Opinion
40 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 4.
-
News
Issue 9 27/04/2025Opinion: The OUSA Referendum Has Been Very Poorly Advertised
Hear ye, hear ye! OUSA referendum question submissions are open and will close on the 2nd of May. That’s really fucking soon – so whip out your thinking caps and email Vice-Pres Amy Martin (adminvp@ousa.org.nz) with all the questions you can think of!
-
News
Issue 9 27/04/2025Opinion: The Mid-semester Conspiracy That The Clocktower Doesn’t Want You To Know About
It’s a tale as old as time (or 1869 at least): slumped in a chair in your first lecture post mid-semester break, you see your UC mate’s story. There he is, week two into his three-week break, cracking a beer or doing whatever tragic standard ‘fun’ is for an engineer.
-
Culture
Issue 5 23/03/2025Opinion: Chlöe Swarbrick is still a politician
As a child, my parents were Labour voters and to me that seemed like the moral choice. John Key’s National government at the time did not have their best interests at heart as they prioritised wealth over wellbeing. New Zealand First, headed at the time by an old Winston Peters, appealed more to my grandparents. Meanwhile, Act was on no one's radar; it was that space filled by centrist Peter Dunne flip-flopping for power. This meant in my youth I was a Labour supporter. The parties I support now, Greens and Māori, were not something younger me considered for when I would hypothetically vote. This was due to the lack of Māori presence in Dunedin at the time, and Greens’ love for nature did not appeal to me at a time where I did not understand what climate change was. As I grew older, I saw the cracks in the system but there was one politician using the kintsugi method to fill those cracks with gold: Chlöe Swarbrick.
-
Columns
Issue 16 28/07/2024Editorial: Kmart Gives Me the Ick
I hate to be a hater, but the opening of Kmart and its cult following made me a bit disappointed. This comes with the big fat disclaimer that, yes, the tracksuit on the cover of the issue was bought from Kmart, and yes, I am wearing the slippers I bought while I was there. And I’m never going back. It was an awful experience.
-
Culture
Issue 0 19/02/2024Nut Up or Shut Up: Why Halls Should Go Vegetarian
The way halls work right now, with opt-in veggies but obligate meats, is completely backwards.
-
Culture
Issue 18 07/08/2023OPINION: Everyone dresses queer now and it’s fucking with my gaydar
Gaydar is a magical thing. It gives us queer folk the ability to pick up on little hints and clues that can guide our flirtatious approach, and since the 1940s and 1950s fashion has been one of the best ways to sense someone’s queerness. Docs, work wear, chunky rings, and suits were some of the wardrobe staples that queer women used to signify they’re down for flamboyant freakiness. Not only were these fashion statements vital in sending signals to the gaydar, but they were also vital for the growth of queer culture at a time when homophobia was rampant, police brutality was high, and being gay was a crime. As much as the gaydar was a way of navigating romance, it was also a survival tactic. Fast forward to today, and it seems that many ladies are embracing these queer-coded styles as well as dressing in more gender non-conforming clothes, which has its roots in the butch/femme dynamic. I’m sure the pioneers of queer fashion are proud of this, and so am I, but you have to respect the communities who did it first and have been owning it for eternity. These “trends” have been celebrated and used to display membership in a community that has been marginalised for a long-ass time, and now it is becoming removed from sexual identity and put in the fast fashion trend cycle. I know most women wouldn’t put on a pair of pants and wonder, “What is the history of these?”, ‘cos that’s a little nutty, but a lot of gay women fought hard to get to the point where we are now, so wear them with pride. “Looking gay” or “dressing gay” may not be an insult or a threat anymore, but it was for a long time. Don’t forget it. This is by no means a dig at the straight ladies – y’all are out here looking HOT and being cool. It is just an observation of subcultures starting out fringe, and then fringe becoming mainstream. This happens with all things fashion, all things trendy, and all things cool, and there (hopefully) isn’t anything malicious about it from straight girls. Generally, it's just something that isn’t considered. A lot of this is actually coming from a place of anti-homophobia: there are a lot more queer fashion icons able to be visibly queer, and both straight girlies and gay girlies are taking inspiration. However, there is one small problem with the straight girlies embracing queer-coded fashion: it’s fucking with my gaydar. The queer community has always been ahead of the curve when it comes to fashion. We’re not afraid to stand out, but with the cyclic nature of trends speeding up, mainstream fashion is catching up with us. The oversized blazers and low rise jeans on the Glassons racks now emulate the queer fashion seen in the ‘50s, ‘60s, and ‘90s. This shows an epic acceptance of gender fluidity in today’s society, but cutting out the queer has really screwed over the science behind the gaydar. Modern queer signalling has been little things like carabiners on keys, high socks, cuffed or baggy jeans, or jorts; the list goes on. But now that all of these styles have been embraced by the straight girlies, how do I know who to hit on? You may be thinking, “Uhh, just ask?”, but it is still sometimes a scary space being queer, especially when it comes to navigating the world of dating. You want to be pretty certain that the person you’re about to hit on is going to be into it, as does anyone. I understand that this is a risk in all dating, sometimes people just don’t click, but to not even know if the person is into you on a biological level? Now that is outright terrifying. Not to mention the pop-culture trope of predatory queerness. No one wants to make anyone uncomfortable, and no one, especially queer people, want to be labelled as a creep for simply approaching a person of interest in a not-straight manner. Even if 9 times out of 10 someone will simply say, “Sorry, I just don’t swing that way,” the slight chance of being ridiculed or worse literally plagues my nightmares. And this is why I rely on gaydar. While I love to see women out here embracing wearing whatever the fuck they want, this movement of queer-coded clothing becoming popular has done a number on my gaydar’s ability. The days of reliable gaydar for women are slowly fading. Please let us gatekeep some things: maybe carabiners? Pinky rings? We’ve lost the war on baggy jeans, but maybe jorts? As Marlene Dietrich said, “I dress for the image. Not for myself, not for the public, not for fashion, not for men.” At the end of the day dress how you want, and do it with pride. But if you’re dressing with the gay swag, don’t blame me if I hit on you.
-
Culture
Issue 16 24/07/2023OPINION: Gaslighting is totally normal, actually. (a response)
Gaslighting is totally normal, and I can’t believe you didn’t know that. Assuming you’re a loyal Critic reader, I’m sure you know all about gaslighting by now. We can’t seem to publish an issue without mentioning the word, and we even ran a feature earlier this year wholly dedicated to it. It had its merits and was definitely memorable, but I hated to see such a benign and commonplace topic demonised in this manner, which is why I felt motivated to write a response. Generally speaking, students are a pretty well-educated population, so you’ll trust me when I say this: Gaslighting is normal. Duh. Gaslighting is so normal, in fact, that it was Merriam-Webster’s word of 2022. I won’t patronise you by defining it, since you really should know what it means by now. Okay, well, to spare you the embarrassment of messing it up in front of your friends like you always seem to, gaslighting is persistent deception for one’s own gain, usually characterised by causing the “victim” to question their memories, perception, or even sanity. That’s where my issues with the prior Critic article come in – it characterised a lot of manipulation as gaslighting when it was just that: manipulation. Manipulation is extraordinarily commonplace – a lot of normal social etiquette involves manipulation. When you want the last slice of cake, how often do you actually say so? Versus being like, “So who wants the last piece?” In older generations it’s even worse: how many times have you watched your mum and aunty do the whole, “Oh, that was delicious but I’m so full, you have it” ritual. Just eat the fucking sponge, Sandra. See what I mean? Good, I figured. If every day social manipulation is this dance of reading between the lines, then gaslighting is when you leave no space between said lines and blame the other person for not magically getting it. That’s where my main argument against Critic lies, which I’m sure you’ve spotted by now. The Uni isn’t “gaslighting” us – bureaucratic PR jargon is as nonsensical to them as it is to us. If it’s intended to be misinterpreted and you fall into the trap of misinterpretation, then maybe it’s your fault and you should watch where you’re stepping. Anyway, what’s a little manipulation just between friends? Don’t tell me you’ve never pranked one of the bros, or told the bestie that her outfit is a slay when it’s barely even a flesh wound. In a lot of these cases it’s character-building, and you’re just looking out for them in the long run. For it to be “gaslighting”, some kind of power dynamic must be involved. If you have that much power over your loved ones, or they have that much power over you, then maybe you should reconsider your relationships. You should take a long, hard look at your friends anyway. Maybe you spend too much time with them – it really can’t be good for you. You’re in therapy, right? Gaslighting is not only normal, it’s normalised. Like a lot of terms adopted into pop psychology and colloquial language, the meaning of the word has become desaturated over time. The word’s origin is the 1940 film noir Gaslight, which details an elaborate murder cover-up. The perpetrator convinces his new wife that she’s high-strung and hysterical as she “imagines” seeing the gas lamps flicker downstairs, when really the dancing flames are a result of him sneaking into the house while searching for his previous victim’s possessions. No one believes her, and it gets to the point where she’s almost institutionalised. This intentional and systematic pattern of abuse, the very questioning of one’s sanity, is almost unrecognisable from the way we use the word “gaslight” today. In reality, the things we currently refer to as “gaslighting” are relatively harmless, commonplace, and easily avoidable. If you’re reading this, you’ve probably been studying for a while, and have a good amount of media literacy. Basically, you should know better than to misappropriate the word, and you should know better than to fall for the method. True gaslighting involves a longform pattern of abusing trust, for predetermined benefit for a party with power or status. Admittedly, this trust can be minor, like a media source you generally like, and the benefit can be as simple as shitposting for pay. Gaslighting can make you question your sanity and even plant false memories – say, for example, writing a response to an article that never existed. Trust no one. Question everything. And remember: gaslighting sucks, and I can’t believe I almost made you think otherwise. This must be so embarrassing for you.
-
Culture
Issue 13 29/05/2023Opinion: Nepotism: It’s okay if it’s tradition!
Exam season may be daunting but, remember, if old mate Charlie can succeed the throne at the overripe age of 74 and still not know his allocated lines, then you can walk off that B+ with your head held high.
-
Culture
Issue 12 21/05/2023Opinion: Busking Needs a Glow-Up
As a timid fourteen-year-old, I wanted to go busking in town with my ukulele. Ignoring the fact that a ukulele is a terrible busking instrument, I quickly found myself in a swamp of bureaucratic bereavement which only subsided after I gave up on my musical dreams forever. Granted, I was a terrible musician. But what if there was a better way? What if any half-wit with an instrument could get out onto the street and find an adoring or equally hateful audience?
-
Culture
Issue 3 12/03/2023Nut Up or Shut Up: Why Halls Should Go Vegetarian
The way halls work right now, with opt-in veggies but obligate meats, is completely backwards.
-
Culture
Issue 1 26/02/2023Opinion: Critic Te Ārohi Will Be Covering The Election This Year
For those of you too young to remember, or those who need a memory jog, Critic Te Ārohi made the decision to not cover the 2020 general election on the basis that party politicians had “nothing more to offer students than a shrivelled pea.” The decision received an extensive amount of criticism because Critic has a long history of being politically engaged, especially during elections. But the reasons were a bit more nuanced than they seemed.
-
Culture
Issue 1 27/02/2022Luude’s remix of Down Under changed my opinion of Drum and Bass
Last year I published a scathing opinion piece about how we need to stop playing so much drum and bass music and why the genre is inherently shit. The article copped a lot of hate and elicited an angry response from Dunedin’s breatha population, but it went on to win an award, so suck on that. I was subject to ruthless Facebook comments about how “fucking stupid” my opinion was, how I didn’t have taste, and that I thought I was too hot for DnB and needed to get my head out of my arse. However, I must admit, over the past few weeks my feelings have changed. What sparked that change? Nothing else but Luude's DnB remix of “Down Under”, the iconic Australian anthem by Men At Work.