going to be renting into their thirties,” said Murdock, unless of course you’re privileged enough to have intergenerational wealth.
-
Columns
Booze review: RUM(S)
Rum is the blindfold that humanity gladly adorns when things get messy.
-
News
Horseplay in Uni Council Meeting!
At a packed Uni Council meeting last week, Otago confirmed that it would be going ahead with the million-dollar rebrand. Student protesters - dressed as pigs and horses - refused to leave the chamber after the announcement, protesting staff cuts. It was truly a dog and pony show, but in the end, everyone left peacefully after some words with the Proctor. The meeting covered two significant topics, which we’ll break down here: the design and implementation of a new name and tohu (symbol), and the ongoing debate over cuts and spending. The overlap between the two has been confined mostly to Facebook debates, with people questioning why the Uni is spending more than a million dollars on a project at the apparent expense of staff positions. In the consultation findings, one staff member commented: “On the one hand, there’s never a good time to do this, and the design is very nice, on the other hand, it’s hard to be excited for a redesign when your job is in doubt.” The new name and symbol were a hot debate online, but feedback from people who actually took time to submit to the proposal painted a different picture: out of around 9,000 responses, two thirds were supportive. Some called it tokenism: “The fact that this survey was sent to me only in English shows it is tokenism and woke by a bunch of white privileged people.” Other comments in the consultation findings seemed to think the changes couldn’t come fast enough to incorporate Māori so that it would not be “lost in the Eurocentric foundations of this organization.” While many respondents worried it was merely a “box-ticking exercise”, Chancellor Stephen Higgs said, “I assure you we have listened, and you have been heard.” Thanks, Stephen, for validating me. From next year, the new name will take effect and the new tohu will be seen around campus. The coat of arms will remain (though it’s getting a polish) and will be more visible on the alumni-facing documents and in ceremonial circumstances. The debate about staff cuts was then briefly touched on, with Council noting that they plan to meet with various MP’s and OUSA to hopefully tease out some more emergency funding, or at least lay the groundwork for changes after the election. These meetings will take place with individual MP’s, not as a group. The TEU will also be present. Stephen opened the meeting with the statement that their negotiations with the government have been “successful in a small way”, which is how we’re feeling about the first semester, too. At this point the meeting finished its public segment. When the Council was cleared for a private session, the students along the back row donned their livestock getup and refused to move, flashing wads of printed cash and asking about the democratic process. A third-year amongst the ranks said, “We tried to put on a performance and we got escorted out of the meeting,” making this the first time livestock has ever been trespassed from the Clocktower. The whole ordeal was rather civil, with the Proctor noting, as he escorted them out, that reasonable protest was an important part of the student experience, and that removing them was just due diligence. We did not ask if he had prior experience trespassing pigs or horses. For context, chaos in this room is nothing new. Some years ago, in the late ‘90s, Otago proposed cuts to some languages departments and proposed raising fees. Students occupied the Clocktower, broke down doors, and ultimately forced a counselor to try to escape the meeting room by sneaking out a window. Better luck next time.
-
News
Year 13s Invade Castle Street, Seeking Thrills
Never before have there been so many students claiming to be first year health sci students on Castle St. Why would anyone make such an absurd claim, you ask? It’s likely because they’re not even students. Recently, there has been a significant upturn in the amount of Dunedin highschool students daring to venture out into the wild streets of studentville, emboldened by the anonymity that large street parties provide. Though this phenomenon has a history dating back decades, the process has accelerated recently with more younglings smoking cones, drinking copiously, and even clubbing in Catacombs (seen at one bold formal afterparty). On Saturday June 24, Columba College, a sporting and academic behemoth nestled in Māori hill, hosted their senior formal for Year 12 and 13 students. Notably, the formal afterparty was hosted at an entirely booked out Catacombs where students frothed to the infamous thudding of DnB. Besides the fact that booking out a nightclub is undoubtedly an absolute gun venture, the act perhaps mirrors the efforts of highschool kids getting increasingly involved in student culture. While Critic Te Ārohi has heard rumours of a similar formal afterparty occurring at Suburbia in weeks to come, the primary offender at this stage is the afterparty at Catacombs. But where does this obsession with student culture spawn from? Sure, it does well to draw in the out-of-towners who only see the highlights, but the fact that even locals are being bamboozled makes for an interesting sight. One Year 12 student, Alex*, told Critic Te Ārohi that the primary reason for increased interest was that “student culture is so public in Dunedin.” Still, she did admit that “there’s a certain type” that takes the plunge into the depths of Castle, having never gone in herself. While many would suspect the “certain type” to be the Logan park larakkin located conveniently at the gates of studentville, Fletcher, a second-year student who ventured into Castle as a Year 13, told us that is was mainly those who were “trying to look cool” (AKA posers). Scorning his own youthful folly, Fletcher stated that the experience was “pretty shit, really, as we mainly just hung out together.” Going one step further, Fletcher told Critic Te Ārohi, “If I saw a Year 13 out and about, I would drop them,” justifying his bold claim with the assertion that, “their time will come.” Ben, a student who performed the same crime as Fletcher, shone some light on the benefits of the excursion when he told Critic Te Ārohi that “you had to sell a lie” to get away with it. Ben admitted, “We all knew we didn’t belong and it was kinda fun sneaking around telling people your course that you’d made up.” Based on this testimony, the murky motivations of the intrepid Year 13’s venturing onto Castle became apparent. The “certain type” that Alex* refers to is the dare-devil, inspired by the glitz and the glam of student life, risking a beating or potential embarrassment to get a taste of the thrill that comes with identity fraud. When you frame it like this, the recent spike in the number of Year 13’s wandering Castle Street makes sense. Keep an eye on the streets of studentville for updates on the trajectory of this worrying trend. *Name changed.
-
Columns
Editorial: Dude, Where’s my Castle Host?
I’ve heard talk that Castle hasn't had an open host since O-Week. What’s up with that? Ya scared? If you live on Castle, you have a communal responsibility to throw open hosts beyond the bare minimum dates of O- and Re-O-Weeks. That’s what Castle is known for, and it’s why you moved there. You can’t choose to move to a new location because of all the promises it offers and then pull up the ladder behind you; that’s like moving to Wanaka to be close to the mountains and then being upset when other people move there after you because “it’s getting too crowded”. The older students (is third-year old?) recognise what’s going on here and, honestly, it’s pretty cringe. The entire point of Castle is to live communally and play host to the heart of Dunedin culture, and if you close it off it’ll become a gated and elitist community rife with incest and infighting. Nobody wants that. Even worse, it means that people won’t want to move there next year because they won’t have the communal party memories associated with it, so you’d be responsible for killing the reputation of Dunedin’s most notorious street. Not to be dramatic or anything. “But wait!” you say, “The reason we’re making it exclusive is because strangers keep trashing our flats!” Ah, yes. There are two problems with this: firstly, that’s not new. Literally everyone before you dealt with that and you knew what they were signing up for. You can’t get mad at the rollercoaster operator because your tummy got upset, right? It’s a rollercoaster. Second, this problem is valid, but it doesn’t mean that the answer is closing off your parties. The responsibility to not be a dick falls on all of our shoulders and, instead of closing off the party, maybe we need to eliminate the behaviour. I recommend the public shaming of people who steal or break things, it really brings the neighbourhood together. Besides, the awkwardness of calling out that behaviour is worth preserving the culture. Now, I’m all about having safer parties, but that’s a different discussion. We all know what goes on at Castle and it’s not going to change any time soon. The only difference is: if you’re not letting other people into the hosts, they won’t have any reason to want to take over the flats, and then the culture begins to die. Who wants to go to a host on Castle if the hosts themselves are exclusive? That’s bad vibes. Don’t be bad vibes. If you’re gonna live on Castle, live on Castle. No half measures. You knew what you were signing up for, and if I see another private Courtyard Ball I’ll cry. You’ve gotta use it or lose it. If you don’t honour the Castle culture, it will honestly just move somewhere else. You won’t be cool anymore. I’m sure Leith is chomping at the bit for a chance to take the title of most notorious party street… you just gonna roll over and let them take it?
-
News
Countdown Central Declares They Hate Self-Expression
After years of allowing them to exist on the Moray Place side of Countdown, the supermarket has finally decided to purge the wall of its posters. Posters promoting local events and gigs, activism and art were common here. The postering spot was the largest stretch in the city, as well as the most heavily foot trafficked. There was also an increase of tagging in this spot over the last few months. Countdown painted it over about a fortnight ago. Street posterers have attempted to paste up posters since, however Countdown continues to swiftly remove these overnight. A street posterer and student (who wished to remain anonymous due to fears of Big Supermarket) expressed their disappointment at this spot being destroyed as it was “really important space for artists, musicians, people who want to express themselves.” Though billsticking is illegal, as it is loosely enforced and extremely cheap, it’s been a popular form of promotion for the community. “I think I’ll be even more disappointed if Phantom [Billstickers] ends up taking over that space,” they said of the possibility the wall may be converted to a space for paid advertising. “It’ll just go to show they’re prioritising profits over community - which is pretty symbolic of the situation with supermarket profits in New Zealand.” Though local events promoters could advertise their gigs on Countdown’s instore community board, it may be somewhat inappropriate for bands with names like Erectile Dysfunctioners or Cuck. Countdown have been approached for comment on whether they are going for a monopoly on community expression in addition to their grocery duopoly.
-
Columns
Horoscopes: Week 15
Aquarius Jan 20 - Feb 18 Aquarius, it’s time for you to normalize insanity. Flatmates pissing you off? Scream at them and eat their cheese. Situationship going downhill? Fuck someone else. Life is too short to not be your best, unhinged self.