Liquor Ban
3 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 1.
-
NewsIssue 6 01/04/2012
Hyde Street Galvanises Fun Police
Battle lines have been drawn over the much-publicised North Dunedin Liquor Ban proposed by the DCC. The liquor ban proposal has been sitting on the table since the beginning of the year. The council’s initial proposal was debated heatedly on campus early in the semester but it seemed to sit on the back burner in recent weeks. But along came Hyde Street. Caved-in roofs, unruly behaviour and public intoxication have brought the proposed liquor ban roaring straight back into the student spotlight. Locals see it as a potential solution for future mayhem. Students, not so much. Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull has said that “this is not about control, this is about keeping people safe”. The DCC has officially approved the proposal and the only thing standing in its way is the submissions process. Vice-Chancellor Harlene Hayne added, “We have to do more than just ban students from being on roofs.” Landlords have called for tighter control and tougher penalties for people who misbehave and damage property. Police reportedly support the proposal if it can reduce harm. OUSA submitted one of seven submissions regarding the liquor ban to the DCC. Their submission is accompanied by a petition which gained thousands of signatures earlier in the semester to form an unstoppable one-two punch to defend student freedoms. OUSA cites recent improvements in student behaviour and a marked change in attitude against anti-social behaviour from the general student population, both of which make the ban unnecessary. OUSA’s submission claims that “The 2012 Hyde Street Keg Party went as planned and the issues that remain can be remedied,” and the association proposes a more proactive strategy for reducing anti-social behaviour rather than a blanket ban which may become unenforceable. The 30-day period for making submissions closed on March 26 but if you have something to say on this one the DCC will still accept e-mailed submissions.
-
News
Issue 4 18/03/2012Powers that be make rules. Rules made to be broken.
Confusion has arisen over the enforcement of the proposed glass ban for the Hyde Street Keg Party. Hyde Street Party posters distributed by OUSA throughout the University state that the event is to be glass-free and that $200 fines can be dished out. However, OUSA do not have the authority to issue fines for possession of glass (nor do they want to). In order for a legitimate fine to be imposed, the Dunedin City Council (DCC) would have to pass a by-law making the possession of glass on Hyde Street illegal. Critic understands that no effort to do so is underway, and it is highly unlikely that it will happen before Hyde Street kicks off. The University has a similarly limited power to impose fines. The Proctor has said that people who are identified as breaking bottles and have not been arrested by police may have their names passed on to him. This could result in a fine; however, the Proctor points out that he and the University “have no authority to fine anyone [merely] for having glass.” The Dunedin Police, who will have a presence at the event, have been made aware of the glass ban, but were just as curious as Critic as to its legal standing. A Police representative told Critic that he would like to know “who will enforce that.” Critic also spoke with Michael Bathgate from the DCC, who reiterated that the glass ban was a condition of the road closure as agreed to by a number of parties. When asked who could enforce it, Mr. Bathgate responded, “the organizer can enforce it and that’s all I’d like to say on the matter.” Which, given that OUSA is the organizer of the event, this just takes us back to square one. OUSA’s Communications Department confirmed that OUSA has no authority either to restrict access to Hyde Street, or to enforce the no-glass policy. However Critic warns that while there may be nothing prohibiting students turning up carrying beer bottles, fish tanks, or large glass dildos, students acting irresponsibly and purposefully breaking glass may see themselves heading in the direction of the Proctor or being dealt with by Police. A glass ban is obviously a positive step towards running a safer event for everyone. Regardless of OUSA’s muddled stance on glass regulations, their input this year has been well-received and even hailed as “perfect” by many Hyde Street residents who “don’t wanna clean up glass.” Vice-Chancellor Harlene Hayne is confident that “OUSA’s involvement will go a long way to maximizing the fun while at the same time minimizing the harm.” The Proctor felt the presence of OUSA “can only assist”, pointing out that it is more effective for students to be corralled by OUSA than by a line of police.
-
News
Issue 1 24/02/2012North Dunedin Street Drinking Culled?
Beverage-loving students are breaking down in tears after the Dunedin City Council took the first step towards a permanent ban on drinking in North Dunedin streets. The ban, if it goes ahead, will cover the area bordered by Queen Street, Opoho Road, Logan Park, and the railway line. Currently, drinking in the street is only banned in the CBD area. The proposed liquor ban, which is supported by police and the University, has been considered by the council several times since the first Undie 500 riots in 2006. But this time, it appears the DCC means business. On 8 February, the Council voted to send the proposed ban to the public for consultation. Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull says the ban is primarily designed to reduce “unsafe behaviour” in the student area. The DCC and the University are also concerned about drunken street parties damaging Dunedin’s reputation. Cull suggested that police “would be required to warn [rather than arrest in the first instance] so as long as someone complied, I imagine there would be no further consequences. Much as it works now.” OUSA President Logan Edgar says “OUSA recognises that some aspects of Dunedin’s alcohol culture are harmful, and we condemn couch fires and any behaviour that ruins things for the rest of us.” But he criticised the proposed ban as a “sticking plaster” that would not stop alcohol-related harm. “It’s going to do nothing, except stopping people having a bottle of wine in the park with their girlfriend or boyfriend.” The proposed ban is particularly targeted at large student gatherings such as the annual Hyde Street keg party, which the DCC regards as dangerous in its current form. Edgar is confident that the liquor ban would “not stop Hyde Street” due to the difficulty of actually enforcing the ban. Cull says the DCC is “absolutely” prepared to work with OUSA to come up with ways to make events such as the Hyde Street keg party safer, rather than shutting them down entirely. But he wants to “do that within the liquor ban. That way we can have more control over rules that would make it safe. For example, you might only be allowed to have kegs so no glass bottles can get thrown around.” The 2012 Hyde Street Keg Party is scheduled for Saturday 24 March. Edgar argues that stricter penalties for behaviour that is currently illegal would be preferable to a liquor ban: “I’m more comfortable with that than taking away students’ liberties”. Edgar will meet with Vice-Chancellor Harlene Hayne over the next few weeks to discuss potential alternatives to an outright ban. He also hopes to engage the Mayor in debate. The public can make submissions on the proposed ban from 25 February to 26 March. Edgar is writing a public submission on behalf of OUSA, and has also started a petition opposing the liquor ban, which as of 23 February had already been signed by 3000 people.