Guy McCallum
Columnist
Articles by Guy McCallum
16 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 2.
-
NewsIssue 5 23/03/2014
Young Politician | Issue 05
For ACT, making a difference is what we’re interested in. Not disrupting debate, like Young Labour’s twit who wrote in this column last. There are people who work for nothing, providing fine services to the vulnerable and voiceless, and he thinks making a difference is following John Key about, making his ministers cry. He says so with no shame. No surprises, though. His party leader wants to take control, for instance, from communities, parents, and children, who are presently making a difference with help from Partnership Schools. Many from struggling communities of Northland want these schools; but Labour promises to snatch them away, all because the tantrums of unions stood in for compelling argument. ACT stands for handing control over our lives and communities back to where they belong instead of in the hands of the Government, whichever party that may be. In our individual lives, and in the life of our communities, the real differences are made from our own efforts. ACT gets it. Labour doesn’t want you to.
-
ColumnsIssue 26 06/10/2013
The Preachings of a Liberal | Opinion
Since this is my last year at university, and my last column for Critic, it seems fitting to use this space to impart some of the wisdom that I have obtained over the years. This wisdom is the end product of my various achievements – and numerous disappointments – first as a Christian, and a socialist, and now as an atheist, a libertarian, and a gay man. Nothing has changed since the first post: I still love liberty. For in an environment of liberty, thoughtful people are released from the shackles of convention and are forced not only to contemplate, but also to pursue, the good life. Here are six life lessons such an environment has taught me: 1. Don’t take advantage of someone’s ignorance; be honest. Deceit is undoubtedly expedient in certain situations, but love and meaningful accomplishments are built on foundations of trust. For that reason, treat your own trust as sacred and revocable. Walk away from abuse. 2. Exercise your own judgement, but do not lean blindly on your own opinion. Remember that your judgement will only ever be as good as the information you have and know you can trust. 3. Let every decision you make sustain or invigorate your creative potential, or inspire creativity in others. The creation of goods and services helps people. Free markets will not automatically take care of such requirements, and the state sure as hell won’t get it right. 4. Trade. Do not take without giving or, at the very least, offering something in return. Of course we sometimes get stuck and need help, so by all means ask, but always be ready to give back. 5. Do no harm, speak up for the downtrodden, and stand in solidarity with your fellow humans. This one always got me in trouble at school, and I have never looked back in regret. 6. Think about things. Don’t just take my word for it – or anyone else’s, for that matter. And while you may believe you are at the centre of everything, take a moment to remind yourself that you live on a giant ball of iron whizzing through a crowded cosmos. Congratulations to this year’s graduands. Having experienced some of the real world myself, I realise that all of this – as is the case with any advice – will be easy to forget, and will be subject to exceptions. That is why we must always practice thinking about the major things, as well as the minor. Thanks for reading!
-
ColumnsIssue 25 29/09/2013
OUSA Election Forums | Opinion
I wasn’t surprised that the questions raised at the Presidential Forum centred around three main themes: participation, finances and OUSA’s role in campus life. Jordan seemed to be the odd one out. Someone (I suspect a friend of his) asked him whether OUSA should, like the modern-day state, be charged with overseeing welfare issues. Jordan responded by arguing that while student welfare is important, we must avoid spending excessively in such areas. He was also of the opinion (and was the first of the candidates to make his position on the issue clear) that OUSA should be more politically neutral. Finally, he believed that a new student pub would constitute a financial liability, and therefore did not support OUSA’s investment in one. Ruby is a fascinating candidate. Her enthusiasm is infectious, and she immediately distinguished herself from her male counterparts. She had clearly thought about her position on the various issues, and her answers added a level of depth to the debate that I wasn’t expecting. This should come as no surprise, though: Ruby has been a member of the Exec throughout 2013 and, in her capacity as Welfare Officer, has worked to deliver free breakfasts to students, secured a $10,000 grant from the Government for something called “healthier relationships,” and promoted queer representation. Zac seemed ill-prepared, but was definitely the best-dressed. I have some experience when it comes to trying to get away with a lack of preparation, and nothing good has ever come of it. The lesson, of course, is that when you leave things to chance you leave your fate in the hands of others. However, while Zac’s opening speech was short, and while he stumbled over most of his answers, his experience as Administrative Vice-President should serve him well should he be elected President. His ideas regarding participation and outreach also reflected a maturity that should be taken into account. Strangely, the tension that the Service Level Agreement (SLA – OUSA’s financial lifeline) may cause in the future was not addressed from the podium. I did, however, ask the candidates privately for their thoughts on the issue. Ruby sounded as though she would do everything she could to keep OUSA ticking over, and supported continuing with the SLA. Zac was a bit nonplussed, but pointed out that he has always been in favour of revenue diversification. Jordan was keen to address the issue, and argued that in a VSM environment, the SLA was crucial. It looks, therefore, as though the SLA is here to stay. On a final note: it must be remembered that putting yourself forward for something like this, and subjecting yourself to the scrutiny of your peers, is incredibly courageous. Congratulations Zac, Jordan and Ruby – I wish you all the best.
-
ColumnsIssue 25 29/09/2013
Yellow and Blue Make Green | Opinion
The environment is a stick with which libertarians are stuck gleefully, and often. If our libertarian ideals are to be taken seriously, they need to be seen to deal satisfactorily with the problem of pollution – a problem that is deeply intertwined with the pressures of consumerism. Personally, I’m on the fence about climate change. I’m (at best) an ignorant admirer of science, and I’m not one for blindly taking people on their word. If, however, we accept that climate change really is a problem – and many say that it is – then the question for libertarians becomes: what should we do about it? We have to accept the status quo, for a start. The decision has already been made (by voters) that governments will intervene. The political “flavour” of governments seems to matter little when it comes to the climate change issue – whether right-leaning or left-leaning, they all seem to respond to the pressure to “do something.” Libertarians, therefore, must start here, and convince voters that their solutions are the best available. To begin with, let’s consider taxing carbon emissions. A simple solution is nearly always best. The idea of carbon markets – power plants in California selling their credits before demand increases, for instance – is destructive nonsense. Taxation, that necessary evil (yes, Russell Norman), is a far more effective way to influence behaviour. If a carbon tax were to be implemented, polluters would naturally try to avoid it. They would essentially be faced with two options: pay the extra in taxation, or cut down on carbon emissions by finding alternative ways to produce the same goods. The downside, of course, is the depression of economic activity due to the tax’s flow-on price effects. The upside, however, is that such a policy may reduce consumer demand for luxury items. More importantly, what would happen if such a tax were axed? Would the lessons we have learnt be remembered and passed down? I highly doubt it. We live in a resilient, docile consumer culture, and tend to overlook the realities of what such a culture means for the environment. This is precisely what the “interventionist environmentalist” has to answer for, and is the reason why governmental policies are merely short-term solutions. There is virtually nothing governments can do – save going to war or installing an authoritarian regime – to change such a culture. The only option is to continuing researching and debating in an effort to raise awareness; and that is the libertarian way.
-
ColumnsIssue 24 22/09/2013
Legalise It | Opinion
History’s progression has seen a steadily narrowing scope of self-determination. When once self-determination was thought of as the right of states, it has become in practice a right of individuals. Some of the fruits of this narrowing scope have been the abolition of slavery (and its pursuit as an evil), the enfranchisement and liberation of women, sexual liberation and free inquiry. The scope of self-determination is getting smaller and smaller, abandoning the state and wrapping itself around the individual. So the time has come for the legalisation of cannabis, yet another narrowing of self-determination. In the following weeks, I will elaborate on each of the “magic wand” proposals one by one. The principles behind my position are these two: every individual has the right to make his own decisions (if they do not directly harm others); and that the law should do no harm. Morally speaking, the best people to make decisions about what one does depends on who is involved. If an intended action leaves only yourself to live with the consequences, whether you accept them or not, then you should by rights be able to do it. Nothing is ever black and white, of course, but this is how we should regard other people – as individuals with autonomy. Using cannabis does no harm to those not directly involved. If you believe that humans are autonomous with rights, you should also support legalisation. Legalisation is also just humane. A WHO Health Survey in 2008 found that 41.9 per cent of adult New Zealanders had tried cannabis at least once in their lifetimes. A smaller proportion within that number use it regularly and a smaller number therein abuse it. For those suffering from abuse, help is fairly easily administered. Those using it responsibly are at risk of a criminal record, and those at risk of abuse shy from help because of the stigma. Let’s not forget the dangerous criminality added to the drug with its illegal status. I’ll leave you with words of Mr X (aka Carl Sagan) in an essay featured in Marihuana Reconsidered (1971) because they do sum up the madness of the present legal situation: “I hope that [legalisation] isn’t too distant; the illegality of cannabis is outrageous, an impediment to full utilisation of a drug which helps produce the serenity and insight, sensitivity and fellowship so desperately needed in this increasingly mad and dangerous world.”
-
ColumnsIssue 23 15/09/2013
If I Had a Magic Wand ... | Opinion
If John Key could implement any policy he wanted tomorrow … it would be to change the flag. (I’d vote for Kyle Lockwood’s design.) But in all seriousness, if we could magically make anything relevant to our nation’s governance happen, what would it be? My first act would be to legalise cannabis, because, as recent Transport Agency public service announcements suggest, New Zealand seems to be well adjusted to it by now. Bakeries are also on board – they can’t wait for the increase in business as well the daily comic relief. Oh, and apparently Dunedin can be like Amsterdam (instead of a smaller Wellington). My second act would be to grant residency to international students who have graduated in New Zealand. I’m open to some fine-tuning on this policy proposal, but it would help with our current chronic skills shortage. Also, we would be incentivising study in this country. Considering that international students pay unsubsidised tuition fees, each of them contributes far more to the economy than domestic students: they pay more to the University they attend, improving that institution in the process, and they bring a substantial amount of money into the country on an individual basis. Plus, if rich people can get residency in New Zealand, why is it not the same for young students who want to make an honest go for themselves in an awesome country? I would make polluters pay. To offset the inevitable increase in the cost of living, income and corporate taxes should be reduced, as should GST. Taxing positive contributions to the economy, such as productive work and market transactions, is counterproductive. Taxing negative externalities such as pollution puts pressure on polluters to find better alternatives or to pollute less. I would also give the negative income tax a go and scrap the minimum wage. Why not wave my wand at poverty? Stopping at-risk (and ordinary) youth from having their employment and travel prospects hindered by possession of a harmless drug will prevent some poverty. Reducing the impact of pollution, which exacerbates certain conditions most prevalent among the poor, will also help to reduce poverty. Getting rid of the minimum wage will get some unemployed into work. Supplementing incomes by way of a negative income tax will give the working poor a break. Allowing international students to stay in New Zealand and to contribute to the economy of a country they love helps us all. I was waving my wand at poverty.
-
ColumnsIssue 22 08/09/2013
The Syrian Question | Opinion
The “Syrian Question” presents a moral dilemma for the Western world, which as I write sits poised to intervene in a Middle Eastern civil war. Do we jump in to save innocent lives? Or do we prevent World War III by staying home? According to the mainstream media, the majority of Western countries are against intervention. Considering everything else that is reported about the Syrian civil war, I can’t begin to understand why. Assad’s regime monitors personal communications in order to root out dissent, and shuts down various websites it doesn’t like. Amnesty International reports that speaking out against the regime usually leads to imprisonment, torture or even execution. Syrians are not free, and neither are their neighbours. When Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri (a leading figure in the 2005 Cedar Revolution that ended a 29-year Syrian occupation) took a stand for independence, he was blown up by a car bomb. If the West decides to stay home, conditions will only get worse. If it happened here … It is significant that Russia and Iran, themselves studies in totalitarianism, are backing Assad’s regime. Let’s reflect on what these countries do. Let’s reflect on Russia’s brutal pogrom against LGBTI persons, the increasing influence of the misogynistic Russian Orthodox Church, and Iran’s version of Islamism, which is against any freedoms (that you and I enjoy) that are not compatible with the Ayatollah’s interpretation of the Qur’an. With thugs like these for friends, it’s no wonder the Syrians are screaming for help. Intervention is not inherently a bad thing, and a distinction is useful. Assad’s Ba’athist regime is known to be brutal and expansionist – there are clear similarities here with the doctrines of fascism and lebensraum. American intervention in the Middle East is premised on the idea that a line must be drawn between a country railing against US foreign policy, on the one hand, and brutally targeting its own civilians, on the other, and has paved the way for moderates to establish strong democracies. Another World War is always close – closer still now that powers like Russia, North Korea and Iran are trying to take control. Chamberlain tried diplomacy; look how that turned out. What makes us think this case is any different? Protecting Syrian innocents from being mulched into statistics is clearly the right thing to do, and if WWIII begins because of this, at least we will go in as the good guys. If the West intervenes for the good, we will encourage good people in bad countries to do the same.
-
ColumnsIssue 21 01/09/2013
The Final Exam of Our Lives | Opinion
There is no autopilot for freedom and democracy. Perhaps it is this fact that should be taken for granted, instead of the goods we derive from them. It’s hard to imagine the end of the present way of life that they make possible – too distant a possibility to be credible. But it’s like a final exam: it’s too late if you’re unprepared when the time arrives. We live in a country untouched by armed conflict – since 1865 at least. Plague has not visited us since 1918, and our fertile lands mean we have never been struck by famine. Our weather is blustery at worst, and natural disasters are uncommon. There have been no violent revolutions or coups d’état in our nation’s history. With every socially progressive step taken by our law and society, New Zealanders have increasingly become the masters of their own destinies. This relative tranquility and the seemingly steady march of progress lull us into thinking that we’ll know when good things like freedom and democracy are at risk. By the time the issue that will excuse the ending of our precious way of life surfaces, we will have missed all the subtle changes that allowed entry to the thief in the night. What will it be? The fiscal challenges in the United States, which continue to undermine confidence in the global economy, perhaps? China’s ban on New Zealand dairy exports, exposing our sensitivity to international politics and downsizing our economy, maybe? Our essential commodities being consistently interrupted by an increasingly thoughtless corporate culture, brought on by legal monopolies and careless regulation? The dollar drop after the recent Wellington earthquakes proves how shaky the ground is upon which we stand. Anything can happen. John Key won’t be Prime Minister in 20 years’ time. Whether that’s a good thing or not depends on who comes next, and whether they use for bad what Key built for (what he considers to be) the preservation of the good. If or when laws like the GCSB and TICS Amendment Bills are enacted, and when worries contribute to instability here and abroad, we know that the final exams aren’t far off. Some leader pretending to have all the answers will be getting ready to take over, perhaps even in this country. There is no asking for an extension and no second chances. But there are last chances, should you wish to seize the moment.
-
ColumnsIssue 20 18/08/2013
Anarchy or the State? | Opinion
Who will build the roads? It’s a question frequently posed to libertarians. Well, private citizens (you and I) pay taxes to the government, and they pay a company of private citizens to do the work. The government (at least in this country) simply decides where the roads need to be; it is private consultants who provide the information needed for planning. So why do we need government? If all the basics of civilisation are being paid for by you and I, and created by us too, then we could just cut out the middleman. Right? Not so fast. Arbitrary authority, exercised by the state, is a subject on which many political philosophies dwell. Even the most ardent libertarians think we need some remnant left over, just in case. Why? The clichéd and simplistic response is that we humans love power and grandeur; we enjoy control over things as they are and for what they might be. But for those without plans for world domination, it seems more likely that arbitrary authority is preferred because it makes up for the fact we don’t trust each other enough to do without it. Government, and democratic government in particular, is a collective expression of a desire for control over our own destinies and the overall scheme of things. The modern pluralist state (liberal representative democracy) means that we all have relatively equal influence on state power through a range of means: elections, pressure groups, media, demonstrations and art. All are beautiful things. This system offers us all an equal chance to control the extent to which the state exercises its arbitrary authority, so that it matches what, on balance, we all think is fair. Anarchy is correctly understood as the absence of authority, but the practice of voluntarism is the main feature (a philosophy in which consent is at the centre of all moral questions). It sounds glorious, but who goes first? Who will be the first to take advantage of that trust taken for granted? This is the problem for anarchists, though it would be better if we were able to trust each other more, and that should still be the aim. If you agree, then the issue is not state versus anarchy, but what is right for government to do. For democracy to thrive, and trust to improve, we need to contemplate that moral question of fairness in our own lives, more often.
-
ColumnsIssue 19 11/08/2013
Rand: Human After All | Opinion
Ayn Rand was a crotchety old bitch. But that’s why I love her. Born in 1905 in St Petersburg, Russia, Ayn Rand lived through the Bolshevik Revolution of October 1917 and escaped to the US in 1925. Her books, and her philosophy, brought her both fame and notoriety: to this day, countless adults and young teens encounter The Fountainhead (1943) and her magnum opus Atlas Shrugged (1957) and claim to be forever changed. Her works, her thoughts and her life leave only love, hate or ignorance as possible responses to her legacy. I am one of those young adults, but the shine came off eventually. Hindsight has cleared away that about which she was wrong, and left only that which I originally loved. She lived the typical tortured life of someone who is clear about what the perfect world is. Try as these people might, they always have to deal with the conviction that they will never live the dream quite as they imagine it. Rand’s life is a useful demonstration of how the promise is far more delightful than the delivery. Louis CK has a scene in his sitcom series Lucky Louie in which his daughter endlessly asks questions. “Why can’t I go outside?” she asks while eating her cereal. “Because it’s only 5am and it’s still dark,” says Louie. “Why?” his daughter asks. She challenges his answers until hilariously she accepts Louie’s final answer: “because we’re all alone and God is dead.” His daughter nods and, satisfied, says, “okay.” Ayn Rand was relentlessly logical too. She hated faith, and dishonesty. She accepted that we exist on this lonely, godless boat – but together. True, she put a lot of emphasis on selfishness, but she always added that generosity and society are necessary for enjoying life. And enjoy life she did, but her cult-like circle of friends, which she ironically named “The Collective,” would show just how limited her philosophy was. Life is about joy. This is Rand’s message. But to experience joy, we must protect the values we love. She didn’t always serve hers in a manner of which we may approve, but fortunately she was, and continues to be, the only true Objectivist. Despite this she led me to the water of individualism, and it has made me a much better person. She wasn’t perfect. But she was human after all, and a heroic one too.
-
Features
Issue 18 04/08/2013Should Dunedin Impose Higher Flatting Standards?
Aaron HawkinsEveryone deserves to live with dignity in a warm and healthy home. For the tens of thousands of Dunedin people living in flats, from students in the north end to families in the south, this means putting together minimum standards for rentals across the city. This will save tenants money, reduce the strain on our stretched health system and attract the talent we need to make Dunedin one of the world’s great small cities. Better insulation, more efficient heating and declaring war on moisture would all contribute to lowering the amount tenants spend on power. The cost of power has been increasing in New Zealand while real wages stagnate or fall, and therefore takes up more and more of your flat’s budget. Nobody should have to choose between heating and eating. Given how hostile and unpredictable the winters can be in Dunedin, this is more relevant here than in most other parts of the country. People who live in dry, warm and healthy homes get sick less often than those who don’t. No matter how many jerseys you wear, or how tight around your neck your sleeping bag is, breathing in lungfuls of black mould every day can make you very sick. Going to the doctor for recommended remedies is an expense many people struggle with, particularly young families, and reducing their need to do so would be a huge help. People getting sick less often due to their living conditions would ease the pressure on community and Student Health Services, and fewer sick days can only be good for our productivity as a community. Dunedin produces some of the greatest young minds in the world, thanks to the University and Polytechnic, and has international standing as a centre of creativity, ingenuity and passion. We need to encourage and support students who have the desire to set up here when they graduate, and lure back alumni after their overseas jaunts, but poor quality housing is a huge obstacle. Thousands of our smartest people leave town each year full of stories of winter suffering, fuelling the myth that the city is a cruel and hostile mistress. When our reputation for being a great city of ideas is no longer burdened by our reputation for being a city in which you have to freeze, great things will happen. Minimum standards for rental housing will go a long way to helping this. A Warrant of Fitness scheme doesn’t mean that the cost of rent will rise accordingly. There are currently schemes in Dunedin, run with the support of government agencies (both national and local), that will cover up to 90 per cent of the cost of winter-proofing flats. In some parts of the country this is as high as 100 per cent (and yet somehow some landlords are still reluctant!). Looking to expand access to these schemes should help to alleviate those concerns. This is also something that needs to be phased in over at least a three to five year period to give landlords time to adjust to the new system. As urgent as this is, rushing the process and excluding all interested parties would be fatal for its success. The argument against intervention has largely been based on Market Choices. If flats are bad, or too expensive, tenants will choose to live somewhere else and this will drive changes in conditions and pricing. For students, however, this has failed, largely because housing doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Our bus service is neither cheap nor efficient, parking on campus is scarce and it’s pretty dangerous for cyclists. Students have limited options in terms of where they choose to live if they want to be able to access their lectures and libraries. It is a captive population, and to suggest otherwise is disingenuous. Minimum standards for flats, managed by a Warrant of Fitness Scheme, will improve the physical and financial health of tens of thousands of people. It will also make Dunedin a more attractive place for people to live in, work in, move to and return to. As long as we don’t dive in without a robust consultation process, this will be hugely beneficial to the city of Dunedin. Guy McCallumEverything we do and don’t do sends a signal to anyone capable of observing your actions. It tells them something about what you’re doing, and allows them to relate it to what they’re doing. This is how markets work. Everything you do has a ripple effect. Changes in the market touch everything, no matter how remote. Signals also help us choose the best available option given the finite resources at our disposal. This is how we deal with scarcity in the economy – you manage what you have according to what you need or want. If you want to have more money after paying rent, you embrace the conditions that will make that possible. We all have to accept particular tradeoffs, both in order to obtain the things we most value and enable ourselves to make better tradeoffs in the future. Proposed regulations to force landlords to meet higher standards takes away certain choices in the market. It inevitably means higher rents as well. To say otherwise, as Mayoral candidate Aaron Hawkins does is, unfortunately, misleading. While it isn’t deplorable to want better quality housing, it isn’t reasonable to expect landlords to provide it at a loss, nor to expect that it will be any cheaper than higher quality housing that is already on offer. So the obvious question then, is this: are the proposed regulations going to have a positive effect? That is, will the tradeoffs between quality and price be any different than they are now? There will be better houses on offer, for sure, but not necessarily better prices. Under the proposed regulations, students would not have the option to choose between an older, (tolerably) less functional house in order to save money or a newer house with all the creature comforts; they will have to choose the latter and simply do without the money it costs. Under such regulations, you will be given only one option: better, but more expensive, housing. Regulations such as these have potential implications not only for housing prices, but also for the housing market. Many rental properties in Dunedin are owned by small-scale investors: Mums and Dads who own an extra home or two as a way of saving for retirement. These investors are low on capital, and so usually borrow to upgrade or fix a property of theirs. If the costs of upgrading to these proposed regulations outweigh the benefit of owning the extra house, they will have little choice but to abandon their investment. Either someone with more money will come along to buy the house, or some other investment owner will try the same thing but end up selling to a bidder with more economic pull. This will probably mean a gradual shift from dispersed rental ownership to the accumulation of rental property in fewer hands. Such regulations make economic ownership a reality only for those who can afford it. The higher the cost of the regulation, the more money you need to have; and the more economic power you have, the more your influence over price. I’m not saying there will be marauding rental monopolies overnight, but the creep will be noticeable over several years as the process of minor investors failing allows mightier investors to take over. So the tradeoffs are these: better housing at higher costs, or mixed quality housing at mixed prices? Dispersed rental ownership, or concentrated ownership? A housing market anyone can afford to enter, or one purely for those wealthy enough to meet the standards? As the consumer, and voter, it is up to you.
-
ColumnsIssue 18 04/08/2013
Saying No to the GCSB and TICS | Opinion
As a member of a party that has offered its support to a Government that wishes to expand the surveillance powers of intelligence agencies, I am often asked a very obvious question: do I support the GCSB or TICS Bills? No, I don’t. I’m not an expert, either, in the fields that these bills affect, but it doesn’t take an expert to figure out that they are bad news. I’ve been encouraged by supporters of the bills to consider the details. (To squabble over the details of a bad bill, however, is still in some ways to implicitly support it.) We know that if the Law Society, New Zealander of the Year Dame Anne Salmond and even our own Mayor Dave Cull oppose these bills, then they are up against some thoughtful opposition. ACT Leader John Banks thinks the balance is possible; if democratic principles and human rights restrictions are included, then the expanded surveillance powers are acceptable. In other words, we just need to fight the right balance between freedom and security. It’s a well-meant offer, but neither he, nor John Key, nor the Labour Party (that launched this entire mess in the first place) can guarantee that the next person with the keys to the Cabinet will be just and noble. Nor can they guarantee that the cadre at the top will not give in to the most obvious, inevitable temptations that come with power of this kind – the power to watch you without you knowing and without having to tell you why. It is incumbent upon all of our political leaders to say no to these bills. Not just because they will lead to the most obvious of all places – state tyranny – but because they should be standing up to anyone who claims that such immoral and perverted powers are necessary. The United States, entertainment industries, nefarious influences in our own backyard – all should be stood up to and told no, we don’t want to go down this road. For we are free. We can live free, independent and private lives if we choose, and still be secure in our persons, property and communities. There need not be any tension between the two, nor any concession made to those who would have us secure, no matter the cost to freedom. Our message to the government should be, resoundingly, that “nothing to hide and nothing to fear” should work both ways.