Guy McCallum
Columnist
Articles by Guy McCallum
16 articles found. Displaying page 2 of 2.
-
ColumnsIssue 17 28/07/2013
Rebooting the Politics of Poverty | Opinion
Having been on the left, and now being on what I call the liberal right, I have detected a deficiency in the way poverty is addressed. Poverty is, of course, a broad problem, and it is obvious then that the issue of where to start is possibly the most intimidating part. But for the sake of getting at least one point across, let’s just take a broad look at the electoral politics of poverty. I find it difficult to discuss poverty properly with people. When I do, I come up against walls that reject anything new. For instance, when I propose to my left-inclined friends that the welfare state may actually institutionalise poverty, it is rejected out of hand. And when I tell people of the right that their paternalism drives the poor into the hands of self-serving radicals, the warning is dismissed. Okay, so they don’t think I have an argument. I can live with that. So, more objectively, what do the impoverished hear when social democrats and conservatives open their mouths? From the left comes the idea that the poor should settle for mediocrity and blame bourgeois bogeymen, almost superstitiously, for causing poverty. From the right comes a stern, paternalistic message and the thinly-veiled imperative to accept an unforgivable guilt for what is presumed, but never confirmed, to be poor life choices. What this competition for superiority overlooks is that at the centre of the poverty problem are thinking, feeling human beings who have been made slaves to their own survival. They are human beings who hope for freedom, but for whom the way forward is blurred by politics as usual. Disagree with me if you wish, but go to the streets of the worst parts of South Auckland or Huntly West (where I went to High School) and tell me that those messages haven’t been received loud and clear and haven’t wrought the following damage. Poverty makes the poor slaves to their own survival. When that is the case, liberation is clearly the answer, not merely state handouts or discouraging those who need help from asking for it. Whether from the state or civil society, a hand up should not be offered with conditions, but as a form of solidarity with those who struggle. That, instead of harvesting the poor for votes or pretending to do something about poverty, is the solution.
-
ColumnsIssue 16 21/07/2013
VSM: A New, Stronger OUSA | Opinion
Critic editor Sam McChesney refreshes some fond memories of mine in his editorial of 15 July. It was about that old political hatchet of yesteryear: Voluntary Student Membership. His “where are they now” analysis of students’ associations since VSM reminds me that a lot was left unsaid, or at least unheard, by its supporters. For instance, VSM supporters (most of them) believed that students’ associations served a public good. Former ACT MP Heather Roy couldn’t say it enough, usually with an amused grin as she debated either NZUSA’s David Do or OUSA’s Logan Edgar. But VSM supporters couldn’t shake the branding, given them by opponents, that they were destroying student institutions. As a libertarian, I find value in social organisations such as students’ associations. It just so happens that most Otago students find value in OUSA too (regardless of partisanship). Neither VSM supporters nor opponents wanted to tear these organisations down. So what was all the fuss about? The problem was a compulsory membership structure that allowed all sorts of stupid and arrogant things to happen. The use of association funds to donate to political parties and to support contentious causes with a minimum of support, for instance. Additionally, the tone of student politics had become severely brutalised, discouraging participation. The situation became so bad, pre-VSM, that voter turnouts for OUSA elections were at one per cent or lower. The reason was no mystery; elected members would do whatever they wanted because their members (and their annual fees) were stuck with them. Furthermore, it was evident to many that OUSA had turned into a nursery for wannabe politicians, or just a good CV-filler. Long gone was the OUSA of student advocacy and support it was intended to be. Now that VSM has made popular support necessary for OUSA’s survival, post-VSM candidates reach out to more than just the likely voters. And the incumbent President is more concerned about how the organisation he runs is perceived. Their manifestos and actions show a keen return to OUSA’s core purposes: student advocacy, issue awareness and student community. Problems new and old, such as an impending long-term Service Level Agreement, will take time to iron out. In the long-run though, OUSA will be seen to have made an adjustment (albeit a noisy one) for what is a core principle of human rights: freedom of association.
-
ColumnsIssue 15 14/07/2013
A Labour of Equality | Opinion
The Labour Party wants the option of banning men from standing in certain electorates – a bizarre stunt to give life to the wearied governing parties. What becomes obvious, sadly, is that Labour is not so sure what equality is, or what is actually more important. It also gives me a reason to confront the notion of putting equality ahead of everything else. Have a read, if you’re curious, of books by Hayek, von Mises, Nozick, Friedman or Wilder-Lane (and others). If you haven’t read them, you’ll have to take my word that they demonstrate very good arguments. They reason that a person at liberty (regardless of background, and dependent upon perspective) is a person who can unleash their potential for achievement. Such a person could lead, for example, an at-risk youth to the conclusion that she can think for herself and achieve great things. In doing so she will learn the abilities needed to make her self-confidence a real thing. She will go on in life knowing that her efforts will make a difference, and that she can be in charge of her own happiness. If you come from an underprivileged background, similar to or worse than mine, you’ll most likely have experienced this. Something else that underprivileged people experience is being kept out. Which, unfortunately and ironically for Labour, is what will happen with a mechanism so open to abuse by those already on the inside. Examples like this aren’t just found in the Labour Party. The minimum wage is another mechanism by which equality would be achieved, but only by those whose earning power presently matches $13.50 an hour. Those who are in no position, at present, to climb over this barrier are either forced to accept fewer hours, more part-time jobs or state welfare. Equality by edict is not equality at all, but privilege. If you take into account the needs and desires of individuals, you’ll find that equality is not as simple as having the same stuff or being the same thing. Equality is as much about being able as it is about being allowed to do the same thing as somebody else. Finally, if you really care about equality, consider these words from Milton Friedman: “A society that puts equality before freedom will get neither. A society that puts freedom before equality will get a high degree of both.”
-
ColumnsIssue 14 07/07/2013
Liberty: How to Spot the Fakers
I love liberty. And we all enjoy the benefits of it. As it turns out, whether or not you have a job you can still pay for all the basics even if you do find yourself struggling. And because of liberty, life is more than what you can do from your wallet: in New Zealand you have the freedom to be yourself (sometimes with the requisite courage), the freedom to decide what you want from life, and how you go about your relationships. Liberty is behind this standard of living. How so? Well, if weren’t for all of us going about our daily business of earning more money than we spend, meeting our obligations and making choices about employment, education, health, recreation and how to live (or think) – and being free to do these things – then the provision of a $23.6 billion welfare state, a $12.4 billion education system, and a $15 billion health system would be impossible. There’s always room for improvement, despite this being a situation in which Flight of the Conchords not only pay for the benefits of society, but also help to construct a society in which being as goofy as they are is a career path. But here’s the crunch: everyone’s about liberty. So how do we know they mean it? Here’s a way to catch out the ones who will achieve only the opposite – those whose underlying (and usually hidden) premise contains the idea of undeserved entitlement. It is, briefly, an entitlement that goes beyond your rights, and expands into someone else’s. And it’s also the resting pulse of big government. Thomas Jefferson (the famous President) once warned that a government big enough to give you everything was also big enough to take it away. That kind of “entitlement to control” can take not only your money, but worse, your freedom. Having said this, I should be clear: a conflict between liberty and entitlement shouldn’t be confused with a conflict between wealth and need. Clearer still, there is a stronger case for providing better public services, and reducing demand on them, than getting rid of the lot. That is, for reducing the use of force to fix problems, and empowering the voluntary. Thanks to those who arrived at the end of this inaugural column – it was intended as a broad introduction. If your intellectual curiosity is as strong as mine, I hope you’ll keep reading.