Greatest Hits / Greatest Shits | Issue 07
from Issue 7 ()
from Issue 7 ()
Greatest HitThis week we’re going international for the Greatest Hit: to Hong Kong. After a change to Hong Kong elections that would mean only “China-approved” candidates would be able to be elected, students began an intense protest for democracy, storming Hong Kong’s Civic Square. Sometimes it’s good to step back and realise we’re lucky to be democratic, when so many places still have to fight for that right. Greatest ShitGood old Karen Price. The environmental lawyer married to David Cunliffe has previously graced our pages in a Greatest Hit. This time, unfortunately, her story is not quite so great. Last weekend, a Twitter account (TarnBabe67) emerged, attacking users who did not support Cunliffe. Apparently it was Karen Price behind it.
Greatest HitThis one’s really easy this week. By the time you read this, the election will be over, and I’ll be able to return to a relatively peaceful life. Thank the fucking Lord. Greatest ShitI really don’t think I could give it to anything other than the National Party for being sued by Eminem over their use of a loop that sounds suspiciously like “Lose Yourself.”
Greatest HitA chance meeting that could have gone horribly wrong but didn’t: Max Key and Mona Dotcom. The Prime Minister’s son and Kim DC’s ex-wife met at a nightclub in Auckland and instantly became friends. Like a strange Beehive Romeo and Juliet, they danced the night away (as friends) and transcended the political boundaries that confine their respective affiliates to party lines. Big thumbs up for generally saying “fuck it” and having a good time. Greatest ShitThis week’s Greatest Shit is a no brainer. It goes to Gordon Dickson, Labour’s Selwyn candidate, who has proven that even democratic candidate selection has its limits. First, he hounded journalist Lloyd Burr in order to say, “ask the Prime Minister if he has faith in Anne Tolley, Minister of Police. Thank you.” Then, when Burr didn’t wander up to John Key and ask him a context-less question about a Minister, he sent Burr a whopper of an email, addressing it “Dear Lazy.” My personal favourite (verbatim) quote is as follows: “Perhaps you are lazy? To help you rediscover your previously perceived role in our society i.e. the ‘fourth estate’ I attach a copy of my formalised request already in the possession of the Prime Minister and the National Board of Directors as well.” He ended it with, “Have a nice weekend and grow a pair.” Charming.
Greatest hitsStuff gets Shit, but they also get Hit for releasing a segment featuring up-close-and-personal portraits of what they call “political bloodstock.” Dark, gritty, and sly, these photographs come far closer to visually depicting the intensity of the election campaign than the majority of awkward headline shots so far. Coupled with a series of tongue-in-cheek captions describing the party leaders as racehorses, it makes a nice change from some of Stuff’s other overly sensationalist efforts. http://www.stuff.co.nz/interactives/political-bloodstock/ Greatest shitsIt isn’t exactly a secret that Stuff’s reporting leaves something to be desired. But they really one-upped themselves with the archaic debate footage on Tuesday night. With out-of-sync audio, the look of a VHS from the 90s, and microphone levels that turned John’s mildest retorts into shrieks and David’s greatest yells into whispers, it was, overall, an utter shambles on the technical front.
Greatest HitThere are a few contenders this week, what with the UBS apparently giving out airline sick bags to anyone who bought a copy of Dirty Politics and the hilarious election broadcasts screening, but Greatest Hit has to go to one of the underdogs of the election: the Civilian Party. They recently selected their deputy leader, Golden Mayan Sweet Pineapple Product of the Philippines, commenting that if it is elected, it “will be the first pineapple MP in our nation’s history. Indeed, it is the first pineapple candidate in our nation’s history. That it has taken us until 2014 to get to this point is a shameful reflection of our past.” What a forward-thinking selection from the Civilian Party. Greatest ShitThis week the Greatest Shit is a bit of a double whammy. It starts with Pam Corkery, who went off her nut at the Internet-MANA campaign launch. After journalists tried to hassle Kim Dotcom into an interview following a questionable “hacking” comment, Pam called a journalist a “puffed up little shit” and asked “when will you glove puppets of Cameron Slater just piss off?” The second piece of this Shit, however, goes to the media reporting of the I-M campaign launch in the first place. Until Pam went wild, they seemed to have no intention of reporting on the policy releases, instead choosing to screen John Key wandering around holding a piece of paper, or something. Policy is probably more important.
Greatest HitWithout a doubt, Greatest Hit this week goes to Nicky Hager, who has created what can only be described as a “shitstorm” in response to the publication of his new book. Prior to its release, the hilarious Twitter speculation alone was enough to warrant it this prized award; but Dirty Politics, released Wednesday 13 August, one-upped its anticipation by being entirely full of juicy scandals about some of our most beloved politicians and political commentators. Whale Oil was thoroughly unimpressed. Greatest ShitWinston always says that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, but it’s hard to be stoked when AUSA hits Yahoo NZ with a story they copied from Critic. Essentially, using our supreme and complex analysis, they too figured out how much it would cost certain politicians if they went to university today. They even presented some of them with certificates. Unfortunately, they managed to get Steven Joyce’s cost wrong, undercharging him by about $2000. Presumably, this is because they fatally forgot to include miscellaneous Massey fees in their costing.
Greatest Hit On Wednesday last week, Clare Curran participated in an AMA on Reddit, an activity that involves answering anything that the New Zealand Internet deems worthy enough to ask her. While it wasn’t full of cheese rolls banter, Clare gets points for responding to “can you please tell Jacinda Ardern she is so hot” with just “ok” and even more for fulfilling her ICT portfolio by doing something internet-y. Greatest Shit I hate to give Greatest Shit to the same person two weeks in a row, but there really is no avoiding it. Last Monday, Asenati Lole-Taylor decided to cancel her appearance on Vote Chat, which was scheduled for Friday of the same week. She left researchers with useless research, the show without a candidate, and me feeling significantly annoyed. How shit of you, Asenati. Thankfully, they managed to fill the spot with Shane Gallagher of the Green Party.
Greatest HitAnother week brings us another hilarious parody website. This one is making fun of Colin Craig; by going to colincraig.co.nz you’re treated to a number of fake press releases, like: “Perhaps choosing the Conservative Party as a name was a bad choice, as we are constantly mistaken to be the Conservation Party,” said Conservative Party leader Colin Craig, while lying coyly in a field of grass. And if you hang around long enough, a giant picture of his face slides onto the screen. According to 3 News, Colin is “tremendously flattered” at being the subject of a parody site, but has, of course, threatened defamation. Greatest ShitNew Zealand First is lucky to have a number of strange MPs, and Asenati Lole-Taylor is decidedly one of them. When asked a few questions by the press, Asenati pulled the classic “my phone is ringing” to try and field off some of the reporters. One of them asked her to “stop pretending.” In retaliation, Asenati thrust her phone to his ear, in order to prove the legitimacy of her phone call. There was no one there.
Greatest HitsRecently Back Benches featured a number of youths. Hailing from Labour, National, Greens, NZ First, and ACT, these youths had a go at hashing out a few pressing issues. They also had a go at each other. This week’s Greatest Hit goes to an amazing call from ACT’s Louis Houlbrooke, who, fed up with the ‘70s-dressed Curwen Rolinson of NZ First, yelled “the only thing bigger than your tie is your ego.” Greatest ShitsIf I didn’t make it clear enough last week, I’m not exactly Cameron Slater, aka Whale Oil’s, biggest fan. I wasn’t particularly looking forward to his contribution to the Tania Billingsley chat, and lo and behold, he didn’t disappoint. First, he tried to argue the whole affair was a smear campaign by the left; second, he tried to say rape culture doesn’t exist in New Zealand, something even Paula Bennett disagrees with. Describing his coverage as insensitive and oblivious is pretty euphemistic.
Greatest hitAs a “young person,” there’s nothing more cringe-worthy than watching non-youths attempt to become well versed in the wonderful world of the Internet if they don’t really understand how the Internet works. That makes social media campaigns hit-or-miss, and means they can either be really great or really ridiculous. Fortunately, this is the Hit section, and the Greatest Hit here goes to the recent explosion of political hashtags. Or, more specifically, the fact that the parties are gaining traction by using them. The National Party has two that have been floating around - #3moreyears and #TeamKey; the Labour Party has recently got #ForABetterNZ off the ground, and the Green Party has been using #Green2014 for a little while. As it becomes apparent just how important social media presence is going to be for getting that ever-slippery youth vote, it’s cool to see some of the parties embracing it with open arms. Greatest shitThis is not overwhelmingly recent, but it’s such a good one I can’t resist – Trevor Mallard, of the Labour Party, wants to revive the moa. In isolation, it’s a relatively cool idea; imagine if we had gigantic birds roaming the streets? In election year, it’s ridiculously hilarious. Apparently Cunliffe said of Trev’s plan, “the moa is not a goer,” but Mallard definitely isn’t joking: “I only want the small moa in Wainuiomata. I don’t want those that are 240kg and 3.5 metres tall. I’d like ones that I could pat on the head.” Beautiful.
Greatest HitOur dearly beloved long-lived politician John “Banksie” Banks has resigned after a bit of a hiccup with the law. The Auckland readers of Critic will know him best, as he ruled the city with an iron fist for two separate terms (2001-2004; 2007-2010); Epsom residents will know him even better, as he was their electorate MP. In a recent legal scandal, Banks was found guilty of filing a false electoral return regarding donations from none other than Kim Dotcom. While he has not been convicted (and won’t be until later in the year), the pressure to resign came from all sides. Why is this deserving of Greatest Hit? Well, his actions were certainly shit worthy – but given his resignation, he’s free to return to his radio show Breakfast with Banksie. Gosh, I can’t wait. Greatest ShitThere is essentially one thing you have to do to form an OUSA club – get ten members to join. Unfortunately for the proposed Internet Party on Campus, in a meeting during the last week of May they only managed to get five. This led to the Dunedin “Internet Party Meet-up Captain” sending around an awkward message to those who clicked “attending” on the Facebook event, asking them to come along next time. Unfortunately for the Captain, a number of young politicians from other parties “attended” only to get the updates, not because they truly believe in the power of torrenting. I do wonder if the Internet Party’s inability to reach the OUSA member minimum is a mystical piece of foreshadowing?
Greatest HitsThe Greatest Hit this week goes to a brand new political party attempting to grace New Zealand with its presence: the Civilian Party. Based on the satirical news site, the Civilian Party stands for a variety of ludicrous and hilarious things. Some of their policies include “defend the traditional institution of marriage as the union between one man and one volumetric flask,” and “replace New Zealand’s national anthem with the theme song from the 1996 film Space Jam, by Quad City DJs. A Maori version of Space Jam shall be composed to be sung alongside the English version,” and “reform the Justice system so that every citizen is required to prove why they shouldn’t be in prison.” For some, this is reminiscent of the Bill and Ben Party; for others, this is a sober reminder that no one party can truly represent our interests – but for most, this is a fucking good laugh. Greatest ShitsRather amazingly, I’ve been given the opportunity to present the Greatest Shit award to actual shit. Last week, as John Banks made his way to the courtroom (regarding anonymous donations), an elderly protester threw a bucket of manure at him. The look on Banksy’s face was one of pure shock, and the protester didn’t hesitate to let loose on his criticisms. It’s an amusing video if you get the chance to have a look.
Greatest HitsOver the past few weeks, Campbell Live has been running an “at home with the leaders” segment, where John Campbell goes to party leaders’ houses and eats the dinner they cook. While it might be a strange twist on Come Dine With Me, it’s a good way to see what the leaders are like as people. Last Monday, the lucky chef was David Cunliffe of the Labour Party. The Greatest Hit doesn’t go to him, however; it goes to his very impressive wife. Karen Price keeps bees, is an environmental lawyer, and a pilot. Although David’s the one who wants to run the country, it’s fairly clear she runs the show. Greatest ShitsThe title of Greatest Shit this week goes to none other than the Prime Minister himself, for a minor scandal known affectionately as “Sausagegate.” At the recent National Party Conference in Queenstown, John Key decided to host a sausage sizzle, giving them away to curious locals. What he didn’t realise, however, was that two girls were also hosting a sausage sizzle nearby, attempting to fundraise for a trip. Given their proximity to the free sausages, they struggled to make many sales. Thankfully, once John realised, he donated a few dollars to their cause.
Greatest HitsThis week’s Greatest Hit goes to my favourite NZ politician/DJ hybrid. No, not Kim Dotcom (whose album ‘Good Times’ spurred an active Facebook campaign to get him to Starters Bar during O-Week), but Laneway alumna Jacinda Ardern. After realising her flight from Wellington to Auckland was cancelled, stranding a number of people at the airport, she picked up the last rental car. Rather than dashing away like Paula Bennett with a poor person’s Easter chocolate, she circled back around and picked up three students. Thanks to Jacinda’s generosity, three more people were able to make it home for the holidays. I can only assume the lucky passengers were treated to a seven hour playlist of DJ Ardern’s favourite tracks. Greatest ShitsIf there’s one MP that’s good for banter, it’s Clare Curran. The Dunedin South resident constantly provides me with glorious, laugh-out-loud Tweets, and I live for the day when she’ll let me interview her. That is, so long as she doesn’t pash me. On a recent episode of 7Days, Clare Curran ended her Yes Minister segment by planting a kiss on the lips of comedian Tim Batt. While I admire her forwardness and don’t deny that MPs should be able to find love in whatever hopeless place they deem fit, it’s not exactly what I like to see on national television. At least she’s not afraid to truly engage with voters.
Greatest hitsOn Tuesday, Tau Henare, National MP, announced that he will retire at this year’s election. This is not the greatest hit; rather it’s Tau himself, who has a twenty-year political career that can be characterised by witty retorts and an “I will say whatever I want” mentality. Starting out in NZ First when he won the Northern Māori electorate, he broke off with four other members in 1998 to form the Mauri Pacific Party. That was short lived, however, as Mauri Pacific did not meet the five per cent threshold required to secure a place. From there, Tau joined the National Party, and was re-elected into Parliament in 2005. Tau is choosing now to retire following the revelation that he’ll be pushed much further down the National Party list, saying he “deserves better from the National Party. Tau is also well known for a brawl with Trevor Mallard, commenting that he “should have hit him first.” The two MPs are fairly chummy now, bantering back and forth on Twitter. Tau’s Twitter name is West Side Tory, a conservative take on a beloved musical that has long put him in my Twitter good books. Greatest shitsIt was revealed on Tuesday that the Government is allowing the Department of Conservation’s biggest forest park to be opened for gas and oil exploration. Victoria Park is one step down from a National Park, which means it is not as protected by regulations. This is bad enough, as NZ should be valuing its natural landscape for more than perpetuating the “drill baby drill” ideology. The Greatest Shit title, however, goes to Simon Bridges. The Energy and Resources Minister signed off on the exploration, but when asked by a reporter “have you heard of the Victoria Forest Park?” he responded, “I haven’t, no.” Good one, Simon, you don’t even know the park you’ve agreed to allow drilling in. Notable mention: Hekia Parata, once again suggesting she picks her initiatives out of a hat, has announced the merger of two Christchurch schools, Phillipstown and Woolton. This means the former will be shut down. It also means she completely ignored what the local community had to say.
Greatest HitsThis week has seen the rise of #nomakeupselfies across the world. Raising $3 million for cancer research, the trend has occupied Facebook, the media, and, surprisingly, Parliament. I followed Louise Upston’s no-makeup Twitter trail, with Metiria Turei and Holly Walker offering selfies of support, and ended up at Seven Sharp to find Anne Tolley, Jacinda Ardern, Jo Goodhew, Louisa Wall, Mojo Mathers, and Jacqui Dean also revealing all on camera. While there has been a considerable amount of criticism over the “point” of a no-makeup selfie, you can’t deny that it has been incredibly effective. Greatest ShitsOver the weekend, a bunch of us young political nerds got together for a good old BYO. Most of us already know each other from classes or Clubs Day, so drinking and debating is not exactly a new experience. It was intended to be a peaceable affair, as chances are we’re going to be seeing a lot of each other in the coming months; and really, who doesn’t love the chance to have a Saturday night BYO and a stint on the Alibi dance floor. I was told, however, that a member of a certain red party told other members not to attend (don’t worry, they still did) – because I’d write terrible things about fraternising with the enemy and the like. Well, I had no intention of writing about our lovely BYO. That would be shooting myself in the foot, as I was there. Upon hearing this, however, I thought to myself, “what is Critic if not facetious.” Therefore, this week’s Greatest Shit goes to the unending menial bureaucracy of political parties and their tendency to be far too uptight for their own good. Apparently, that extends beyond the Beehive and right into our very own sacred BYO joints. Very notable mention: Hekia Parata’s continued incompetence and the poor handling of the Kohanga Reo Trust scandal. A considerable amount of news time has been dedicated to questioning whether it’s a cover up or a fuck up, and once the truth is revealed (it hasn’t at the time of writing), I’m sure it has the potential to take the Greatest Shit headlining act.
Greatest HitsOn Wednesday morning a new set of changes to the electoral law was passed. While there is considerable criticism about a number of aspects, there is a particular redeeming feature that will finally catapult our elections into modernity: now you can enrol to vote online. For those of us who prefer to use the Internet to snail mail, this is great. Unfortunately, you can’t quite vote online yet, so you still have to leave your computer on 20 September. Greatest ShitsAnadarko has failed once again. Despite the Government’s insistence that deep sea oil drilling is a good idea, the Texan company has been unable to hunt out fossil fuels in Otago and is set to say goodbye to NZ waters. This comes as much frustration to the pro-oil lobby, while anti-oil protesters are able to happily say, “I told you so.” When asked about the failure, the chief executive of the Petroleum Exploration and Production Association of New Zealand said, “the oil is where the oil is and the only way to find it is to drill for it.” Thanks for that pearl of wisdom, David.
Greatest HitsIt was very tempting to award Greatest Hit to John Key for choosing 20 September as the election date, as a few Critic staff were recipients of healthy iPredict payouts (myself included); but in the interest of providing students with something a little better than “should’ve got on the insider trading buzz,” the award goes elsewhere. It’s therefore not the man in blue who gets the prize; it’s the idea of a blue zone. Over the weekend, the Greens proposed that the Government set up a blue zone in Christchurch to allow homeowners of flood-damaged properties to get the hell out. Based on the red zone, the $140 million idea is one that would help the poor citizens of Christchurch deal with this latest setback. Notable mention: the Baywatch-style shot of David Shearer and his dog during Paul Henry’s MP pet therapy segment. Greatest ShitsIt seems it only took two days for the Beehive to kick-start the election drama, and while much of it was shit-worthy, there is one particular instance that undoubtedly takes the Greatest Shit cake: milkgate. It was revealed that Judith Collins, our ever eloquent and graceful Justice Minister, took an “official trip” to China with her husband and had dinner with a few too many Chinese big shots. Costing over $30,000 in taxpayer money, this conflict of interest resulted in a snap debate in the House on Wednesday. Highlights include classic Winston racism and Gareth Hughes insinuating that Collins is “rancid milk.” John Key is “disappointed,” and while at the time of writing Judith has not yet resigned, there is still time.
Greatest HitSometimes it’s easy to get so caught up in the humdrum of menial political drama that we forget we don’t actually live in a hilarious equilibrium of MP DJs (looking at you, Jacinda) and in-the-house banter. We do have a global context, and we have a proud history of attempting to stand up for the little guy. In recognition of this, the first Greatest Hit goes to Parliament’s unanimous support of Murray McCully’s motion to “express deep concern at the Russian Federation’s violation of Ukrainian sovereignty and territorial integrity.” As the potentially disastrous situation unfolds, it’s good to know our Parliament recognises the need to give support, even if only in words. Greatest ShitChoosing a very first Greatest Shit was a challenge, as New Zealand politics has been particularly fun-filled this past week. We’ve seen the NZ Taxpayers Union accuse Mojo Mathers of wasting taxpayer money (she attended an interview in person because she’s deaf); Judith Collins had her antics in China questioned; and Cunliffe came under the spotlight for his secretive trust funds. While all of these were hot contenders, the winner comes in the form of Clare Curran. The Labour MP accidentally emailed a confidential set of policy documents to National’s Amy Adams (although it was later revealed that apparently a staffer made the mistake). The documents included proposed Internet caps, a Digital Bill of Rights, and a plethora of Kiwi-prefixed plans that are largely uninteresting if not for proving the longevity of National’s ‘Iwi/Kiwi’ campaign. Amy had apparently been accidentally included before, commenting “they invited me to a strategy session just after Mr Cunliffe became leader so I'm starting to get a complex.” Looks like the GCSB won’t end up having much of a job if Clare keeps at it.