Elisabeth Larsen
Contributor
Articles by Elisabeth Larsen
8 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 1.
-
Columns
Issue 27 12/10/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 27
What did you do in the last 15 minutes? Walk to Uni, waste time on facebook, take a long shower that annoyed your flatties? 15 minutes feels eternal from a Monday morning lecture theatre, but in the grand scheme it’s a fraction of a microsecond. Yet every 15 minutes something happens that is very significant in the grand scheme. On average, a species on planet earth becomes extinct every 15 minutes. That’s four an hour, and nearly a hundred per day. That’s 35,040 a year. Just forget who favourited your latest Tweet for a second and let that sink in – 350,400 over the next ten years if this keeps up (this is a moderate estimate – conservative estimates consist of 50 a day, extreme ones of up to 150). And if you believe World Wildlife Fund, who published an article in The Guardian last week, then you’ll be shocked to know that in the past 40 years earth has lost half of its wildlife. But why has this happened? What on this rapidly depleting earth could have possibly gone so frighteningly, horrifically wrong? WWF attributes it to a number of sources. Climate change accounts for seven per cent of the species that have become extinct, and habitat degradation or change for another 31 per cent. Total loss of habitat counts for another 13 per cent of the species lost, and “other” for another 11 per cent. However, the overwhelming reason attributable to this huge reduction in animal species is exploitation, the cause that accounts for a whopping 37 per cent of the species that are now gone forever. “Exploitation” here doesn’t imply paying children six cents a day to slave away in a sweatshop somewhere in Asia. But it is synonymous with “capitalisation” – it has to do with the act of making use and benefiting from resources. In short, consumerism is killing. And we can’t forget the astounding amounts of rubbish we are producing, which is also contributing to all of this. According to National Geographic, Americans produced 251 million tons of trash in 2006 (this is the most recent Environmental Protection Agency record available). Over half of this ended up in landfill. Particularly in the Western world, we are poisoning our planet and the other beautiful living creatures we are so lucky to share it with. The human global population has boomed in the last 40 years. According to Geohive, in 1964 the global population was around 3.25 billion. As you read this, it’s well over 7.25 billion and growing all the time. You’ve read my angry rants about how supply and demand is ruining our morality – cheap eggs from fucking miserable tortured hens, anyone?? Coupled with this population growth, we are running our planet into the ground. Maybe if we all worked on being a little less demanding, and a little more responsible and thoughtful with our actions, we won’t see dolphins, deer and dugong dying like the dinosaurs and the dodo. Is it really worth your new iPhone 6? I guess it does have a slightly bigger screen. What the fuck does ruining the earth matter if you have that.
-
Columns
Issue 25 28/09/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 25
More and more people are rejecting the “absolute” nature of veganism. The “all or nothing” attitude can be very alienating, and even put people off considering going vegan. And it’s difficult in today’s world as well. We aren’t growing our own crops, instead relying on the integrated markets. Sometimes animal rights groups reject other groups that help animals because of ideological differences. However here at Otago SALDF we have a more pragmatic approach to the animal rights movement. We support anyone that helps animals. Period. And this is consistent with an emerging popular view on the appropriate manner of veganism. Very few people exclude “trace amount” quantities of dairy or egg because of their vegan lifestyle. Even “radicals” PETA are less interested in “personal purity” than in sending a message to producers that there is a growing market for food with vegan ingredients. There is an argument that we shouldn’t be supporting industries that use animal products at all, if we truly want to be vegan. But there is a fundamental difference between boycotting McDonalds and boycotting New World. Even “part-time” vegetarianism or veganism reduces the number of animals killed for our plates. There are bigger things going on than worrying about whether those Oreos may contain an undetectable amount of dairy because of the factory they were produced in. We’re lucky we aren’t in Europe, where pig bones and hooves are used to pave roads. Regardless of how committed you are and how deeply you care, it might not be possible to avoid using animal derived products entirely. Lack of funds is not an excuse for continuing to consume cheap, cruel meat or eggs, because plant foods are considerably cheaper. With the right knowledge and resources you can even save a lot of money. But I empathise. Our flats are cold and damp. We have little money for heating. In these circumstances, it is okay to hold onto those waterproof leather boots you’ve had for years, that ancient woollen jersey or your old duck-down duvet or puffer jacket. And by all means, eat that cheesy pasta thing that would be chucked otherwise. You just don’t need to buy any more. No, you really don’t. I know wastage is a pretty permissible reason to detract from purity for a moment, when 20,000 children will starve to death today (sorry to depress you, but it’s the reality of the world we live in). What is more important is that you’re reducing your consumption of animal-derived products, sending a strong message to marketers, and influencing others into making kinder choices every day.
-
Columns
Issue 23 14/09/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 23
As a student, I’m always keen to scope out cheap restaurants. Circadian Rhythm on St Andrew’s Street (just down from Starbucks, Auckland girls) is one of my favourites. The food is excellent value for money, the staff are lovely, they have adorable hipster-friendly board-games and squashy couches, and they have jazz nights and poetry readings. And their food is 98 per cent vegan. I went there with a friend who discretely commented on the “sickly looking vegans” there. And she wasn’t wrong. Many vegans or vegetarians don’t get adequate sustenance and do look very run down. We even studied a case for Family Law about a baby who died from malnutrition after his raw-food vegan mother breastfed him. Remember that you can get very run-down on an omnivorous diet too. Imagine living on Burger King’s Creamy Mayo Cheeseburgers for a month, and they’re full of meat, dairy and eggs. You’d feel awful. You’d feel the same after just eating Oreos, BBQ Shapes and drinking V – and they’re vegan. So the key is to make sure you get all the nutrients your body needs. Makes sense, right? And it may be trickier on a vegetarian or vegan diet, but it’s definitely not impossible. You could save a lot of money too. Pulses and legumes (think lentils, chickpeas and beans) are far better value for money than meat and eggs. But you need to get enough protein and iron, which is easy if you know how to do it. Women need 46g of protein per day, and men need 56g. A serve of chick peas (100g) has 19g of protein. A 100g serving of black beans (AWESOME in Mexican dishes) has 22g. Half a cup of tempeh (delicious pressed tofu) has 15 grams of protein. And just two tablespoons of chia seeds will give you 4g. Iron is a little trickier. Most vegans and vegetarians have to take a supplement, I won’t lie to you. Women need 18mg per day, and men just 8mg. A cup of cooked spinach will give you 2.7mg, and silverbeet 2.53mg. Vitamin B12 is a bacteria found in the soil. It is most easily consumed via animal sources, so it’s a trump card for people who want to find fault in a vegan diet. It’s also very important – the baby with the vegan mother would have been saved by B12 injections. It’s easy and cheap to get enough via Pam’s Soy Milk, and a number of other plant milks have it as a supplement as well (such as almonds and rice). Alternatively, there are tablet supplements. Getting all your nutrients on a vegan diet is possible. You’ll also save money and reduce your impact on the environment, and will probably lose weight too. But if you’re thinking of going vegan, then please don’t go all self-righteous on us. I reckon the worst myth surrounding vegans is that they’re all dicks.
-
Columns
Issue 21 31/08/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 21
For all of us over at the Law School, the Honourable Michael Kirby requires no introduction. He served as a Justice of Australia’s highest court from 1996 until 2009. Though he is well into his 70s, Michael is now chairing the UN Human Rights Commission of Inquiry, investigating human rights abuses in North Korea. A couple of Tuesdays ago he gave a devastating account of the current situation. He later met with the LLB Hons students and SALDF. Michael Kirby has been a personal hero of mine for a long time. Beyond frequenting my textbooks, he is also openly gay and a passionate advocate of animal welfare. And he is a really lovely person with a wicked sense of humour and an acute interest in Marxist philosophy. While from a judiciary traditionally dominated by straight conservatives (mostly white, middle-class men), he is admired by us filthy left-wingers. You can imagine my excitement when I happened across him in the foyer of Richardson and was introduced to him by our Dean in the lift. Michael then sat next to me in the Law staffroom, as he listened to our Honours students speak about their theses, and then gave his own views on the animal rights movement. He spoke of reading a book on the meat industry in Australia and New Zealand, then never eating meat again. He is moving towards veganism, though he did ask Mark for tea with milk. Interestingly, Michael’s long-term partner Jan (pronounced “Yahn”) is unapologetically carnivorous. When Jan argues that humans were designed to eat meat and that our brains expanded when we did, Michael responds with “as our brains expanded, so did our sense of morality.” He wanted to know New Zealand’s laws on live export, and stressed the ethical concerns and risks of allowing cows to be removed to jurisdictions where we can have no say in their treatment and killing. He described the ways of killing animals in these countries as “grossly disrespectful and degrading.” However, SALDF’s Publications Officer, Oska Rego, pointed out the current situation of intensive animal farming in New Zealand – you, dear reader, must have been living under a rock if you hadn’t noticed the “Stop Factory Farming” nationwide protests. SALDF discussed with Michael New Zealand’s laws on stunning an animal before slaughter; this is a controversial practice because it is inconsistent with Islamic and Jewish beliefs. However, Michael considers that if we must kill animals, ultimately, it is more important to do it as kindly as possible (stunning is unanimously considered kinder to the animal than not) than to honour religious practice. Michael Kirby is known for his eloquent and moving judgements. True to reputation, he left us with the reminder that “they feel anger, distress, fear, and pain, and the killing is very frightening and painful for them. And we definitely know that larger mammals feel love.” Your Honour, I submit that the human larger mammal does not love other animals enough.
-
Columns
Issue 19 10/08/2014Defending the Kingdom | Issue 19
“But, it can’t be that bad if it’s legal!” We irritating bleeding hearts hear this quite regularly in regards to Factory Farming and its continued legality in New Zealand. We even do stuff like rally against it – like we did a couple of weekends ago in New Zealand’s five biggest cities. Indeed we Kiwis do have an Animal Welfare Act, which came into force at the end of the 1990s. Theoretically, it sounds great. It sounds bulletproof. Section four sets out the physical, health, and behavioural needs of animals, which are definitely not accommodated for in current intensive farming practice. They include proper and sufficient food and water, adequate shelter, and opportunity to display normal patterns of behaviour. Under section 10, everyone in charge of an animal must ensure these needs are met, with the stated purpose of ensuring that owners of animals and persons in charge of animals attend properly to the welfare of those animals. 2010’s amendment of section 28 covers the “wilful ill-treatment of animals.” It states that a person commits an offence if that person wilfully ill-treats an animal with the result that the animal is permanently disabled; or the animal dies; or the pain or distress caused to the animal is so great that it is necessary to destroy the animal in order to end its suffering; or the animal is seriously injured or impaired. And there are serious penalties for violation of these laws, too. An individual person who does it can be fined up to $100,000, or sent to prison for up to five years. A body corporate can be fined up to half a million dollars for a breach of these provisions. So if that is the law, and it has been for 15 years now, then why is Factory Farming still a thing? Why are the loudmouths still bitching about it, if there are laws in place to stop it? The reason is the loophole in the Animal Welfare Act, in Part Five: the defence of compliance with minimal codes of welfare. And the National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee may, in “exceptional circumstances,” recommend minimum standards and recommendations for best practice that do not fully meet the obligations of the provisions. “Exceptional circumstances” include being difficult or expensive to transition. These factors are considered more important than maintaining the integrity of the law. Even though I have a piggy bank in my room, I doubt the real piglets being tortured nationwide care too much about the cost of stamping out Factory Farming for good. So if you want to see change, then in September you need to vote for the political parties that have policies to stamp out Factory Farming: Labour, the Greens, Mana, and the Internet Party. Only through legislative and policy change, and higher minimum standards for the welfare codes, can we save the animals, and ensure a kinder future for them.
-
Columns
Issue 17 27/07/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 17
“BUT I BUY FREE-RANGE! LEAVE ME ALONE, YOU DIRTY STINKING HIPPY!” At some point in the near future, you may well find yourself saying this to some random in New World. He may or may not be wearing hemp pants. With the chia seeds and quinoa in his basket, he peers dubiously at the “free-range” eggs in your own. But it’s ok. You aren’t supporting a cruel industry. You are buying free-range eggs, and that means they came from happy hens, “free to roam in the natural shelter of trees.” Right? Unfortunately, no. Consumer concern at the appalling living conditions of cage egg-producing hens has lead many cafes and restaurants to start using free-range products (both eggs and meat). Even the South Island’s McDonald’s have made the switch from battery eggs. While this is indeed a kinder alternative to factory farmed, in reality there isn’t the enormous disparity in welfare standards that most people envisage. Ultimately, the term “free-range” has no legally sanctioned meaning in New Zealand. There are no legal standards for how much outside space a free-range hen must have, the size of flocks or the provision of grassy paddocks. According to SPCA chief executive Robyn McDonald, many free-range hens are in barns all their lives, eating only grain. Under current law, free-range farmers may supplement their flocks with hens that have spent their life in battery cages. And free-range chicks are bought from battery producers. Remember that the male chicks are killed when they are just a day old because they have no value as layers. And Woodlands, the biggest free-range brand, is owned by cage producer Mainland. This is another huge problem; even if you have no intention to do so, you are supporting the cage egg industry when you buy free-range eggs. Animal welfare campaigner Dr Michael Morris said feather-pecking, cannibalism and disease outbreaks are the biggest welfare problems on free-range farms. He said faced with crowded conditions, some farmers clip the birds’ beaks to stop them hurting one another. And, no, they don’t get anaesthetic. This isn’t what we imagine when we pay up to three times as much money for “free-range” eggs. But, we have to trust the SPCA, right? Even if we don’t trust business giants, most of us feel consoled when purchasing the eggs with “SPCA Approved” stamped on them. However, even the 30 per cent of free-range farmers who hold this qualification (meaning that their farms are audited and approved by SPCA inspectors) are allowed to clip their hens’ beaks. I know that a lot of Critic readers (myself included) love to bake. Fortunately, there are a number of cheap, healthy and delicious substitutes for eggs to help bind it together. I find that Orgran’s No Egg is particularly good in cake mixes. If you don’t want to go out and buy stuff, 1/3 of a cup of mashed banana will have the same effect. Or if you happen to have it, a tablespoon of flaxseed.
-
Columns
Issue 16 20/07/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 16
A few months ago, animal lovers all over the country rejoiced at the news that the notorious Brougham Park egg farm (just over the hill at Mosgiel) was to be closing down. However, the new owner of the property did not wish to keep the farm, and so all the laying hens were to be culled (killed, for all you city slickers). The wonderful Tayla O’Driscoll is a third-year English and Philosophy student here at Otago. She’s also a strict vegan, a smoking hawt six-foot-one model, a strident feminist, and a trusted friend of mine. And while she would whack me for saying it, it’s not an overstatement to call her wonderful. Tayla took it upon herself to rescue as many of the Brougham Park hens as she could. And with extensive time, effort and expenditure, she and a team of activists managed to find homes for all 3,000 hens. This is a truly commendable achievement. Tayla said, “When we began, my personal goal was to save a third of the hens. I told myself that I was not allowed to be disappointed if we managed that. It was a daunting task. When we got closer to saving every single one of them, my heart yearned more. Perhaps the most terrifying moment in this entire process has been just recently, when we only had a few hundred left to save. I didn’t want anyone to be left behind.” With help from SAFE (Saving Animals From Exploitation), NZAVS (New Zealand Anti-Vivisection Society), HUHANZ (Helping You Help Animals), Farmwatch, and social networking sites, Tayla found hundreds of people who were willing to give homes to “the girls.” A team consisting of members of these charities took the last 200–300 hens and delivered them to new homes all over the South Island. Other individuals whom Tayla insisted I honour are Jordan Wyatt and Jenny Stone, who coordinated the Invercargill rescues. They saved a massive 465 hens, and even took some themselves. Those of you who read my article “Finding Fundamental Fault in Factory Farmed Foods” may remember my account of how battery hens are kept. You will hence be unsurprised that some of the Brougham Park hens have died. Some of them are very ill due to years of mistreatment, and likely to die soon. This is the inevitable consequence of high-intensity farming. While the experience was very emotional for everyone involved, Tayla considers that “at least [the hens] had the chance to taste freedom, to experience love and compassion.” It is now uncontested evidence that chickens dream. So do most other birds, as do dogs, cats, pigs, and many rodents. Tayla believes that caged hens dream of freedom. She reminds us that “everyone is capable of making a positive difference. One less farm in New Zealand is a success, but there are still so many more. Start by rescuing animals every day by not consuming their flesh or by-products.”
-
Columns
Issue 10 04/05/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 10
For animal rights activists, Mojo Mathers is a woman who requires no introduction. She is frequently hailed as “the voice for animals,” as well as a trailblazer for people with disabilities. The list MP has been an adviser to the Green Party since 2006, and a Member of Parliament since 2011. She was New Zealand’s first deaf Member of Parliament. Earlier in the month, I attended her talk on animal welfare in New Zealand, hosted by Take Action for Animals. Representatives from all of the city’s animal welfare groups attended. Mojo’s message was about how much animals do for us as people, and that they deserve to be treated with respect and dignity. Most obviously is our consumption of animal products. She also spoke about cosmetic and medical testing, entertainment (such as rodeos, circuses and racing), and pets. We were told about factory farming conditions; pigs and chickens being kept in tiny cages and being subject to great pain, in order to generate maximum business output. Green Party stickers were given out, saying, “I