Simon Broadbent
Contributor
Articles by Simon Broadbent
2 articles found. Displaying page 1 of 1.
-
Culture
Issue 8 13/04/2014Noah
Rating: B+ Rather than a faithful and preachy account of the Bible jazzed up into a feature-length, Aronofsky attempts a blend of biopic, CGI fantasy, gritty reboot, and ecological fairy-tale which moulds the well-known story of Noah into something entirely new. Any moral preaching is reserved for environmental rather than biblical causes; a good fit for a story about a man who saves a boatload of animals, but delivered with such unapologetic bluntness that it feels ... well, preachy. Crowe is well cast in this complex and dark take on the biblical character, explored in unforgiving depth. The muffled screams of those left to die heard through the walls of the Ark is something left out of most children’s books, but it makes powerful and thought-provoking cinema, well-suited to the harsh morality of the Old Testament. Dealing largely with the emotional, moral and existential dilemmas facing Noah’s family, the film leaves many of the practical questions of the story (food and basic reproductive biology) untouched. Though possibly more sensible than trying to fill every plot hole in Genesis, this tempers the powerful angst Noah otherwise paints beautifully, and the result is a confusing sprawl that teeters between a human drama that makes no sense and a fairy tale that takes itself far too seriously. Puncturing suspense of disbelief in an entirely different manner, some of the CGI – the parade of the animals, the Lord of the Rings-style battles – isn’t quite up to standard. That said, the beautiful time-lapse shots of the creation of the universe are almost worth the ticket price alone, and the CGI destruction of the world is delivered with all the pomp Hollywood can muster. There’s a lot to enjoy, as a spectacle, and even as fuel to a good discussion about religion or environmentalism, but Noah itself never quite gels into a coherent film. All in all, it’s a miss, but a near one; genuine ambition and vision played out with big blockbuster money. That has to be worth something.
-
Culture
Issue 4 16/03/2014Non-Stop
Grade: B- Almost the first shot of Non-Stop is Neeson’s grizzled Air Marshal pouring whisky into his morning coffee, so you know you’re dealing with gritty Neeson, not Love Actually Neeson. But then he sentimentally touches the picture of his daughter taped to the roof of his car, so you know he’s got a heart. No, this isn’t Taken’s damaged but ruthless ex-CIA Bryan Mills. This is alcoholic but committed Bill Marks. Totally different guy. Actually, the body-count isn’t that high, relying on suspense rather than brutality for the majority of the film, and there’s a pretty decent “whodunnit” mystery throughout. Is it tough-looking bald guy? Blonde bunny-boiler with older man? Stereotypically Arabic guy? Surprisingly, they’re all portrayed by impressive acting – it’s actually a shame we don’t see more of them. The action stays fresh and the pace is true to the title – and that’s the main problem. These people are stuck in a metal tube with a possible murderer and/or hijacker. Where’s the claustrophobia? The wild accusations? The overwhelming feeling of helplessness? Despite being told repeatedly that there are 150 people on this plane (goddammit!), it never feels like it – just Marks’ few suspects getting in one or two lines as he charges around the plane, never quite earning your sympathy. I liked Taken because it stayed just on the right side of convincing me that, yeah, actually, if you kidnap an ex-CIA man’s daughter, he might well have a particular set of skills, and he might well use those skills to kill people in inventive ways. Non-Stop barely convinced me that they were on a plane. I can’t fault it on being a big-budget, technically serviceable thriller. The cinematography is pleasant, if pedestrian, the actors are talented enough, and the script fulfils the title’s promise exactly as you’d expect. The flight angle just feels a bit tacked-on, nothing more than a rushed third act political point and an automatic stake-raiser. Non-Stop is distracting for exactly its run-time, and then you will never think about it again.