The OUSA Executive yesterday confronted a breach of the OUSA Constitution by three of the four delegates sent to Wellington to cast OUSA’s votes in the 2014 NZUSA (New Zealand Union of Students’ Associations) election. The offending delegates voted contrary to a motion carried during Monday 4 November’s Executive Meeting, notably moved by Jordan Taylor, “that the Executive direct the delegates attending the NZUSA Conference to vote for Francisco Hernandez in the NZUSA Presidential elections on 10 November.”
The delegates attending the conference were OUSA Welfare Officer and President-Elect Ruby Sycamore-Smith, Finance Officer Nick Tenci, Education Officer Jordan Taylor, and Womens Representative Sam Allen.
Although Hernandez obtained a majority of votes in the first round of voting, he required a larger 2/3 majority to be elected President of NZUSA. It came to his attention that all delegates except for Sycamore-Smith had each switched one of OUSA’s votes from Hernandez to another candidate in the second round of voting, when his position suddenly dropped to third and final place.
OUSA is given four votes in NZUSA elections, with votes given to associations in proportion to their respective university’s student enrolments. These votes are explicitly not then given to “delegates” in the sense that they are empowered with the authority to make decisions on OUSA’s behalf. Rather, the use of delegates is more like a highly inefficient alternative to the OUSA Executive casting its votes by carrier pigeon. This is in accordance with section 7.6 of the OUSA Constitution, which states “All Resolutions of the Executive and all acts done will be binding upon all the members of the Executive whether present at any such meeting or not.”
The OUSA Constitution is a legally binding document, and thus the offending Executive members were allegedly breaking the law. This is also the first time in recent history, if not ever, that OUSA’s Constitution has been broken in such a way. As such, sanctions passed down by the Executive were setting a significant precedent.
The incident was initially discussed at an OUSA Executive meeting held on Monday 18 November. However, Taylor was absent from the meeting and as such only the sanctions placed on Tenci for his involvement were decided.
Sadly, Critic is unable to report the vast merry-go-round of discussion and debate that followed, as the meeting was put into Committee of the Whole (during which all discussions are strictly confidential) for reasons of personal privacy for exactly an hour and nine minutes.
What Critic can report, however, is that the Executive acknowledged and accepted Tenci’s apology and explanation, and considered a vote of no confidence in the Executive members involved as a consequence. This idea was dismissed, however, “owing to technical issues.”
The sanctions finally placed on Tenci were to censure him; to forbid him “from any external representation on behalf of OUSA until after 31 December 2013;” and to reduce his honorarium (pay) by half as from 10 November (when the offense occurred) until 31 December 2013.
Tenci was notably absent from the Executive meeting of 4 November during which the motion in question was passed. He is also relatively new to the Executive, having won a by-election for the Finance Officer position late this year.
In contrast, Jordan Taylor, who was the Executive member that moved the breached motion, was recently re-elected by the student body to his third term in the position of Education Officer for 2014. This experience, paired with documented support and understanding of the motion in contention, would indicate in layman’s terms that Taylor should have known better.
Critic was thus expecting a stronger precedent to be set in yesterday’s Executive meeting, held to decide what sanctions would be placed on Taylor.
The meeting was again put into Committee of the Whole, with the resulting sanctions placed on Taylor simply altered versions of those placed on Tenci. Taylor is now forbidden only from “new” external representation on behalf of OUSA for the remainder of the year, and has an increased honorarium cut of 80 per cent.
Sycamore-Smith abstained from voting in both motions of sanction. Notable also was that Administrative Vice President Zac Gawn switched from voting against the sanctions placed on Tenci to voting for the sanctions placed on Taylor.
Critic can also report that once Wednesday’s meeting moved out of Committee of the Whole, it was agreed by the Executive that OUSA would “review its policies on transparency.”
The final delegate understood to have breached the motion to vote for Hernandez was OUSA Women’s Representative Sam Allen. Allen is not an Executive member, however, she had travelled to Wellington to successfully stand for the position of NZUSA Women’s Rights Officer.
It was stated in Monday’s meeting, “The Executive also expressed strongly their disapproval of Sam Allen’s involvement in the voting process considering she isn’t an elected Executive member on OUSA. The Executive request a conference call or Skype be had with Sam to explain her part in this decision.”
Following Wednesday’s Executive meeting, Hernandez instructed the members in question not to speak with Critic about the incident. He told Critic that this was because he had prior discussions with them and felt he could articulate their responses himself.
“Both individuals moved the motions of sanctions against themselves, which shows they think the sanctions are fair,” he told Critic.
Hernandez hesitated to agree that he saw these as “honest mistakes,” however, he did say that he saw it “more as a cock-up than as a conspiracy.
“I think people are allowed to make mistakes. These mistakes happen all the time in politics, but when people make mistakes that have serious consequences, then those who have made the mistakes should also face serious consequences.
“I think the Executive pursued a restorative justice approach, that both restored the mana of the person affected and took steps to heavily sanction the people who performed them and ensure it doesn’t happen again. We’ve all learned lessons from this.”
Hernandez also pointed out that at this point in the year, the sanctions that the Executive could pursue were “heavily limited because there’s only a few months left in the year.”
However, he thinks that “it does establish a fair precedent, it’s just that the impact of it is muted because it’s the end of the year.
“If it had happened in, say, May, the sanctions may have been for the rest of the year. Losing part of your pay check for half of the year that you’re working is worse than losing it for just a couple of months.”
Hernandez also agreed “there is potential” that this incident would have had to go to the student body if it had occurred earlier in the year.
In fact, the OUSA Constitution states that the Executive must instruct the Association Secretary to call an SGM (Student General Meeting) to notify the student body of any breach of the Constitution. This is likely to occur early next year, as an SGM must be held during term time.
What remains to be seen is whether this perceived setback will continue to reflect a lack of Hernandez support to other students’ associations when voting occurs again on 11 December, as a 2/3 majority was still not reached after three rounds of voting. Hernandez thinks it “undoubtedly” will.
“It’s like I’m a stock market crash.”
Critic also drew attention to whether president-elect Ruby Sycamore-Smith can feel confident in having support from her Executive next year, with the two offending Executive members re-elected to their respective positions in the most recent OUSA elections. However, Hernandez thinks the incident will instead give her leverage through “guilt-tripping them” next year.
“I think Ruby should have cracked the whip a little bit more, but I’m really grateful for her loyalty. Her parents should have named her ‘Diamond,’ because she came under extreme pressure that weekend and came out more beautiful. Actually, that sounds like a pickup line so maybe don’t print that.
“I’m very disappointed with what’s happened. And I expected them to know better. I set my expectations pretty clear, and they chose not to listen.
“I’ve learned a lesson in politics from this: don’t trust anyone. They’ll either fuck up or they’ll be disloyal, and either is as damaging.”
More News from Issue 26
-
Tall, White Male Selected as 2014 Critic Editor in Shocking Upset
It’s third time lucky for Critic’s resident ladder-climber Zane Pocock, who has been named Critic editor for 2014. “Fuck that took a while,” Pocock sighed when told the news. He has since been spotted standing at the OUSA balcony for hours on end, staring longingly and with just a hint of pride over the students he expects to mislead next year. Pocock started his epic and brutal quest to reach the top as a film reviewer in first year. However, he has now admitted that “there were a few shaky rungs that I discovered as I tried to increase the pace too much. “Pulling one out from under this year’s first Editor was certainly a risky move. If he fell the wrong way it could have wiped me out, too.” Fears have been raised that, at 21, Pocock is far too young for a job where the last three managers have been ageing man-children. It is understood that his desire to prove himself at the top of Critic’s ranks comes out of a tortured self-consciousness that, in his youthfulness, he can’t grow proper facial hair, a claim Pocock fervently denies. “Sometimes I need to shave!” he retorted. Still on his learner’s, Pocock even has a mullet in his drivers’ licence photo. Which says it all, really. Pocock is also understood to be an ardent left-wing liberal, with his Facebook friend list having halved following his rants about the 2011 election outcome. This has concerned many who foolishly see Critic as holding a lot of influence over how students will vote in an election year. However, because these political beliefs are in the public sphere, Pocock believes his selection has given him a mandate to pretend the right wing doesn’t exist. “It’s just quid pro quo, really. If John Key thinks he has a mandate to sell our assets, then I have a mandate to … wait, who are we talking about?” With a high level of interest in contemporary art, Pocock is also promising that most content next year will be wanky, convoluted and confusing. “But it will look really interesting,” he assures us.
-
Too Much Pussy in North Dunedin
Pussy swapping is the next big thing to hit North Dunedin. An initiative is underway to deal with the rising number of stray cats in the student quarters. SPCA Executive Officer Sophie McSkimming said the Society “hopes to have a Facebook page for Cat Swapping by the end of the week.” Students will be able to post a picture of their cat on the page in the hopes of permanently rehoming it or finding someone who wants to take care of it temporarily over the summer. After receiving a number of complaints about the increasing cat population, DCC Councillor Kate Wilson began working with OUSA and the SPCA to take action. “The University area was acknowledged as an area with a large population change at the year’s end that sometimes resulted in cats being deserted,” Wilson said. With students accumulating feline flatmates over the University year, there are surplus cats that are not taken out of North Dunedin for the holidays, causing an increase in the population of pussies in Dunedin. Wilson believed that the problem lay in “stray cats being ‘adopted’ by students, fed, and being healthy enough to breed, [resulting in] numbers growing.” The SPCA is currently inundated with cats, and is well over their capacity. The Cat Swapping initiative aims to reduce the number of cats in North Dunedin by encouraging flats that wish to adopt a cat to find one on the cat swap site rather than acquiring a new one. Another initiative has also been put in place to get a de-sexing bus up and running in Dunedin in the hope of preventing cats from breeding like rabbits. The SPCA is funding the bus, which aims to de-sex 300 cats and 50 dogs for free over a period of three weeks in December. Female cats at the SPCA will also be adopted for $65, half the usual price, from 4-10 October. Free pamper packs have been donated by local businesses for the SPCA to give to adopters. Wilson stated that she “[doesn’t] encourage or discourage students having cats … I encourage students to be responsible, spay their cats, keep rubbish covered and stored well to reduce scavenging of strays. And if you find cats and want to deal with them consider seeking advice from the SPCA.” McSkimming noted that the SPCA does not currently adopt out to anybody living in North Dunedin.
-
Interview: Francisco Hernandez
OUSA President Francisco Hernandez will soon leave the association after three years on the Executive. In that time he has revolutionised student politics, producing groundbreaking campaign videos (“Frangnam Style”), conducting “ironically terrible” interviews on national television (TV3’s Firstline), and pioneering sharp new fashion trends (trousers tucked into socks). Critic editor Sam McChesney caught up with Fran for one last, emotional interview. Beforehand, Fran promised that he would “stock up on tissues. For the tears that is.” Sam: So, the end of an era. Fran: It’s not the end of an era. I think you can just see me as a continuation of the Logan Edgar era, because I was a Scarfie like him. Umm … No, I’m kidding. I’m quite different from Logan. In what way? In every way. I’m the complete fucking opposite. He’s white, I’m brown. He was a Scarfie, I’m a nerd. So you’re about to start your lame-duck period. Any big plans? Just quacking pointlessly in my office. If I get elected to the DCC I’m planning to cut my term short; there’s no point stuffing around here when I’ve got a new president potentially ready to take over. So I will go early if I get elected to the DCC, probably a month early. What would you say is your greatest achievement as president? That’s like asking me who my favourite son is. You don’t have any sons. Are you saying you have no achievements? It’s a metaphor. My children are the taonga that I pass on to the next generation. You know? I think my biggest achievement was probably … I don’t know, what would you say my biggest achievement is? Probably succession planning, leaving a strong field of presidential candidates behind. Yeah, grooming the next generation of leadership. That was all planned. I dunno, I think my biggest achievement was probably the Memorandum of Understanding with the Dunedin City Council. That’s the first such agreement between a students’ association and a local body. There isn’t anything like that anywhere else in the world, and I was the first to get it done. Second biggest achievement is probably the tertiary student bus discount. People have been trying to do that for ages; I’m the one who got it done. Cheap food on campus, people have been whining about it for ages. Mine was the Exec that got it done. I think overall my Exec has been quite progressive and visionary about getting stuff done, whereas other people just piss and moan and complain about it. What was your biggest fuck-up this year? Probably the governance review. I fucking hated that. Governance reviews are like the graveyard of student politicians. … They’re useful, and they tell you some important things, but the process of actually doing is extremely painful. It’s like getting circumcised without anaesthesia, and I’ve done that, so I know. I actually have, and it’s a similar sort of … you can’t see what’s going on, you know it’s painful, and you’re supposed to have drugs to keep you sedated but it’s not working properly. This is making me really uncomfortable, so let’s move on to the next question. How many OUSA sex scandals have there been under your watch? None. I haven’t had sex while I’ve been President. I can’t think of anyone who’s had sex this year. With each other, that is. On the Executive. Who is the most interesting person to insult you this year and what did they say about you? There was that guy who called me “Hitler” Hernandez earlier in the year because he couldn’t buy a ticket to Netsky. Okay, officially not allowing people to buy tickets to a popular Belgian act is like committing genocide against six million Jews. OUSA election stock has been hitting the top of iPredict’s most-traded list. How would you rank this in the canon of great OUSA moments? It’s probably the best thing that’s ever happened – after all the things that I’ve done. It’s given us profile all over the country, and it’s given us the chance to engage in rampant insider speculation. Why do you think I do all those Facebook posts, Sam? Because I’m bored? No, it’s because I have stocks on iPredict. Every time I do one of those posts the market moves in the direction I want it to move. I don’t just do it because I’m bored, I do it because I’m getting money out of it. Who do you think asked iPredict to put those stocks there? Why do you think that person asked for those stocks to be placed there? This is all on the record. I’m taking the piss, by the way. That’s also on the record, so you have to print that. Interviews can be abridged. How long do you think it will be until you end up on the back bench of a Labour opposition? Well, I think you have to consider the fact that I’m focused on serving my constituents. I don’t have any other plans other than to be a good councillor if I do get elected, or be a good NZUSA president if I get that job, or be a good priest I become a priest. I’m not the sort of person who, like, goes along with a plan, you know, just wanting to be a backbench MP. It’s not like that; I just want to serve the people. I’m not just using the positions I’ve gained as some sort of ladder to advance myself. That would be wrong. But by 2020 would be my guess, if I were that sort of person. Which I’m not. Shoot, shag, or marry – Logan Edgar, Zac Gawn, Ryan Edgar? I’d probably shag Ryan. I’d shoot Zac. I’d marry Logan, because Logan and I have a constructive partnership. I’m most familiar with him and I understand him the most as a person. Ryan is probably the most attractive out of all of them. I’m not gay, but objectively speaking, he is the most attractive out of the three of them. And I’d shoot Zac because I have iPredict stock and I’m betting against him, so if he dies that stock gets voided and Ruby gets elected. It’s nothing personal, it’s just money.
-
Fran Makes $300 on iPredict
Ruby Sycamore-Smith has won the election for OUSA President in 2014 with 49.86 per cent of the vote. Her closest rival, Zac Gawn, won 34.35 per cent, with Jordan Watts a distant third on 10.42 per cent. The election saw OUSA’s largest voter turnout “in a generation.” 5,193 votes were cast, representing 25 per cent of OUSA members. Other winners included Ryan Edgar in the Administrative Vice-President position, Jordan Taylor as Education Officer, Nali Lee as Welfare Officer, Hamish Barker as Campaigns Officer, and Henri Faulkner as Recreation Officer. Nick Tenci, Kurt Purdon, Kamil Saifuddin and Brydie Ockwell won their respective positions of Finance Officer, Postgraduate Officer, International Officer, and Colleges Officer unopposed. The 2014 President of Te Roopu Maori, who sits on the OUSA Executive, will be Mariana Te Pou. Sycamore-Smith succumbed to a bout of tears when her victory was confirmed, but perhaps emotions clouded her short-term memory when Critic enquired who she was most looking forward to working with in 2014. Erroneously believing that Campaigns Officer hopeful Jarred Griffiths had won his race, Sycamore-Smith said that she and Jarred “worked very closely on the campaign together, so I’m excited to work with him.” Sycamore-Smith proved less enthusiastic about her campaign video, a reworking of Miley Cyrus’ “Wrecking Ball.” “I got more dislikes than likes, which is pretty cheeky … but I think it was good in the sense that I really put myself out there and showed everyone how much I really wanted to be the president of OUSA. Getting my face out of there is pretty important.” Outgoing President Francisco Hernandez was expecting to make about $300 from the Sycamore-Smith iPredict stocks he owned, having “put a lot of eggs in this basket.” With Gawn losing by such a significant margin, Hernandez felt that “we did see the limitations of the Scarfie vote. You can’t run on a double Scarfie ticket and expect to win anymore. You need a little bit more diversity on your ticket.” Ryan Edgar, elected Administrative Vice-President by a 21.13 per cent margin over his closest rival Paul Hunt, was on Gawn’s Scarfie ticket, along with Barker, who won by a tiny 0.55 per cent margin over Griffiths. Edgar certainly had mixed feelings over Sycamore-Smith’s win, initially only admitting, “I’m looking forward to working with Ruby. I’m looking forward to liking her again.” However, as the first celebratory drink started to process, he let out his true feelings. “I’ve always really liked Ruby … I really like her … Ruby is great … I know she’ll do a really good job.” We get it, Ryan. There might be future inter-OUSA relations. 2014 Welfare Officer Nali Lee was “already pissed” when Critic spoke to her. She felt that her campaign video, which featured her deep-throating a condom-clad banana, won her the election. She literally squealed at the thought of holding her position, and launched into an epic monologue when asked how she expected to celebrate. “Dude, I’m fucking already pissed man! Dude. Can you not see my face? I’ve got the Asian blush on! Well, it is quarter to four right now [it was actually quarter to five], I’m going to keep drinking, I’m going to pass out at 4:30 [she had already missed her scheduled pass-out time], I’m going to wake myself up at 7:30 and I’m going to the OCOM ball to drink the $4 cocktails.” The 2014 Executive will receive training from the current executive before taking control of the 124-year-old organisation from 1 January 2014. Results:
-
Sycamore-Smith Coasts to Victory Despite Video Gaffe | Opinion
With the Zac Gawn ticket victorious in two out of three contested positions, the outcome of the OUSA Presidential election can largely be seen as a personal endorsement of Ruby Sycamore-Smith. The election also saw the rise of iPredict and the resurgence of feminism, and cemented the importance of campaign videos. In a largely clean and well-fought race, the broad consensus throughout had Sycamore-Smith as favourite, with momentum swinging back towards Gawn in the last few days. In reality, though, nobody had any idea who would win, and the only certainty was that Jordan Watts – an outsider who ran a largely muted campaign and did not even show up to the results announcement – would finish third. On the whole, Gawn ran a much better campaign than Sycamore-Smith. He stayed on message and, despite taking several knocks over the course of the campaign, he remained restrained and mature in dealing with his critics. The main blemish was a disastrous candidates’ debate in which he was steamrollered by Sycamore-Smith. Sycamore-Smith campaigned hard on the ground, but unlike Gawn, she never really had to prove herself. She entered the race with Critic’s endorsement, the support of most OUSA insiders, and strong backing from female voters. Indeed, Sycamore-Smith’s campaign, which relied heavily on support from campus feminists, saw feminism exert more influence on OUSA elections than at any other time since the 90s. “I’m just thrilled to be a demographic seen as worth pandering to,” Golda Matthias commented after yet another Facebook post by the Sycamore-Smith ticket was thrust upon the Dunedin Feminist Discussion Group. Even so, Sycamore-Smith’s attempt to position herself as the grownup in the room and the thinking Scarfie’s President almost backfired spectacularly, after she released a campaign video that riffed on Miley Cyrus’ “Wrecking Ball.” The video, in which Sycamore-Smith lip-synched sloppily to some off-key singing, writhed around in lollipops, removed items of clothing, and made a laughable attempt to imbibe directly from a goon, was described by viewers as “one of the most cringeworthy things I have ever seen,” not to mention “about three minutes too long.” Whereas Sycamore-Smith’s video came across as desperate, Gawn’s – featuring Logan Edgar, gratuitous male nudity, and Gawn skulling two bottles of wine – was effortlessly Scarfie. Meanwhile, Nali Lee won the Welfare Officer position after releasing a ten-second clip in which she deep-throated a banana. Politics. The election also saw rampant insider trading as election stock were, for the first time, traded on iPredict; at various times in the race, Sycamore-Smith and Gawn’s stock even reached the top of the site’s “most-traded” list. Most of the trading came from OUSA insiders, with Hernandez for one winning $300 after placing large bets on Sycamore-Smith. Returning Officer Tom Harries reported few issues. Sycamore-Smith was ordered to remove a photo from Facebook that breached election rules, and Gawn was investigated after promising beer to students who shared his campaign photo. Both candidates were also warned about their conduct during lectures, with several lecturers complaining of lengthy disruptions by candidates distributing flyers and speechifying. Fran was unable to restrain himself, and published a series of ridiculously long “analyses” of the candidates during the elections. The analyses were heavily biased in favour of Fran’s close friend and 2012 campaign partner Jordan Taylor (Education Officer) and against frequent critic Dan Stride (Recreation Officer), and were accompanied by a somewhat disingenuous disclaimer to the effect that Fran did not, in fact, endorse any of the candidates. Stride complained to Harries about the posts, but Harries held that under a rule change last year, members of the Executive were allowed to endorse candidates.
-
Otago’s Already Shit Ranking Artificially Propped Up by Foreigners
The Times Higher Education World University Rankings have placed the University of Otago 226-250th worldwide, the same ranking as 2012 but below the 2011 ranking of 201-250th. Auckland University placed 164th which, despite being down three places on 2012, still made it the mostly highly ranked university in New Zealand. Victoria University of Wellington also slipped down the ranks, dropping down a bracket from 251-275 to 276-300. The University of Canterbury and the University of Waikato were both placed 301-350th. Otago University is now ranked tenth in the Oceania region. Otago placed 91st for clinical, pre-clinical and health subjects, while Auckland placed 72nd in the same area. Victoria and Auckland also gained positions in the top 100 for Arts and Humanities. Professor Vernon Squire, University of Otago Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), had little to say about Otago’s shit performance. “It is pleasing that Otago has maintained its place in the 226-250 band,” he told Critic. That was all. Using different methodology, the QS World University rankings for 2013 placed Otago at 155th worldwide. Phil Baty, rankings editor of Times Higher Education, said that “institutions ranked outside of the top 200 are not given an exact position, as differences in performance at the lower end of the tables are slight.” Times Higher Education employs 13 separate performance indicators, making them the “only global university performance tables to judge research-led universities across all the core missions of the modern global university – research, teaching, knowledge transfer and international activity.” The multitude of performance indicators “provides the most comprehensive and balanced comparisons, which are trusted by students, academics, university leaders, industry and governments.” Universities are excluded from the rankings if they do not teach undergraduates, if they teach only a single narrow subject, or if their research output amounted to fewer than 1,000 articles between 2006 and 2010 (or 200 a year). The performance indicators are grouped into five areas, each contributing to an overall ranking score: - Teaching (30 per cent): This area assesses the learning environment of the institution, and is based on an analysis of the staff-to-student ratio, the number of PhD and undergraduate degrees awarded, the caliber of the academic staff and the results of a reputation survey. - Research (30 per cent): This analyses the volume and reputation of research published by the institution, and the income received from that research. - Citation impact (30 per cent): This measures the normalised average citations per paper. 50 million citations from 12,000 carefully selected academic journals and 6 million papers are analysed over a six year window (2007-2012). - International outlook (7.5 per cent): Ratios are calculated for the number of international students and staff in comparison to total staff and students, as well as the number of scholarly papers involving international co-authors. Otago received 84.8 per cent in this area. - Industry income (2.5 per cent): A measurement of knowledge transfer and innovation. Otago had low ratings in teaching and research (volume, income and reputation), but scored exceptionally well in one of the least important areas – international outlook. On a slightly more positive note, the high citations score means that the research we do produce is circulating well. For the third year in a row, California Institute of Technology came in first overall, with Harvard and Oxford Universities placing joint second.
-
Critic “Borrows” Story From Salient. Thanks, Suckers.
Concerns from key groups were ignored as the Government introduced their border arrest scheme for student loan defaulters earlier this year, the details of which remain unknown. Documents obtained by Salient under the Official Information Act show that there was limited consultation with stakeholders before the policy was announced, that Police concerns were not addressed, and that the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) did not believe such a measure was necessary. In addition, a submission from the Legislation Advisory Committee for greater transparency was ignored in favour of secrecy over exactly who would be subject to arrest under the policy. Border arrests were announced as part of the 2013 Budget in an effort to improve repayments from overseas-based borrowers and “[increase] personal responsibility for debt repayment.” Under the policy, borrowers in “serious default” who returned to New Zealand would not be able to leave the country unless they organised repayments. Failure to do so would result in an arrest warrant being released. The scheme would affect “a small number” of borrowers, though it is unclear exactly how many this is as the IRD have not made public the criteria for “serious default.” There are 101,095 overseas-based based borrowers, who form the majority of all borrowers with overdue repayments. The Regulatory Impact Statement (RIS) of 22 March – three months before the announcement – states that the border arrest policy “will have a significant impact on those affected,” could be challenged under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act (1990) for impeding freedom of movement, and “may discourage overseas-based borrowers from returning to New Zealand.” The IRD also add that “if passport restrictions were to be introduced … this measure might be sufficient,” and border arrests would not be necessary. Despite these concerns with the policy, consultation with stakeholders has not taken place. “Limited time was available for consultation. We did not consult with sector groups due to the budget-sensitive nature of the proposals,” the RIS reads. The Police raised a number of concerns, citing negative “operational and reputational impacts” on Police. They suggested that border arrests would make Police look like IRD debt collection agents, and added that border arrests would be too difficult given the nature of airports. Police would have to find the defaulter in busy departure lounges, often with no photo ID supplied, a task that raised further concerns relating to delaying planes and creating undue extra costs on airlines. “Police note that no cost benefit analysis, including the impact on their parties such as airports, has been concluded,” the statement read, adding that the Police already have 37,000 outstanding arrest warrants and therefore that student loan arrest warrants would not merit a high priority. The IRD have refused to release the exact threshold for “serious default,” and therefore it remains unclear exactly who will be able to be arrested under the policy. A Policy Report from 26 July reveals IRD fears that borrowers may repay to just below the threshold for arrest, or that people who know they are not going to be arrested will not contact the IRD to arrange repayments. “To publicise specific criteria would undermine the effectiveness of the border sanctions policy by … enabling borrowers to circumvent the criteria [and] weakening the deterrent effect of the policy,” states the report, released two months after the border arrest policy was announced. This secrecy persists despite the concerns of the Legislation Advisory Committee (LAC), who requested “more detailed criteria … to provide more certain limits as to who may be caught by the definition” in their submission on the Student Loan Scheme Amendment Bill (No 2). The LAC hold that the current ambiguity does not provide sufficient guidance to Government departments about when it would be acceptable to share personal information about borrowers. The Policy Advice Division of IRD and the Treasury declined the LAC’s request that further information be released. Under the legislation, failing to respond to the IRD, providing incorrect details to the IRD or continuing to default after contact has been made by the IRD will be grounds for arrest. To get an arrest warrant, intent to not repay debt must be proven. Documents relating to the border arrest scheme suggest that the definition of intent has been broadened from other similar legislation, like the Child Support Act, to make arrest warrants easier to obtain. The exact cost of the border arrest policy is unclear. It is estimated to cost $600,000 to implement, but this figure excludes the extra costs imposed on Courts and Police, who are responsible for managing the arrest warrants. The expected value of the border arrests policy was listed as “unavailable” in a document circulated just months before the budget.
-
NZUSA Given Yet Another Reprieve
The New Zealand Union of Students’ Associations’ (NZUSA) future is secure, after both OUSA and the Victoria University of Wellington Students’ Association (VUWSA) decided to remain members of the ailing national body. The two organisations, which each pay an annual NZUSA membership levy of $45,000, continued their membership on the condition that NZUSA implement significant reforms. NZUSA has come under fire this year due to a perceived lack of political campaigning. OUSA President Francisco Hernandez, VUWSA President Rory McCourt, and Auckland University Students’ Association (AUSA) President Daniel Haines collectively issued a statement to NZUSA on 22 August, threatening withdrawal if reforms were not passed. The referenda at OUSA and VUWSA were effectively a vote on the body’s continued existence, with the two associations responsible for around a third of NZUSA’s overall funding. OUSA’s motion to remain part of the organisation passed overwhelmingly, with 86.39 per cent supporting continued membership. VUWSA’s margin of support was less extreme, with 62.72 per cent in favour of continued membership. OUSA’s referendum was fraught with procedural difficulties, and the question was altered shortly before it was put to the student body. The initial wording of the question was rejected by OUSA’s honorary solicitor on the grounds that it precluded a simple “yes” or “no” answer. When this composition was rejected, OUSA President Francisco Hernandez hastily assembled the question that was included the referendum (despite being submitted after the set deadline): “Should the Otago University Students’ Association (OUSA) continue its membership of the New Zealand Union of Students’ Associations (NZUSA) if it implements reforms that enhance its campaigning capacity?” In addition to the inherent bias toward “yes” answers in referenda, the question itself was criticised as leading, with one observer describing it as “a fucking joke.” Hernandez is known to favour continued membership, and originally intended to formulate the question along the lines of “should OUSA remain in NZUSA in order to play a leadership role in reforming the organisation to be a strong national voice for students?” NZUSA’s continued existence would suit Hernandez well – he plans to run for NZUSA President in 2014 if he fails in his current bid for a seat on the Dunedin City Council. Visibly gleeful after the referendum results were released, Hernandez was quick to blow his own trumpet. “It’s a ringing mandate for continuing to stay in NZUSA,” he said. “I’m not surprised at all. I think the reforms I have proposed were endorsed by the student population by a ringing margin and I look forward to working with NZUSA.” Hernandez earlier voiced support for the endangered organisation. Citing a number of difficulties facing New Zealand students, he made it clear that he believed in NZUSA’s ability to respond to them satisfactorily, despite the total lack of evidence for such a view. “Now is not the time to abandon a national student voice at a time when many students are hurting due to government allowance restrictions, increases in the cost of living, and suffering in cold damp flats,” he said. NZUSA President Pete Hodkinson has not met with Tertiary Education Minister Steven Joyce in over 18 months.
-
Fran and Ruby in Most Pre-Determined Election Ever
Hot on the heels of the usual fanfare created by the OUSA election comes the University Council elections, giving students one more chance to select who will represent them in the ever-exciting realm of student politics. The University Council is the governing body of the University and, among other things, determines policies as well as prepares and adopts a charter for the University. There are two seats available, and two candidates running for election. Critic wonders who will get in … Francisco HernandezKia Ora I’m Francisco Hernandez, OUSA President 2013 and current University of Otago Council member. I’m standing for re-election for the Uni Council and would appreciate your vote. During my term on the University Council, I’ve gotten a lot of stuff done. I’m a proven leader with a track record of change, including drafting housing warrant-of-fitness legislation, securing improvements to Dunedin’s bus service – such as the trial tertiary student discount – and leading the campaign to stop the North Dunedin Liquor Ban in favour of constructive alternatives. I’ve fought hard for you on the Otago University Council this year. I will keep fighting for you. If elected, I’ll use my experience to guide the new OUSA President so that she can get the stuff she wants done. I will also continue my work on upgrading Dunedin’s housing stock, enhancing campus sustainability, improving the Satellite campus experience, strengthening ties between the city/university/polytechnic, and lobbying for improvements in Dunedin’s public transport through better buses and safer cycleways. I know times are tough for students, so I’ll keep working to restrain fee rises. Vote Francisco Hernandez to get strong representation, fresh vision and proven leadership on the University of Otago Council. Ruby Sycamore-SmithKia Ora, I’m Ruby, and I am running for the University of Otago Council. First and foremost I would like to point out that I am passionate about everything I do – I sink my teeth into every situation and always give 110 per cent. I’m a third-year student studying communications and marketing, and I’m going to ensure that you get the year that you deserve! I will be an excellent student representative on the Council and make sure that the student voice is heard! I will make sure that all students will get the most out of their time at Otago. As your current Welfare Officer I’ve: - Delivered free breakfasts and five dollar meals. - Secured $10,000 in funding from the Ministry of Social Development to promote healthy relationships. - Successfully advocated for making the Queer Support Position full time. - Led OUSA’s stress-free exam efforts including establishing a puppy room! - Led negotiations with the University over establishing a student pub on campus. My record as your Welfare Officer has been impressive, and with me on University Council you can expect more. Expect more. Vote Ruby for University Council.
-
Cool Research Bro. Here, Have 800k
Minister of Education Steven Joyce last week announced the 10 recipients of this year’s Rutherford Discovery Fellowship. Two Otago University researchers were among those acknowledged. The Fellowship rewards New Zealand’s top early- to mid-career researchers with a funding package worth $800,000 over five years. The funding allows them “to undertake important research that will be valuable for New Zealand’s future,” Mr Joyce explained. Among the recipients were Otago’s Dr Angela Wanhalla, for her research on “Marriage: The Politics of Private Life in New Zealand,” and Dr Suetonia Palmer, of the University’s Christchurch Campus, for her research on “Improving evidence for decision-makers in chronic kidney disease.” “The Fellowships will help attract and retain our most talented early-career researchers and encourage their career development in this country,” said Joyce. Dr Wanhalla said that receiving the grant served to “reinforce what [I am] doing in terms of research,” and that it is also an “honour for the [Humanities] department.” She noted that having her research acknowledged by the Fellowship will “help elevate history to the sciences level,” and will allow her to widen the scope of her research on marriage and “do something of a grander vision.” Dr Wanhalla said she hopes in the future to look into how “marriage opens up the window to wider social issues,” including how we historicise these issues. Critic also spoke with recipient Dr Palmer, who described the award as a “life-changing event.” She said that the Fellowship helps to put research back on the centre stage and will allow her to give her undivided attention to her research, something she describes as a “unique and unexpected opportunity.” Dr Palmer described herself as “an information specialist” and hopes to use “next generation” methods of data gathering to “challenge the status quo in medical practice and improve health.” “The Rutherford awards are a genuinely visionary idea to keep New Zealand researchers in New Zealand for the period in their working lives when they are setting up research networks, teams and new ideas,” Dr Palmer said. With the aim of developing and fostering future leaders in the broader New Zealand science sector, the competitive Fellowship is available to researchers within three to eight years of completing their PhD. The fellowship was established in 2010 and now boasts 40 fellows, with this number expected to rise to 50 by 2014.
-
Hernandez Loses His Shit
Outgoing OUSA President Francisco Hernandez has expressed outrage at the Government’s decision to reduce the maximum size of university and wananga governing councils from 20 members to 12. Tertiary Education Minister Steven Joyce announced the decision in his Review of the Legislative Settings for University Governance last week. Joyce reasoned that the lower membership numbers would strengthen such institutions’ governance capabilities and enable them to remain internationally competitive. Hernandez, however, thought differently. “The government is attacking student representation on university councils,” he said. “This report has the whiff of an all-nighter pulled to crank out a forgotten piece of assessment. This isn’t even a C- job. It is an anemic, anonymous, 11-page document that compares poorly with the comprehensive Review of Tertiary Education Governance conducted … for Governance of the University of Canberra in 2003,” Hernandez continued. “The New Zealand tertiary education system, under current governance arrangements, has produced more qualifications and graduates than ever before. Or so announced the Minister yesterday. It is difficult to reconcile the ‘we’re doing a great job’ story line with the ‘the governance of universities needs to change’ story line.” Tertiary Education Union national secretary, Sharn Riggs, felt similarly, but said the announcement was no surprise. “The minister has been keen on turning universities into businesses with no links to their communities for some time now. His view is that increased productivity and profitability in the ITP sector, where similar changes were made two years ago, has nothing to do with the efforts of staff and other stakeholders but is the result of stripping out the representative structures on the councils.” “The Minister’s speech to tertiary education leaders this morning mentioned the word ‘society’ just once,” Riggs said. “Tertiary education has many benefits, not just the economic ones.” The Ministry of Education is coordinating consultation over the proposed changes. Public submissions close on 12 November.