Alex Carroll
Contributor
Articles by Alex Carroll
2 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 1.
-
Columns
Issue 11 11/05/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 11
Most readers will agree that sexism and racism are bad things, and that there are no tangible differences within the human species. But how would you react if I told you that there are no tangible differences between humans and the entire animal kingdom? I think most readers would consider this outrageous. However, history can be telling. Advocates against speciesism argue that our treatment of non-human animals is no different to how powerful human groups treated other humans throughout history. If during US slavery I walked into a plantation and exclaimed that human races are equal or, prior to suffrage, I treated woman as equals, I would have been met with contempt and outrage. While I understand that the concept of animals as equals is radical to many, I would like to offer this article as food for thought (no pun intended). “Speciesism,” widely defined, is the unequal treatment of an individual purely due to their species. More specifically, the Oxford Dictionary defines it as “the assumption of human superiority leading to the exploitation of animals.” This assumption is well rooted in our psyche. In the fourth century BCE, Aristotle spoke of how non-human animals exist for human use, and to an extent this view remains pervasive today. This impression is based on the idea that intelligence is the ultimate mark of a living being’s worth. Monkeys are smart so eating them is abominable, yet sheep are stupid so killing roughly 25 million a year in NZ is okay. This is clearly anthropocentric because, while humans developed intelligence, other animals developed different traits to cope with their environment. The cheetah developed speed, the turtle its shell and the dog its sense of smell. The only test that awards intelligence as the best trait is human made, and is thus biased. Advocates for an end to speciesism do not hope for a world where human and pig can go to a bar together and share a beer. What they strive for is that the automatic assumption that non-human animal interests are below those of humans should end. Because all animals are cognisant and able to feel pain, they inherently have interests of their own that deserve to be respected. These are likely to be distinct from humans, because a cow has no use for a right to vote. However, rights that encompass all the animal kingdom could include freedom of movement, freedom of natural behaviour, and freedom from pain and suffering. Currently, these basic freedoms are infringed upon by humans without a second thought. Trivial human interests, such as entertainment, are placed above fundamental animal interests, such as freedom of movement – as found in zoos and circuses. The only explanation that could be given for this is that “the animals aren’t human, so this treatment is fine.” This is clear speciesism. Speciesism is a complex and heavily debated issue, but I hope this provides you with an introduction to this oft-forgotten rights issue. In contrast to those affected by racism and sexism, non-human animals are unable to advance their own cause. Changing human perception of non-human animals must happen from the inside over time.
-
Columns
Issue 9 27/04/2014Defending the kingdom | Issue 09
Pigs have long been a human meal, being one of the first animals to be domesticated almost 13,000 years ago. Under domestication, pigs lived a similar life to what they had in the wild, bar only the fence around their enclosure. This way of farming pigs remained largely unchanged until the second half of the twentieth century. From then onwards, farms became increasingly impersonal, more intensive, and developed into what we refer to today as factory farms. It is a common misconception that the factory farm is not a New Zealand issue. We have images in our mind of rolling pastures dotted with cattle, or rugged peaks mottled with sheep. However, most pigs are not so lucky. It is the sad truth that even New Zealand sows (adult female pigs) spend a large part of their lives in stark confinement. A sow stall, also known as a gestation crate, is a metal cage measuring about 60 by 200 centimetres. Housed indoors, the concrete floor is sloped to allow waste to drain out. The confines of the cage mean that the pig is unable to turn around or lie on their side. The vast majority of the world’s sows are contained in these conditions for the duration of their pregnancy, which lasts an average of 114 days. With an average of 2.5 pregnancies in a year, sows spend most of these 285 days contained in the sow crate. While nursing their young, the sow is placed in a similar confine called a farrowing crate. Slightly larger, the pig is able to lie on their side to allow teat access to the piglets. The use of the farrowing crate is only needed as the pork industry demands production of more piglets than a sow can naturally handle. Thankfully, in December 2012, the use of sow crates in NZ was limited to the first four weeks of pregnancy. However, this is still four weeks of solitary confinement. Studies have shown that sows in these conditions exhibit repetitive behaviours such as head waving, tongue rolling and biting the bars of the crate, sometimes until their gums bleed. Sows in these conditions have also been observed to suffer from learned helplessness, in that they will remain passive when poked or splashed with a bucket of water. Proponents argue that the sow crate is necessary, as sows become aggressive during pregnancy, and can harm the swineherd or other pigs. However, the final size of the crate cannot rest upon any other factor than cost saving. There is no reason why the crates cannot be large enough to allow a pig to be comfortable. The sow crate is banned in Sweden and the UK, and, thankfully, will be phased out here next year. Already prohibited in Sweden and Switzerland, there are no plans to discontinue the use of farrowing crates in NZ. So next time you bite into your bacon buttie, have a think about what suffering has occurred before that tasty morsel. It might be better to avoid pork altogether, at least until next year – unless it is free range.