Wee Doubt
Contributor
Articles by Wee Doubt
45 articles found. Displaying page 4 of 4.
-
Columns
Issue 9 26/04/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 9
In 1998 Andrew Wakefield, a British former surgeon and medical researcher, published a fraudulent research paper in support of the now-discredited claim that there was a link between the administration of the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine (MMR), and the appearance of autism and bowel disease. He fabricated evidence and was later convicted of 36 charges of malpractice, including four counts of dishonesty and 12 counts involving the abuse of developmentally challenged children.
-
Columns
Issue 8 19/04/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 8
In 2006 a book was published that has gone on to sell 19 million copies worldwide by promising everybody literally everything they ever wanted. That book is The Secret by Rhonda Byrne.
-
Columns
Issue 7 12/04/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 7
The most controversial Facebook post I’ve ever written was one that said: “I can’t believe how many of my friends who would never judge someone based on their race, gender or sexuality are happy to make massive, sweeping, shameless assumptions about people based on the month they are born in.” This post was followed by a tirade of comments that accused me of not understanding the nuances of astrology and the skill behind drawing up star-charts, and emphasising my arrogance for criticising something I didn’t understand. Astrology is a fucking pre-Copernican system. It comes from a time when we thought that the Earth was the centre of the solar system. Copernicus risked torture and execution for his theory that the Earth goes round the Sun. Show him some respect and ditch the astrology. I have had to fill in my star sign on a job application form. I have had a virtual stranger tell me that my boyfriend and I were compatible because we had complementary star signs. (We had been together for three years.) I’ve had a pregnant woman tell me she was hoping her baby would be born a week after its due date so that it would be a Pisces instead of an Aquarius. I think we should look at people who believe in star signs in a similar way to how we look at other bigots. I’ve been told that, being a Taurus, I am almost certainly gluttonous, stubborn and unimaginative. If you don’t think this is offensive, try replacing “Taurean” with “Korean”. “Being Korean, you are almost certainly gluttonous, stubborn and unimaginative.” How does that sound? The answer is it sounds unmistakably, unforgivably, disgustingly racist. And also eye-suckingly crazy. If you judge a person by their star-sign, you are signist. If you say someone is “balanced, for a Gemini”, you are signist. If you say, “I’ve been out with three Aquarians and they were all nuts”, you are signist. But, astrologers would argue, your sun sign is only part of it. True astrologers recognise that you need a map of the solar system to determine the character of a person. Even then the person’s fate is not set, as they can recognise their character and work to change it. That sounds like being a human. Why can’t we just get to know people, learn from our mistakes and try to be better? What do we need astrology for? And why do people keep asking each other what their fucking star sign is?
-
Columns
Issue 6 29/03/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 6
Wake up and smell the wee! Would you drink your own piss for the sake of your health? Because doing it every day will, according to some, cure you of pretty much everything from acne to cancer. The first big wee in the morning is the most effective, with urine taken mid-stream and then drunk fresh and steaming or mixed with juice or served over fruit. However, participants in urine therapy should expect to endure around six months of nausea, stomach pain, diarrhoea and vomiting. This is supposedly your body’s response to releasing “toxins” from your system. Maybe. Or maybe you are feeling sick because you’re drinking wee. Urine is 95 per cent water, but it also contains small quantities of nutrients including sodium, calcium, folic acid, iron, magnesium and zinc. According to extremehealthradio.com, drinking urine helps the immune system by reminding it of the substances it has already encountered, similar to “reading a book for the second time.” It has purported antiseptic qualities, though if this is the case I don’t know why you would want to put it into your stomach every day and risk disrupting the delicate balance of bacteria the gut needs to function healthily. Drinking urine supposedly improves skin tone and energy levels. The website also claims that urine therapy prevents and treats arthritis, cancer, hepatitis (type not specified), MS, eczema, psoriasis, diabetes, herpes, adrenal failure and pretty much any other illness. Warning bells should go off in your head when you read something “cures cancer”. This jumps the line between an eccentric lifestyle choice and a very dangerous, possibly life-threatening idea. If someone chooses to forego medical treatment for cancer in favour of urine therapy, they may well die. Proponents of urine therapy believe that the magical qualities of wee have been kept under wraps by pharmaceutical companies because there is no way to make money from telling people to drink piss. To believe this you have to believe that every doctor you know would rather see you die of cancer or suffer with disease than tell you about the secret miracle cure you are carrying around in your own bladder. I don’t think that indulging in urine therapy occasionally will do you any harm, save from having to live with the knowledge that you’ve drunk your own feculence. But I, Wee Doubt, doubt that drinking wee will do you any good.
-
Columns
Issue 5 22/03/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 5
Romantic comedies, love stories, dating websites and the wedding industry would have you believe that somewhere in the world there is a person for you, and not just any person but your “soul mate”. One day you will find the only person who really knows you, who understands you and, most importantly, will love you for the rest of your life, or even for eternity. So if there really is just one person in the world for you, how likely is it that you will find them? If there really is just one person for you in the world, that’s bad news. Randall Munroe, author of a book dealing with absurd hypothetical questions called What If?, calculated the likelihood of finding your one true soul mate. Assuming your soul mate is alive at the same time as you, and that you would like to meet someone within your age group, Munroe estimates the number of times people make eye contact with strangers every day and calculates the likelihood of you finding your special someone to be 1 in 10,000. This is assuming you will recognise each other and fall in love the instant your eyes meet. Munroe puts the average number of living candidates for your soul mate at half a billion, but if there is only one person in the world for you at any point in history, that number climbs to one hundred billion. With only seven billion people alive now, 90 per cent of our soul mates are dead. But it gets worse. Your soul mate may not be born yet! Putting aside the inevitable destruction of the Earth, and most probable extinction of humans long before that, we need to include an unknowable number of possible soul mates in the future. The likelihood of you being born in the same century, yet alone meeting them, becomes practically zilch. So if you haven’t found “The One” yet, feel comfort in the fact that probably nobody in history ever has either. Maybe we should replace the expression “soul mate” with “person whose company I enjoy and who can tolerate me for a few decades until we both die”. Be happy that there isn’t just one person in the world that you are compatible with. Even if your true love is one in a million, there are still 4.5 of them in New Zealand.
-
Columns
Issue 4 15/03/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 4
T he first definition of “virginity” in The Urban Dictionary is “What women are proud to have and men are ashamed of.” This sums up our culture’s obsession with “virginity” as a tangible part of a person. But outside of its cultural context, virginity is a myth. Men are expected to be physically unaltered through losing their virginity, but women are still often expected to have physical changes. The hymen is a thin membrane of skin covering the vaginal opening — its presence in many traditions is considered evidence that a woman is a virgin. However, the hymen varies in shape and form, with some hymens covering nearly the entire entrance to the vagina and others being barely present at all. A hymen may not even be detectable in a “virgin” vagina. A hymen can be broken through activities other than penetrative sex, such as exercise. In many cases, if the woman is properly aroused, her hymen will often stretch to accommodate a penis during penetrative sex and return to its original shape. Only rough sex or a lack of lubrication will damage many hymens. The traditional definition of loss of “virginity” is through penetrative vaginal sex, so a woman could have sex with other women her whole life and still be a “virgin”. Having oral or anal sex may or may not be considered “losing your virginity” depending on who you talk to. Penetrative vaginal sex may not lead to female orgasm, even after years of sexual activity. So a woman who has never had an orgasm can be considered a non-virgin by having a man orgasm by means of her body. If the reverse were true and a man was considered a non-virgin only when a woman had achieved orgasm through penetrative sex with him, a man could have sex for his whole life and still be a “virgin”. If virginity were to be defined as a person achieving personal sexual gratification, then what would losing your virginity entail? Achieving orgasm through penetrative sex? Penetration by an object? Any kind of sexual contact with another person? On your own? The whole concept of “virginity” is outdated and meaningless. If a person wishes to partake in or abstain from sexual contact with another person for any reason, that is entirely their business. They don’t need an antiquated and sexist label imposed on them by a ridiculous tradition.
-
Columns
Issue 3 08/03/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 3
There’s nothing like a shitty cold to make you feel terrible for a week and turn you into a disgusting walking bag of mucous: mucous that makes a frequent and dramatic exit via two small portals on your face. If there were a medication I could take to stop me from getting a cold for the rest of my life, I’d pay a lot for it, take it happily and skip home clicking my heels. Enter “immune boosters”: the pills, potions and powders that claim to strengthen your immune system and help prevent the common cold by making your body too damn tough for those snotty little arsehole viruses to get in. However, there is a problem: boosting your immune system is the last thing you want to do to prevent colds. There are over 200 different viruses that cause the common cold, most of which are harmless. The unpleasant symptoms we experience with a cold are the result of your immune system going haywire over nothing. If “boosting” medications did anything, they would only be encouraging your melodramatic immune system. Medication to relieve symptoms, such as antihistamines, pain-killers and anti-inflammatories, works by suppressing your immune system’s response to the virus, not “boosting” it. Once you have been infected by a particular virus, it can’t infect you again; you become immune to it. This is the reason why older people get fewer colds than teenagers: they’ve been exposed to more cold-causing viruses over the course of their life. I looked at some immune boosters at a local pharmacy to see what they claimed to do. Most pussyfooted around the folk-myth that colds are the result of an attack on a weak immune system while not actually mentioning either colds or flus. For example, Echimax™’s product claimed to be “for optimal winter wellness”, while Viralex®’s “Supports the body’s daily defence.” Comvita™ Coldclear was the only one touting “immune boosting action which helps relieve symptoms of colds and flus.” This claim is supposedly backed by “traditional and scientific studies,” but I couldn’t find any reference to what these studies were on their website. I emailed them. I ended my research after their polite but evasive reply: “Our full evidence list consists of some proprietary information and unfortunately I am unable to share this with you.”
-
Columns
Issue 2 01/03/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 2
Imagine if I were to show you a million dollars in cash with one hand and a loaded gun with the other. I then tell you that I will give you the money and walk away if you believe that John Key is, at that moment, wearing a chicken suit and riding a tricycle to Helen Clark’s house for a play-date. If you don’t believe me, I will shoot you in the face. Assuming that you want the money and don’t want to die, you have everything to gain by choosing to believe this is true. But even if disbelief means certain death, would you really believe it? If I could see into your brain and know whether you truly believed my statement (rather than desperately wanting to believe it), would I be convinced by what I saw? Or would I still shoot you? Blaise Pascal, a seventeenth-century French philosopher, thought that by not believing in God you were taking a huge personal risk. His “wager” went like this: even if God’s existence seems extremely improbable to you, you should still believe in him because you have nothing to lose and everything to gain. If God exists and you believe in him, you get into heaven. If God doesn’t exist and you either believe in him or you don’t, nothing happens. But if you don’t believe in him and he does exist, you risk missing out on heaven and landing yourself in hell for eternity. So, according to Pascal, it is rational to believe in God. The problem is the difference between wanting to believe in something and actually believing in something. It may be rational to try to believe, but if you can’t make yourself believe anything, you don’t have good reason to believe. As in the example with the money and the gun, if you searched the world for evidence of God, went to church every day, prayed to God, read the Bible (which, of course, assumes you’ve picked the right God), studied theosophy and told everybody around you that you believed in him, but you still knew in your mind that you really didn’t believe at all, would God be convinced? Or would he go ahead and smite you for lying? Surely God would appreciate you admitting to honest disbelief more than having you lie about believing in him. A sincere disbelief in God (or John Key on a tricycle) is more admirable than an insincere hedging of your bets to try to win yourself a reward.
-
Columns
Issue 1 22/02/2015Skeptic Schism | Issue 1
Ah, the 1790s. A time before germ theory and anaesthesia, when medical doctors would bleed, purge and burn their patients to restore their four “humours”, or life forces, to balance. Miasma theory, the idea that disease was caused by bad smells, was considered a radical new science. Witch-hunts were still at large in Europe. And Samuel Hahnemann invented homeopathy. Hahnemann’s idea was simple: that “like cures like”. After being administered a tiny dose of a substance that causes similar symptoms to those suffered by the patient, the body would respond by healing itself. For example, hay fever makes you cry and onions make you cry; therefore (in Hahnemann’s logic), onions cure hay fever. Rather than rubbing onions into the patient’s eyes, Hahnemann devised a way to dilute the onion in water to a very tiny amount. Water was put into a vial and banged several times against a leather-bound book, preferably a Bible. This would supposedly activate the water’s ability to retain a “memory”. Then a small part of the onion was added, the vial was shaken in a specific way, and a single drop from it added to another hundred drops of water. This process was repeated until no single molecule of the original substance remained in the water. The “memory” of the substance was said to remain in the water, ready for the body to respond to when it was administered to the patient. If you think modern homeopathy is less wacky than this, think again. A small sample of substances used as base ingredients in today’s homeopathic concoctions are: the liver of a duck, a spider ground up alive, table salt, the breast milk of a German Shepherd dog, beer, menstrual blood and, no joke, dog shit. Thankfully, no trace of these substances is left in the preparations by the time they are consumed. In fact, in one British investigation of homeopathy the machines used to dose sugar pills with the diluted concoctions were regularly causing the drops to miss their destination, so none of the water was reaching the pills at all. Attempts to prove homeopathy’s efficacy have been foiled by revelations of biased, cherry-picked, shaky data and a failure to replicate positive results in careful, double-blind studies. Rival medical treatments from its time, such as whipping out demons, blistering patients’ skin to release bad humours and half drowning patients in icy water, have disappeared because they are painful and dangerous. Homeopathy has endured because it is painless. But its theory is as illogical as any of its maddest contemporaries. Don’t waste your money on it.