Nice.
Probably.
I don't know but we definitely should.
Poor Col.
from Issue 20 ()
During Dunedin’s Illuminate Paint Party, which took place at Forsyth Barr Stadium on 10 July 2014, a University of Otago student was denied entry due to appearing intoxicated to staff. In actual fact he suffered from a number of physical disabilities. Critic spoke with the student, Richard, who is actively involved in sport at the University. He asked us not to publish his last name. Richard said that when he approached the stadium staff on the door, he lightly stumbled due to his disability. The staff member on guard asked him how he was; his stutter was then taken as a sign that he was too intoxicated and was denied entry into the premises. “I pleaded with staff for about two and a half hours, but they weren’t having a bar of it.” After attempting to explain his disability to multiple staff members, as well as two police officers, Richard was still denied entry into the stadium. Richard stated he had only consumed three standard drinks that night, hours before he left home. “I had completely burned it off and wasn’t feeling any effect by the time I had arrived at the Paint Party.” The student said he was “extremely shocked” by what had happened, saying, “nothing to that extent had ever happened before.” Although it was the first time an issue such as this has occurred at an event OUSA has been involved with, for similar reasons, he has been unfairly denied by bouncers at Dunedin’s Boogie Nites and Capone on two separate occasions. A family member of the student later contacted the University’s Disability Information and Support Office to inform them of the incident, who then contacted OUSA and staff at the Forsyth Barr Stadium. General Manager of OUSA Darel Hall said that as soon as they were informed, OUSA immediately offered the student a refund of the $40 ticket cost. Hall said, “It isn’t clear who should be held responsible. [OUSA are] not the promoter; it wasn’t our event, we just provide health and safety.” Either way, OUSA refunded the individual “because it’s a pretty unfortunate situation.” Since being made aware of the incident, OUSA has looked into various ways that they can prevent such mistakes from re-occurring. “We’ve been trying to think about any kind of systemic procedures we can put in place in terms of ID cards. [OUSA] has looked into whether there was any kind of national structure that allowed people who have certain disabilities to verify that.” OUSA have spoken to the stadium in regards to the idea, who have stated that they would be willing to cooperate if it was implemented in the future. The student told Critic he has not yet had an apology from OUSA, or staff at the stadium, since they have been made aware of the mistake. However, OUSA said they apologised to the student’s brother when he recently made contact with them. Hall said he sympathised with the Stadium staff. Having previously been an Alcohol Health Promoter, he said it is “extremely hard work” trying to determine an individual’s level of intoxication. “There are all kinds of things that you need to take into account to make a judgment of whether or not you think someone is intoxicated. There isn’t an objective standard of what intoxication looks like.” OUSA is not aware of any similar incidents occurring at past events involving the University, “It’s a relatively rare occurrence,” Hall noted, though, “If there are circumstances where people need individual care, we are happy to do that.” Melissa Lethaby, Manager of Otago University Disability Information and Support, told Critic she believed OUSA “handled the matter very well.” When she was informed of the issue, she immediately contacted Hall who “was very responsive.” She said, “I feel comfortable that Darel Hall and the team will do what they can for future events.” President of OUSA Ruby Sycamore Smith said, “OUSA believes in an inclusive environment and we’re sorry this happened to a student at an event we had a presence at. We’ve worked with the student and their family along with the University’s Disability Support, OUSA Student Support, DVML and others to create a policy which will mean this won’t happen again.”
We got a wee bit excited last Executive meeting after the team appeared to be having productive discussion. It didn’t last long. The meeting began with some good old-fashioned OUSA scandal. OUSA President Ruby Sycamore-Smith announced that she had entered into a relationship with Critic Editor Zane Pocock. As it is Critic's responsibility to hold Ruby and OUSA accountable to students, action had to be taken to address the obvious conflict of interest. Zane has stepped back from having editorial rights over Critic content that covers OUSA’s activities, handing the task to the News Editor. The issue was discussed after Critic staff were asked to leave the room, so when it was officially announced in the meeting, no comment was made by any Executive members. Ruby also declared that she would no longer be chairing the meetings of Planet Media Dunedin Limited (a wholly-owned subsidiary of OUSA under which Critic falls) due to the conflict but would remain on the board whilst Admin VP Ryan Edgar took over. Planet Media holds direct governance over the Critic Editor’s management, so it is also a conflict of interest for Ruby to chair the board. Ryan then discussed changes to the Elections Policy. There are conflicting statements with the internal policy and the constitution in that “one policy says we must have an abstain option, the other says we don’t have to and another says do whatever.” Section 5.6 was removed from the elections policy, which states there must be “an option to abstain from voting” until the constitution could be amended. The second edit was to correct a typo in 9.14 of the Elections Policy from “no” to “not,” so it was not “not” anymore. The third edit was made to section 9.8, which states that candidates cannot campaign in “a manner that implies endorsement by OUSA.” Any Executive member outwardly supporting a candidate must make it clear that they are “acting as an individual, outside of their official OUSA capacity.” Any campaign materials involving the Executive member, including social media posts, must also clearly display a disclaimer that their support is “in no way an endorsement by OUSA.” Ruby concluded the policy talk pointing out that the Executive should thoroughly read the policy and “if there is something that sticks out like a sore thumb, say something so we can turn it into a positive thumb.” OUSA General Manager Darel Hall had his operations report passed. He outlined that a recent survey revealed that students do not use the student handbook diary and its future was being considered, but that the wall-planner and Critic magazine were widely used. Darel is also focussing on health and safety standards, with a focus on earthquake safety measures. The squash building is back to a satisfactory level in regards to building standards. OUSA Finance Officer Paul Hunt discussed whether there should be a committee for religious groups. There was a lack of input from most of the Executive but Paul observed, “Religious and country groups are more where you go along and hang out together rather than doing stuff.” Recreation Officer Henri Faulkner then talked about religion, or something along those lines – Critic was unable to decipher the many words that were said and the rest of the Executive looked equally confused. No decision was made and Ruby, clearly irritated by the complete lack of constructive input from anyone, said “it would be good to put a piece of paper in the agenda so we have some context. So the discussion can be constructive.” Welfare Officer Payal Ramritu then addressed her five items on the agenda. On her mission to make OUSA Executive members more accountable, she asked Critic how this may be achieved through the publication. Critic responded that they simply needed contentious issues to be openly discussed in Executive meetings. The discussion then returned to talk of timesheets and Ruby quickly pointed out that there was strong objection to the idea when she suggested it at the start of the first semester. Ryan commented, “I don’t care anymore.” The only agreement was that the Executive would return to giving a round-up of their progress at the end of each meeting. Expecting some pressing issues on accountability to be addressed, Payal then discussed microwaves and the free breakfasts offered to students. She requested more microwaves, saying “the average wait time is 7.5 minutes” and most were either unavailable outside of business hours or broken. She also requested peanut butter, marmite and marmalade for the free breakfasts held at Student Support. The Executive agreed this would be looked into as Ryan pointed out the request was “pretty unsubstantial and uncontroversial.” Critic notes it got pretty substantial and controversial once raisins were discussed. “We want more raisins,” Payal said, “Can we just have more raisins?” “How many do they get?” asked Darel. “They get about three and want eight.” “But that’s a 300 per cent increase. What about four raisins?” asked Darel. He agreed to look into the issue soon. The meeting finished with a round up of what each Executive member had recently achieved. This consisted of nothing interesting and is available at the end of the Executive minutes on the OUSA website. Instead of printing their summaries, the screenshot from a recent conversation between the 2013 OUSA President and the 2013 Critic Editor was much more entertaining. There was a final comment on accountability, tactfully used by Ruby. She asked the Executive three times to join her on the stage for the upcoming graduation ceremony, finally needing to say, “It’s important to make sure you are seen. It dove tails into accountability.” Payal finally agreed to assist, but no other Executive members volunteered. Since the meeting, the peanut butter issue has been dealt with. The raisins issue is still to be addressed.
Dunedin’s first Street Art Festival is set to take place in October. With a $10,000 Dunedin City Council grant for more artwork, organisers have raised a further $5,000 to bring international street artist Dal East to the festival. The contributions of 11 artists have been confirmed to attend the festival, which will take place as part of the Vogel Street Party on 18 October 2014. The line up includes international artists Dal East, the return of Phlegm, Pixel Pancho, and Mica Still from Wellington. The festival will include Dunedin artists Sean Duffel, aka Ghstie, Andy McCready and Jon Thom. The Dunedin City Council has granted $10,000 from the Central City Heritage Reuse grant to the owner of the Chipmunks building to bring Italian street artist Pixel Pancho to Dunedin. The festival, which is being organised by a group of volunteers from Dunedin Street Art, is, according to their Facebook page, “In a city which proudly boasts New Zealand’s first public Art Gallery and first Art Society, we are embracing our evolution.” However, the matter of how it is being funded and who is involved does not blend well with some Dunedin residents. One Dunedin artist, who wished to remain anonymous, believed the project “stinks of nepotism.” He says some of the local artists include people that have been employed in other capacities by Tourism Dunedin and aspects of the event appear to be self-promotion of some artists. “We are being asked to pay $5,000 to get Dal East over here when we have a bevvy of incredibly talented NZ street artists,” he said. “I think they are undervaluing NZ street artists and making the ratepayers cough up for no reason.” When asked how the New Zealand artists would be paid for their contributions to the festival, Justin Cashell, a member of Dunedin Street Art who also works for Tourism Dunedin as Tactical Branding and Marketing manager, declined to comment. The Dunedin Street Art’s Facebook page also states, “The art will attract people to visit Dunedin and help them really understand us as a city and as a people.” The idea for the festival evolved from the “ripples” created by Belgium artist ROA’s work in Bath Street and Phlegm’s work he completed in April 2014. ROA is renowned for his giant paintings of black and white animals. In March 2013, Critic reported the plans for the Warehouse Precinct’s development for “creative” plans, and it seems the street art project is one of the stepping-stones towards achieving these plans. “It’s not for us to force creativity – it is about creating the spaces in which people can find those synergies and inspirations,” DCC Heritage Planner, Dr Glen Hazelton, told Critic.
The Labour Party has announced the tertiary education policy that they plan to implement if they are elected to government. The policy was released by Labour’s Tertiary Education spokesperson Maryan Street. It promises “a Labour Government will fully review the student support system – including allowances, loans, accommodation support and scholarships – with a view to increasing access and making the system fair, transparent and sustainable.” According to the statement, the first step the Labour government will take is to reinstate the student allowance for postgraduate students and those studying longer degrees, such as Clinical Psychology. They will also remove the restriction for medical and dentistry students on access to student loans after seven years. “New Zealand needs more highly skilled people for a knowledge-based future and preventing postgraduate students from accessing allowances stands in the way of that,” Street says. The statement dubs the abolition of student allowances for postgrads as “a thoughtless and mean initiative of Steven Joyce’s” and claims that some students who were close to the end of their courses have been forced to leave because they could not afford to finish. The statement also announces Labour’s intentions of reinstating post-doctoral fellowships for recent PhD graduates, capping fees at four per cent (but reviewing the cap on enrolments to make it more flexible), reinstating students’ associations, not proceeding with the Education Amendment Bill proposed by National, and reviewing the Tertiary Education Commission “to reinstate its intended strategic purpose, instead of the tick-the-box organisation it has become.” Students have given mixed opinions on the policy. “It’s a step in the right direction,” according to fifth-year Law student Finbarr Noble. “Reinstating Students’ Associations is great, as are the promises not to proceed with the Education Amendment Bill and to restore democracy and autonomy to our universities’ councils,” he said. “That said, I reckon it will take more than just modest commitments to restore people’s faith in tertiary education, particularly university education and its value.” Some were more sceptical. Second-year Commerce and Botany student Cambrian Molark noted that “all of the policies sound like great ideas on the surface, although [Labour] haven’t acknowledged where the money to fund the various schemes will come from … they seem promising for students with little attention paid to the details.”
Cameron Price, Co-Editor of Victoria University’s student magazine Salient, has brutally failed at an attempt to troll the intellects at Critic. Price recently put himself forward for multiple executive positions in the VUWSA (Victoria University of Wellington Student Association) elections for 2015. Price originally applied for the roles of President, Vice-President (Engagement), Equity Officer, Clubs and Activities Officer, and Campaigns Officer. For reasons unknown to Critic, he withdrew from the election soon after. Price then attempted to play Critic for mere fools, insisting he was still running in the campaign, the desired result being that Critic would print a false story. Whilst outlining the likeness he had to Labour hopeful Tamati Coffey, Price assured Critic he was “the change VUWSA needs.” Though he is not putting himself forward to mend the said inefficiencies in VUWSA, he was extremely quick to point out what he believed the current Executive members were doing wrong, or simply not doing at all. “[Throughout VUWSA] personal politics get in the way of pragmatic achievements being made. Too often the idea of consultants and focus groups and stakeholder planning takes over,” he commented. Price states that in 2013 only one thousand students voted in the VUWSA elections. Following this “the resulting Exec got to spend $10,000 of students’ money.” Price believed this was “outrageous” considering that “Salient’s funding remained the same.” It is alleged that VUWSA “don’t get anything done except for a mediocre O-Week and a sausage sizzle now and then.” Although he is not intending to do so himself, Price believes “we can do better than that. Yes we can.” He also had a great deal to say about current VUWSA President, Sonya Clark. Price believes Clark has been “openly endorsing one of the candidates,” who goes by the name of Rick. “Her and Rick had a gentleman’s agreement last year that he wouldn’t run against her, and then he would succeed the next year.” Price believes this is an “undermining of democracy” and “totes inappropes.” Although Price was unsure of how Critic became aware of the story, he said, “If it’s through Sonya you should know she talks a lot of shit. You can print that if you’d like.” Critic was unable to contact Sonya Clark for a comment on Price’s accusations. Nominations for the VUWSA elections closed at 4.30pm last Tuesday. Voting will take place from Wednesday 20 August to Friday 22 August, with winners announced shortly after.
Aoraki Polytechnic continues to record a decline in student numbers, according to figures released by the Tertiary Education Commission. The figures show that Aoraki is losing students at a faster rate than any other New Zealand university or polytechnic. In 2013, numbers dropped from 915 to 664 over the course of the year – a substantial 27.4 per cent. The decline comes at a rough time for Aoraki, after finishing last year with a deficit of three million dollars and a string of redundancies. To make matters worse, Aoraki’s chief competitors in the South – the University of Otago and Otago Polytechnic – both recorded a growth in numbers, defying national trends. However, Aoraki Polytechnic’s CEO Alex Cabrera believes the figures do not accurately reflect Aoraki’s “new focus.” “Aoraki is in the process of transitioning into areas of priority for the region,” states Cabrera, “so our [numbers] do, and will, look different as we work through this process.” Cabrera blames a “buoyant employment market“ for loss of students, with “prospective students securing jobs” instead of beginning or continuing study. “We are making provisions for growth in part-time, flexible, work-based programmes of study to appeal to people already in employment,” states Cabrera. These “provisions” include a cadetship programme, work-based and project-based learning, and a remodelling of the trades programme to now include two days of workplace engagement for every three days of study. In addition, Aoraki plans to introduce a new Diploma in Agribusiness Management and Horticulture, alongside new Painting and Decorating programmes and a “more flexible delivery model” for Carpentry. The Otago Daily Times reported that the Tertiary Education Commission figures only included “student achievement component'' (sac-funded) places and did not account for enrolments by international students, non-Government funded places and students participating in other Government schemes. Otago Polytechnic communications director Mike Waddell reported to the ODT that the “Otago factor” was a key reason for the increase, stating that he believed Otago Polytechnic’s success was largely down to the “quality of the programmes and the quality of the staff.” Sac-funded numbers grew from 2,425 to 2,647 at Otago Polytechnic, while student numbers at Southern Institute of Technology grew from 2695 to 2924. In spite of facing some daunting figures, Aoraki’s Cabrera remains “excited for the future.” “We remain committed to continue to support our community … Aoraki Polytechnic’s focus is on quality education most relevant to the students and industries in the region that we serve.”
Toroa College’s recent upgrade and expansion has gone over budget by even more than previously reported, with the total cost of the refurbishment now being over budget by almost $1 million. As previously found, the extreme difference in cost was recorded as being an error in the estimated cost. The latest University Council meeting, held on the 12 August, stated that an extra $915,000 was spent on the upgrade and expansion of the college, due to “an approved project overrun as a result of a QS error made on the cost estimates for the project.” In last month’s council meeting, the refurbishment of the college was recorded at being only $580,000 for the January to May period. The total cost of the upgrade spent, however, was upwards of $4 million, higher than the $3.01 million that was allocated for the upgrade. The excess $915,000 that was spent on Toroa College and its refurbishments includes the construction of an additional 20 rooms and a larger central common room. This has been in conjunction with the refurbishments carried out at other colleges around campus such as Carrington College and Aquinas College. The refurbishments at the college are the most extensive since the college was first established 18 years ago, with the new common room allowing residents to be able to relax, study, watch television, game and enjoy time with other Toroa residents. The University Council report also revealed that $1.894 million in extra, externally funded research was received due to “greater than expected income from non-reciprocal research.” Departmental and divisional variances of budget were covered during the Council meeting. Major variances in budget were found in the operating costs of the University, with expenditure for the year to date at $297 million, $4.053 million over budget. Laboratory expenses, reference material costs and travel and accommodation expenses accounted for $1.6 million of the variance. $1.7 million of the overspending was due to academic salary costs, due to “higher than expected research activity.” The Health Sciences and (other) Science divisions, respectively, recorded budget blowouts of $1.486 million and $450,000. A lack of tutors and demonstrators was cited as a cause of this overrun of the budget.
A former University of Otago student has been removed as a member of the New Zealand Institute of Chartered Accountants after giving false medical certificates to his former workplace and a fake reference to a recruitment company. At his hearing on 5 August 2014, Simon Michael Collins was found guilty of providing false medical certificates to his former employer. The decision said Collins’ former workplace was to be suppressed. An analysis of his LinkedIn profile indicates that he was working at Deloitte in Christchurch at the time. When questioned about the accusations, he stated he received medical treatment, including surgery, in Timaru during the 11-day period he was absent from work. However, this was proven to be untrue. He also provided to a recruitment company a previous manager as a referee, but used his own home telephone number as the “manager’s” number. It is believed he either gave a telephone reference impersonating his manager or arranged for another person to impersonate him. He also failed to respond in writing to the initial complaint when the discovery of his fraudulent behaviour first came to light. After being found guilty of the charges and as well as being stood down from the NZICA, he has also been ordered to pay $9,348 to cover his court costs. As listed on his LinkedIn profile, it states he had been working for De Lorenzo NZ Ltd since November 2013 as General Manager and also as a Financial Controller for Enzo International Ltd. The hearing decision read “repeated dishonesty is however incompatible with membership of the Institute.” “Professional disqualification is a very rare event. There are 100,000 members of the new combined Australia and New Zealand professional body, CAANZ. That there are so few cases of dishonesty is evidence of the strong professional mores of accountants,” Professor Colin Campbell-Hunt, Head of Department of Accountancy and Finance at Otago University, told Critic. “These people are, after all, put in positions of great trust over the most sensitive of human transactions – money,” Campbell-Hunt continues. As for the strong reputation of Otago’s graduate accountants, Campbell-Hunt does not believe the case of Collins will hinder the reputation of the finest graduates. “We are proud of [the graduates] and the reputation of an Otago degree in these subjects will undoubtedly be influenced far more strongly by them than by the odd bad apple,” says Campbell-Hunt. “Having said that, we are putting more and more energy into lifting the standard of our degree.” “Nobody in this Department is interested in delivering second-class teaching or producing second-class graduates.” Collins was registered as a Provisional Member of the NZICA, which as another Dunedin accountant pointed out means, “he has either (a) never sat his exams to be a full Chartered Accountant or (b) failed the exams.” The process to become a Chartered Accountant usually takes two to three years, costs around $10,000 and includes a six-hour exam.
A 21-year-old male student from Otago Polytechnic has been charged with importing class A and class B controlled drugs. The recent drug haul, which found LSD and MDMA (ecstasy) on Monday 11 August, had an estimated value of between $3,000 and $7,000 for the LSD and approximately $50,000 for the MDMA. Critic spoke to Detective Hamish Barrons of the Southern District Organised Crime Squad about how the product was found. “The arrest was as a result of three importations that were intended for Dunedin," said Barrons. The drugs were sourced online from Germany and the United Kingdom, but were intercepted at the Auckland Mail Centre. This resulted in the surveillance of a PO BOX and two search warrants being executed by Police and Customs. Barrons contends that the drugs were for a commercial enterprise. He believes they were intended for mixing with other products and sold in capsules on the Dunedin market. The student is facing a number of other charges in connection to the drug seize on top of charges for importing Class A and B drugs, and is possibly looking at a number of years in prison. Drug Foundation Executive Director Ross Bell described the drug haul as unusual in terms of LSD. "They're not commonly seen in New Zealand; there is not a huge market for LSD but it seems to be beginning to see a comeback," he said. Bell remarked that this kind of drug find is quite rare, but spoke of the health risks of the student market that drugs were likely intended for. "We are going to end up with a lot of novice users or people who do not know how to stay safe ... People need to be careful." The ecstasy was seized in a crystalline form, but it is thought that this would be "cut down" and mixed with undesirable products. It is worth about $450 per gram in the crystalline form. The student appeared in the Dunedin District Court on Tuesday morning. The standard sentence for this level of drug importation depends on the person’s criminal history. "The thing is that he is only 21 but dealing with drugs in such high quantities. He will probably end up with a pretty harsh sentence," said Bell. "This will affect everything; his employment, his travel, for the rest of his life. That is the reality." Bell reminds those who do choose to take drugs, such as LSD and ecstasy, to do so in a safe environment and to be in the right frame of mind. He also pointed out that when dealing with ecstasy to do so in moderation, especially those doing it for the first time. Karen Heine from OUSA Student Support urges those with issues to seek support. "People can absolutely come to Student Support to have a chat about what they're going through and the various avenues of support available to them," she said.
This week we go to the Weirwood and Valyrian steel football desk where over the past few years our two favourite things to illegally stream online have been HBO’s violent, softcore-pornography drama, Game of Thrones, and the less violent but equally awesome male soap-opera that is the English Premier League. While the next season of Game of Thrones is still many, many months away the 2014/15 Premier League has just kicked off so to get in the mood for the season ahead we have put together an unexpected mashup, recapping the events of the last few seasons of both “games.” These days, spoilers are viewed as a crime worthy of beheading so readers beware: Spoiler Alert! Spoiler Alert! Spoiler Alert! House Lannister of Manchester City “Hear Me Roar” The Lannisters have a precarious hold on power in Westeros owing much to their political machinations and the deep pockets of overseas financiers. This is very similar to the recent rise of Manchester City, whose Middle-Easton owners have financed the purchase of many sell-swords who have helped City to the Premier League title in 2012 and 2014. If City boss Manuel Pellegrini doesn’t deliver continued success he might meet the same unfortunate fate as patriarch Tywin Lannister. Manchester City retain the services of their “King Slayer” Sergio Aguero who will always be remembered for his injury time goal that won them the Premier League in 2012, ripping it out of the hands of their bitter rivals, Manchester United. Also amongst their ranks is everyone’s favourite little imp, David Silva. “A Lannister always pays his debts” is a well known line from the show and Manchester City have had to make good on this pledge by paying a £49 million pound fine as punishment for breaching the rules of financial fair play. House Targaryen of Liverpool “Fire and Blood” The Targaryens ruled Westeros for many years before being knocked off their perch by the Baratheon usurpers. Similarly, Liverpool ruled the roost in England for many years before the introduction of the Premier League saw their power decline to the benefit of their great rival, Manchester United. The young but strong-willed Daenerys Targaryen has spent previous seasons breaking chains and recruiting new soldiers from Qarth to Mereen whilst nurturing her young dragons: the temperamental Drogon and his siblings Rhaegal and Viserion. The young but strong-willed Liverpool boss, Brendan Rodgers, has been on a similar recruitment drive of his own from Portugal to Germany while also nurturing his own young dragons, last season’s temperamental top scorer Suarez and his understudies Sturridge and Sterling. At the end of last season Daenerys was heartbroken to learn that Drogon had killed the innocent daughter of a goat herder and has since disappeared, whereabouts unknown. During the World Cup, Rodgers was equally heartbroken to learn that Suarez had bitten the innocent shoulder of yet another opponent and has since disappeared, transferred to Barcelona. House Tyrell of Chelsea “Growing Strong” The Tyrells are a modest House with only a limited amount of recent success of which to brag about. Much like Chelsea in the capital of London, the Tyrells’ current power and status in the capital of Kings Landing is derived through their money and shrewd political machinations. Despite Chelsea’s recent emergence as a powerful player, they lack the respect of the wider footballing community just as no one truly respects the Tyrells, criticising both for being nouveau-riche usurpers. Both the Tyrells and Chelsea have had to enter into marriages of convenience for their long-term benefit and survival. Margaery and Loras have been pimped out to the Baratheons and Lannisters to help solidify the Tyrells’ positions of power in the same way that Mata and Lukaku were sent north to United and Everton at different times to try and take away points of Chelsea’s more immediate title rivals. Although her half-witted son Mace is the head of House Tyrell it is the canny old Matriarch Olenna Tyrell who is really pulling the strings. Her subtle but effective playing of the "Game of Thrones" is par excellence with the brilliance of Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho who plays the Premier League mind games better than anyway and constantly gets the half-witted Chelsea owner, Roman Abramovich, to stump up the cash to help the team keep “Growing Strong.” House Martell of Arsenal “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” Oberyn Martell arrived in the capital at the start of last season full of swagger and memorable one-liners. Much the same way Arsene Wenger and his Arsenal side started their season, leading the table for the majority of the season and over the busy Christmas period. In Oberyn’s “trial by combat” with “The Mountain” he gained the upper hand in the early stages and we all thought he was destined for victory until his ego got in the way; instead of finishing off The Mountain he insisted that The Mountain confess to the rape and murder of his sister. This lead to Oberyn suffering a skull crushing defeat that came as quite the shock to the disbelieving audience. This was reflected in Arsenal’s eventual downfall. The team on top of the table after Christmas and New Year has historically gone on to win the title but, like Oberyn, Wenger got a little too cocky and refused to splash the cash in the January transfer window as his ego is built on consistent success without the big spending of his rivals. He refused to purchase another striker and Arsenal ran out of steam and ended up suffering a soul crushing defeat that came as quite a shock to their disbelieving fans. House Stark of Tottenham Hotspur “Winter is Coming” While the cockerel mascot of Tottenham Hotspur isn’t nearly as intimidating as the Direwolf sigil of House Stark there are many similarities between the two nonetheless. The Starks fight to maintain control of the North of Westeros while Spurs find themselves constantly under siege in their seat of power in the North of London. Like the honourable and much liked Ned and Robb Stark, recent Spurs managers Andre Villas-Boas and Tim Sherwood have met the same fate as their honourable Stark counterparts, all of these beheadings coming as an untimely shock to their respective audiences. In recent seasons Jon Snow, the Starks’ best swordsmen, decided he wasn’t fitting in at Winterfell and decided to “take the black” and head north to join the Night’s Watch on the “The Wall.” Similarly, the very popular Gareth Bale, Spurs’ best striker, decided he wasn’t fitting in at White Hart Lane and decided to “take the white” and head south to join the Los Blancos in Real Madrid. With the loss of Bale many Spurs fans feared the often mentioned winter had finally arrived and with most of their elders dead or sold, both Spurs and the Starks will be relying on their plucky younger generations to fly the flag. House Baratheon of Manchester United “Ours is the Fury” In Robert Baratheon and Sir Alex Ferguson you had a fat, red-nosed drunk in charge of a respected House/club. They were both past their prime when they passed the crown to their illegitimate heirs, Joffrey and David Moyes, who both proved to be unfit leaders that were universally despised as a King and a manager, one for being generally sadistic and the other for being generally incompetent. Their time on the throne was cut short, being poisoned out of the top job by those close to the throne. New United boss Louis van Gaal will need to have a major internal shake up to bring back the fury that made United so feared and revered. While Wayne Rooney is as dumb as Hodor, he is also the Stannis of Man United. Urged on by his greedy Melisandre-esque wife, Coleen, Rooney claims that he is the rightful heir to the captaincy of the United and England teams. However, many people disrespect him and his claim, accusing him of being unfit to lead because he is overpaid and underperforming.
Since I’ve already featured an article in which I followed Clare Curran around for an afternoon, I figured it was only fair to take a look at two of the other people vying for the spot: Hamish Walker of the National Party and Shane Gallagher of the Greens. Initially, I was hoping to host a debate between the two of them, but Hamish is a very busy man and ended up being unable to make it. My dreams of a verbal swordfight were shattered. He emailed me answers instead. I still spoke to Shane, however, and gave him the opportunity to respond to some of the things Hamish said. In case you’re thinking “BIAS,” one way or the other (inevitable), think of it like this: Hamish got the day to mull over his responses and present them in a written format (and the last question was only asked of him); Shane got the last word and was able to hear some of Hamish’s responses. If Hamish wants to respond to anything Shane has said, he is invited to write a letter to Critic. For ease of reading, they’re presented as follows: Shane’s answer to question, Hamish’s answer to question, Shane’s response to Hamish. What are some initiatives you have to improve employment for people in Dunedin South? Shane: Well, we have a range of issues, ‘cause we try to approach everything holistically, so the headline things are: the $1b research and development fund, which is looking at industries that are green and sustainable; one of the key areas that Dunedin could be looking at there is biofuel, so biofuel development. We have a lot of woody fuel, with the city forests. I know that Celsius, which is a New Zealand biofuel company that’s now gone overseas because it wasn’t able to get the venture capital, wanted to base one of its processing plants here in Dunedin, but wasn’t able to raise the funding. […] We’ve also got IT design, the Green Investment Bank, which we’re proposing, so people come up with innovative ideas of their own, then get loans from that. Hamish: I would love to see more opportunities for people (and high school students in particular) to try work experience across a number of different businesses and industries in Dunedin South. […] We also need to make it easier for students to get work once they graduate. I would like to see more students placed into internships during study where more “real world” experience is gained and gives students that experience. […] After six years of a National Government, we now have more youth engaged in education, training or apprenticeships now, than ever before. […] Ministry of Employment, Innovation and Business estimate the 90-day trial introduced a couple of years ago has resulted in an extra 13,000 jobs, mainly to people who wouldn’t have been given that opportunity under old employment law. Shane’s Response: Well the 90-day trial hasn’t improved any jobs, it hasn’t given anyone extra jobs; it just means employers are more likely to sack you. It doesn’t actually create jobs, this is some sort of fallacy that you have some sort of change in the way you can employ someone and suddenly this magically creates jobs. Jobs are created by stimulus in the economy, activity in the economy, and so the idea that you can magically create jobs by changing the working conditions is not tenable; it makes no sense. And unless there’re actual jobs there, in the economy, how can you transition to them from education? Again, it’s just not joining the dots, there’s no sense to that, there’s no continuity. [In-study internships] might be an okay idea, but [since 1988] […] people’s wages have remained flat while productivity has massively increased, and that money’s gone somewhere, and we know where, it’s gone to the very top, because that’s what’s driven inequality in New Zealand. So the thing that drives economies is you need to start getting money into people’s pockets so that they can spend, so you want to increase the wages, so you need to increase minimum wage and get them working on a living wage, cause people shouldn’t have to subsist on a wage they simply cannot live on in order to boost the profits of a company. […] What about businesses? What do you plan to do to help them? Hamish: I would like to see more interaction between businesses in Dunedin. Networking between different businesses through local business associations/groups/employers association allows them to work together on common problems and that can only be a good thing. Moreover, I would also like to see these groups working with students more. The transition between university and work would be smoother, not only for the student, but more so for the employer if they have more say on what they want from students upon graduation. Shane’s Response: I mean, [networking between businesses] is one of those catchphrases that actually means nothing, and one of the things they could have done, for instance, was ensure that Hillside Workshops actually were able to build trains. Because when you take jobs away and hand them off to China or hand them off to Spain or wherever, you’re taking away jobs and you’re taking away money within the economy. So Hillside Workshops did a lot of subcontracting to engineering companies throughout the whole of South Dunedin, and South Dunedin is a major engineering hub, and it has always been one of those hidden secrets; those open secrets that no one really knows about. But Hillside Workshops was a really major engineering hub, and now that has been taken away, you’ve torn out the heart of the engineering sector in Dunedin. It’s still there but it’s struggling. Another issue for Dunedin South is poverty, as many of the population hubs in the electorate are dense and poor. What do you plan to do to help people who’re struggling? Shane: Again, we’ve got a lot of policies, which line up together or come together as jigsaw pieces, so again we want to raise the minimum wage, we want to get people being paid the living wage, we want to reduce costs by reducing people’s power bills, we want to extend the insulation scheme. […] And by also introducing our NZ Power idea we can actually reduce people’s power bills by $300 a year. […] If people are healthier and happier and have a bit more money in their pockets that stimulates your society and your economy. We also have the Carbon Tax: we’re going to give people a tax cut, and it’s a $2000 tax-free allowance that will basically mean you get an extra $300 a year. It doesn’t sound like a huge amount, but again, with the savings from your reduced power bills and increased spending power from being able to have a decent wage through a minimum wage job, these things all add up. Hamish: I will work with a number of different agencies to get a good stock take of what the main problems are out there. I will then lobby for the needs of the people of Dunedin South. […] I will be talking to different groups, for example church groups, community groups, and other organisations to see where we can help each other out. The Student Army is one example of the benefits the community can achieve when it comes together. I have also visited community hubs in Dunedin South where people struggling to put food on the table meet regularly for play groups and soup kitchens. These hubs are doing great things for the community and families involved. Shane’s Response: Again, he’s denying the fact that these are systemic problems created by his government. I mean, they’ve created the situation in Dunedin where we have poor jobs; we’ve lost 44,000 jobs in the manufacturing industry alone. And Price Waterhouse Coopers has estimated that if we went down the green sector route, the green industrial route, that that could be worth $22b a year to us as an economy. […] The balance between local government and national government in Dunedin is complex, and often leaves initiatives and people falling through the cracks. How would you increase the efficacy and efficiency of the relationship between local and national government? Shane: Well, we need to actually start talking to local government on a real level. One of the interesting conversations I had with Mayor Cull was that when they met with the Minister for Local Government that they were uniquely unimpressed by his dismissive and aggressive attitude, that he was basically telling them how to do their jobs. And what we really want to do is partner with local government, ‘cause local government can have a lot of initiatives, and they come up with the local solutions. […] Hamish: It’s important to have a good working relationship with the mayor and councillors and be fully briefed on what’s happening in the district. I need to be fully aware of the local council and what they are doing and what their aspirations are for Dunedin South. Shane’s Response: Again, look at the track record of what National’s done. We had Environment Canterbury turn around and say ‘we don’t like what you’re doing’; then the National Government simply abolished democracy in Canterbury because they didn’t like what ECAN were telling them. […] There’s not an environment in which local government and national government have trust in each other because any local government body now always has to second-guess themselves about if it is going to upset the National government. Let’s again look at the record, because the record is pretty poor on this matter. With regards to providing facilities for the community, who should do what is often difficult to ascertain. What do you believe your role would and should be in this context? Hamish: I will work tirelessly and dedicate myself 100 per cent to the people of Dunedin South. The people will identify the facilities they need and I will lobby forcefully on their behalf. While we are on the topic of community facilities, I would love to see a facility in Dunedin South where youth have somewhere to hang out during the weekends (especially in the evenings), which will keep a number of them out of trouble.
Greatest HitWithout a doubt, Greatest Hit this week goes to Nicky Hager, who has created what can only be described as a “shitstorm” in response to the publication of his new book. Prior to its release, the hilarious Twitter speculation alone was enough to warrant it this prized award; but Dirty Politics, released Wednesday 13 August, one-upped its anticipation by being entirely full of juicy scandals about some of our most beloved politicians and political commentators. Whale Oil was thoroughly unimpressed. Greatest ShitWinston always says that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, but it’s hard to be stoked when AUSA hits Yahoo NZ with a story they copied from Critic. Essentially, using our supreme and complex analysis, they too figured out how much it would cost certain politicians if they went to university today. They even presented some of them with certificates. Unfortunately, they managed to get Steven Joyce’s cost wrong, undercharging him by about $2000. Presumably, this is because they fatally forgot to include miscellaneous Massey fees in their costing.
Following reports from past and present students from the University of Otago Halls of Residence, Critic has spoken to numerous parties to address complaints regarding hall life. A number of students have reported to Critic that their time at their hall is “cliquey,” “lonely” and “not safe enough.” As well as this, students and Student Support report that rules appear to be getting stricter each year, but in all the wrong ways. A resident of Arana said that he agreed with the comments made regarding hall regulations and that despite the same levels of alcohol being consumed each year, the rules turn the halls into “a bit of a prison.” Critic spoke to Advocate & Student Representative Coordinator Philippa Keaney, who said that Student Support gets “quite a few reports” from unhappy students at the halls. She said that there was “definitely” an issue with loneliness across all the halls, but this is understandable considering it is many students’ first time away from home. However, she agreed with the issue of certain halls, particularly the more prestigious halls, having a higher rate of “cliquey” attitudes. She said, “Loneliness and cliquey-ness are two very different things.” She does not notice the same issue with students who flat together, whether first years or not, “the only social issue with flatting really is not getting along.” A large part of the issue may be from certain halls excluded themselves from general first year events. For example, holding their own Toga parties, separate to the rest of the University events. OUSA Colleges Officer Jess McLean points out that OUSA continues to promote clubs and recreation as “a great way to get out and meet new people.” Acknowledgement needs to be given to the fact that these first year students are living within the atmosphere of this “clique-ness” though and, as Jess says, “it can be like a mini high school sometimes!” Director of Accommodation Services James Lindsay says the University is unaware of the reputation of Knox, Arana and Selwyn have as having a superiority complex over other halls. “However a perception that each college is different could be held by students themselves. Some colleges do, for example, tend to attract a majority of students studying particular courses, such as health sciences or teaching.” He says that this may “lead to the establishment of a different character or culture for each of the colleges that mirrors the predominant mix of students.” Keaney believes the only way for the halls to address the superiority issue is to “diversify the intake.” She says that, for example, situations like at Knox, where there are students “whose parents, aunties, uncles, etc.” have attended the hall, “just adds to the issue.” Keaney also said that the safety of women in the halls was a major issue: “It’s like they pretend nothing even happens.” She said that there is no form of advice in the hall handbooks and a solid policy needed to be in place. Keaney said that at meetings with Lindsay and the former Colleges Officer Brydie Ockwell, the halls defended themselves saying that the Residential Assistants were trained in dealing with incidents. Keaney says training the RAs is “just not good enough” and that there needs to be a consistent policy across the halls. OUSA are supposed to be working on a policy, but with the change in Executive Rep, they are still waiting on a draft. Jess said the hall policy on sexual assault “is moving forward” and plans on meeting with Student Support later this week. In regards to the students who were recently asked to leave Unicol, there were rumours that the students’ rooms were actively searched whilst they were on holiday. The Proctor said that it was “absolutely not policy” to search peoples’ rooms “without an absolutely cast iron reason.” He says, “it is a student’s home,” but individual rules are with the Halls depending on what was signed in the contract. Lindsay said that cleaning services are required each week to enter rooms when students are not present; “also college staff may enter rooms for health and safety reasons when a student leaves for semester breaks, for example.” He said that this is done to check heaters or lights are not left on, or windows are not left open. “If a smell of cannabis is detected, staff will act to check the source to ensure no illegal activity is taking place on the premises.” Another student complained of some halls blocking certain websites. In response to a Facebook post, he said “even though they're paying $300ish a week for the privilege of their own room they're not allowed to watch BangBus4 the Re-Bangening in the privacy and comfort of their own bedrooms.” He adds, “It just seems a somewhat too paternalistic view to take towards young adults, especially when they're the ones paying the bills.” A resident at Cumberland said she felt the early kick-out time was “endangering us.” She explained that in the freezing winter months, being kicked out of the hall at 9pm meant students were taking bottles to the park and drinking there, “just relying on our alcohol blankets when we’re preloading.” Keaney said that this was “really irresponsible for [the halls] to do.” She was aware that some halls had that policy in place but may only loosely follow it. Students at a number of halls confirmed that the rule was firmly enforced at several other halls. The Cumberland resident said that, if she were home, she would be allowed to responsibly drink in the house and their hall is supposed to be “a home away from home.” Critic asked if the University would support a move to encourage halls to allow drinking in the dining halls later in the evenings. University of Otago Director of Accommodation Services Mr James Lindsay said,“Rules about alcohol consumption in Colleges are in place for good reasons … Experience of running these colleges shows that not all college residents drink alcohol, and nor are they comfortable with the consumption of alcohol by others next or near to them.” He adds, “Some colleges already allow alcohol to be consumed at certain times … all regulations are tailored to the character of each different college community.” Jess said, “If there was a demand for it [from students] then OUSA would be interested in discussing a better solution with the colleges, especially as the North Dunedin bar scene has changed and colleges are a safer place.” As a resident at St Margaret’s, she believes her hall deals with it well: “They don’t restrict times when alcohol can be consumed, instead they have repercussions if you can’t use it responsibly.” Knox was widely known as one of the heaviest-drinking Halls of Residence affiliated with the University, but it appears that since the change of Master, the hall has gone “from one extreme to the other,” says Keaney. Residents who misbehave at Knox are required to buy New World vouchers for the OUSA food bank. Keaney says, “Now we are overwhelmed with New World vouchers.” She believes it has almost gotten too strict, with some students being punished for talking too loudly on the phone when coming back from a night on the town. “Friends are having to sneak their drunk mates in back from town. Their mates who also live at the hall.” It believes it has almost created an “underbelly of drinking.” A former Knox student, who was a resident in 2009 and 2010, said residents were “encouraged to drink with our friends over dinner [as a] a way to encourage us to drink in a positive way.” He also attended Unicol, which he says “was an equally great time but different.” Critic spoke to the Proctor, who said, “You don’t booze after tea.” He believes that allowing students to drink in the hall until 9pm is “very generous.” He explains that trying to get Halls to allow students in the dining hall to drink would pose “a huge problem” with the much bigger halls. He said that, “at the end of the day, the attitude of just getting smashed before town needs to change.” He explained that “years ago we would have all gone drinking and then hopped in a car. No one would do that now. We just have to change attitudes.” He suggests that students go to town earlier so town isn’t starting at midnight and can get going at 9pm instead. The former Knox student believes that it is a shame Knox is heading down “the same road as the other halls.” He says, “including Knox these days, they are resorting to just putting a blanket over the issue of alcohol.” He says everyone is kicked out at 10pm at Unicol regardless of their drinking level. At the same time, he said, “It was pretty unbelievable what we got away with. They went too far trying to enforce rules.” He says, “I could have walked in with two bottles of vodka and would have got away with it. I understand that is probably not a good idea either.” The University clearly holds a favourable look on all of the Halls but speaking to a number of students and with OUSA it is clear that there are still many issues to address, especially in terms of the wellness of first year students. We all know that the issue of where freshers drink needs to be addressed, particularly with student bars closing down. RAs cannot be expected to deal with the sexual assault process, and Halls should be helping, not hindering, students with getting involved with the rest of the University. OUSA Colleges Officer Jess McLean says, “We would ask anyone who is having any issues to get in touch with OUSA Student Support.”