Protestor Arrested in Campus Palestine Protest
News

Protestor Arrested in Campus Palestine Protest

The University of Otago’s stance of “institutional neutrality” on Israel’s actions in Palestine has continued to be fiercely criticised by its staff and students. Last Wednesday, October 9th, the Otago Students for Justice in Palestine (OSJP) held a peaceful campus protest that spiralled into one student being arrested for wilful damage of a Clocktower reception glass door.

The protest began at noon. A mixed crowd of around 200 students, staff, and members of the public gathered at the Otago Museum lawn. They held Palestine flags, protest signs, and Critic spotted a crochet watermelon badge or two (a symbol of Palestinian solidarity). 

“This is the most recent in a series of peaceful student actions calling on the University to publicly condemn the genocide in Palestine and to boycott and divest from Israeli corporations,” OSJP said in a statement following the protest. The group’s march-path took them from the Museum Lawn, through the Link, and ended in front of the Clocktower. They sang and chanted as they went: “We’re calling on you to take a side, it’s been one year of genocide.” 

Three of the protest organisers spoke at the Clocktower as members of Campus Watch looked on, including the Proctor Dave Scott. The first, student Namugga Nakayiza, began by saying, “I’m speaking to you with a lot of pain.” As the protest came just two days after the anniversary of October 7th, she reflected on the horror of watching from afar as an estimated 41,000 Palestinians and 1,200 Israelis have been killed.

Each of the speakers took aim at the University’s stance of “institutional neutrality” on the matter. Otago University has consistently said that “to the best of [their] knowledge” they do not have financial ties to Israel. But Namugga pointed out that the Uni’s pension fund, Unisaver, is invested in military contractors such as Elbit Systems and Palantir. This would mean students’ tuition fees are going toward companies who create the bombs Israel is dropping on innocent civilians, she said. At time of writing, the University has not responded to these allegations.

Politics lecturer Dr David Jenkins was the second speaker. Earlier that day, an opinion piece he’d co-written with MFCO lecturer Dr Olivier Jutel on behalf of Otago Staff for Palestine (OSP) had been published by the ODT titled ‘University could, should take ethical stand’. “[OSP] are a group of staff and students trying to convince the University of Otago to take a stand against Israel’s actions in Gaza and the Occupied Territories, actions which the International Court of Justice and many human rights experts argue plausibly amount to genocide.”

Jenkins in his speech referenced the arguments made in the article against the University’s neutrality. While OSP acknowledges that “institutional neutrality is certainly an important principle” it was “never meant to serve as an ultimate trump card against all political stances” – an especially salient point in light of the Uni’s support of hospital marches, transition away from fossil fuels, and concerted effort to becoming a Te Tiriti-led institution this year, signified by the rebranded ikoa Māori and tohu in collaboration with mana whenua.

The third speaker was OSJP member Neave Ashton. They spoke of how students at other college campuses in protests “played a pivotal role shining a light on institutional complicity and pressuring their universities to endorse [the BDS movement] [...] We’re here following their example.” 

Neave also came for Otago’s stubbornly neutral stance, yelling, “In taking no stance, this university de facto endorses the continuation of the genocide. This should forfeit their claimed role of the conscience and critic of society. If you can’t take a stand against genocide, what the fuck can you take a stand for?” Their words were met with applause and shouts of “shame!” from the crowd.

Neave wrapped up their speech by calling on protestors to stage a sit-in inside the Clocktower on the stairs. OSJP said this was “a move carefully planned by OSJP harkening back to current Vice-Chancellor Grant Robertson’s very own clocktower [sic] occupation in his university days.” As a group broke off from the crowd to rush inside, Neave warned that doing so would be at their own risk as they “might be trespassed.” 

“The energy changed quickly when students were met with violence,” claimed OSJP. “Campus Watch and Proctor Dave Scott forcefully held the protestors back at the door, shouting and pushing them back through the entrance. A Campus Watch officer grappled a student who had made it past the front doors and was standing in the entranceway. In an attempt to wrestle her backwards, he collided with an interior glass door which shattered.”

“I was appalled to see Campus Watch put guarding the Clocktower above the safety of our students. We are a peaceful group, and that was a totally excessive response,” said an OSJP spokesperson. Following the incident, the student sought medical attention and was arrested for wilful damage by Police who’d shown up on the scene shortly after. “One person has been arrested in relation to the incident and charges will be considered,” Police told Critic. 

VC Grant commented following the events, “Peaceful protest has been a long tradition at the University of Otago – Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka. It is important that students and staff are able to express their views and protest within the law. However, there is no place for vandalism or disorderly actions, particularly when the safety of others including staff and students is put at risk. This protest crossed that line. This is against the kaupapa of our community and is not welcome.” 

The statement, rather than coming from the heart, is worded almost exactly the same as former Acting Vice-Chancellor Prof Tony Ballantyne’s after another student protest that vandalised walls in the Business School just last year. Uni staff member Brandon Johnstone criticised Grant’s “lack of genuine engagement” with the “stock response”.

OSJP intends to continue to call on the University to endorse the BDS movement for a free Palestine, stating, “It is important to remember why we are here: tens of thousands of people are being slaughtered in Palestine and our university has done nothing.”


Warning: Undefined variable $more in /container/application/public/article.php on line 194

Fatal error: Uncaught TypeError: mysqli_num_rows(): Argument #1 ($result) must be of type mysqli_result, null given in /container/application/public/admin/config.php:132 Stack trace: #0 /container/application/public/admin/config.php(132): mysqli_num_rows(NULL) #1 /container/application/public/article.php(194): mnr(NULL) #2 /container/application/public/index.php(30): include('/container/appl...') #3 {main} thrown in /container/application/public/admin/config.php on line 132