Press Council ruling against Critic
News

Press Council ruling against Critic

By

The Press Council has part-upheld a complaint from Dunedin City Council against two Critic articles. This is a summary of the Press Council ruling.  See here for the full decision www.presscouncil.org.nz

Critic’s article headlined DCC accused of ‘active and willful campaign to discourage student voters’ centered on negotiations between the Council and the Otago University Students’ Association over the provision of a special voting booth on the campus for the upcoming local government elections.

 

The story, which relied heavily on unnamed sources, said the Association pulled out of the arrangement because of demands from Council officials, which included the location of the booth and the need to have it supervised. The story also said that a request for a bulk supply of enrolment forms was denied and only provided on a piecemeal basis.

 

The Press Council noted that Dunedin City Council representatives (specifically the Electoral Officer) should have been contacted for comment. The brief email exchange between the reporter and the Officer was not enough and Critic had an obligation to put all the relevant claims and comments, across both stories, to the Council for balance. A fair voice must be given to the opposition view.

 

Unnamed sources should be used only in cases where there is no alternative to telling a story that is in the public interest, the Press Council said.

 

Also, Critic was wrong to suggest DCC or its Electoral Officer had refused the bulk request for enrolment forms, as the provision of enrolment forms is a matter for the Registrar of Electors. The editor had agreed this was wrong, however this error was not publicly corrected.

 

The second Critic story Emails reveal DCC deception over 2013 voting booth decision, was based on a series of emails - sought in May 2016 under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act – that had been sent/received ahead of the 2013 election.

 

The Press Council did not agree with DCC that Critic’s statement that it had ‘acquired’ emails suggests they were obtained via clandestine means.

 

With regards to the headline the Press Council noted the headline matched the story and did not effectively label the Electoral Officer a liar, as the DCC contended.

 

The Press Council also noted that while it was not useful for the editor to argue Critic’s complete independence from the Association, when by the publication’s own admission it is the ‘student magazine of the Otago University Students’ Association’, it cannot be said that an editorial arm of a media organisation cannot operate independently of its owner.

 

These parts of the complaint were not upheld.

 

Warning: Undefined variable $more in /container/application/public/article.php on line 194

Fatal error: Uncaught TypeError: mysqli_num_rows(): Argument #1 ($result) must be of type mysqli_result, null given in /container/application/public/admin/config.php:132 Stack trace: #0 /container/application/public/admin/config.php(132): mysqli_num_rows(NULL) #1 /container/application/public/article.php(194): mnr(NULL) #2 /container/application/public/index.php(30): include('/container/appl...') #3 {main} thrown in /container/application/public/admin/config.php on line 132