The Otago University Debating Society meets every Tuesday at 6pm for social debating—new members are always welcome! Join our Facebook group for more information: facebook.com/groups/otagouniversitydebatingsociety
Affirmative, by Little Bo Peep
There's a reason why the joke about unemployed BA graduates exists… some areas of the humanities are becoming redundant in the context of what knowledge and skills humanity need heading into the future - especially with the increasing development of STEM (science, technology, engineering and maths) courses to absorb relevant areas of the humanities into their framework.
We need to recognise that there is increasing need for graduates of commerce and science, and stagnant or decreasing demand for graduates from the likes of performing arts or art history. The employability of arts degrees is heavily derived from the value of the fundamental skills it instills; such as critical thinking and empathy. This is because in a modern context, what employers extract the most value from is the application of humanitarian thought to STEM fields (for example, the ethical critique of genetic engineering technologies or the sociological/cultural perspectives on resource management and climate change). Regardless, the science is the thrust and the arts are ceasing to stand on their own.
Furthermore, such skills can often be taught in a much more direct way within STEM courses, through earlier education and increased engagement with online resources and forums. To some extent, they are even inherent in human nature. While some subjects such as politics, linguistics/language and education arguably have much deeper value, reducing funding to the arts benefits students in those subjects as well as STEM students.
Firstly, this money can be allocated towards science departments, allowing them to improve their facilities and educate more people. It only seems fair that the amount of funding allocated to each department is proportionate to the number of students enrolled. The arts students that remain can be assured that, as the courses available are streamlined to only include the best, they will be getting an education that is both engaging and increases their likelihood of employment upon completing their degree. Furthermore, a smaller arts programme means less students entering the degree 'just because', reducing competition in an already oversaturated market.
In reality, it is better to do a small number of things well than do many poorly. With the number of arts students enrolling at Otago falling and the increasing demand for STEM courses, the university should realize that what it does well, and what will provide people with long term security, is the best option.
Negative, by Mary Mary Quite Contrary
Arts subjects are hugely undervalued, and whole enrolment numbers have been dropping… but this in no way means that Arts graduates are not needed in society. Without politicians, educators and performers the world would be both dull and dysfunctional. It’s practically impossible to separate human society and its evolution from the arts and the key roles that they have played in pushing society and humanity forward. From ancient vases and sculptures that told the stories and history of past civilisations, to Picasso’s revolutionary, unorthodox painting that altered the way that the self was perceived and portrayed in art. The Arts as a field are inexplicably linked to the face and progression of society. It would be an injustice to limit our society’s ability to pass on and advance that knowledge further, and it would also be impractical for the university to cut funding to the arts.
Though STEM may offer more promising job prospects, there are qualities that the arts engender that still valuable, just less tangible. Subjects that make up the arts like philosophy and performing arts present the world in a varying way and often contrasts with the way the world works in a more conceptual, abstract manner. The representation of human identity is not necessarily something that can be explained or quantified by scientific theory.
What universities need to recognise is that they aren't simply businesses that pump graduates out, but a place where lots of people have the best experiences of their lives and learn about themselves. Nor do they actively encourage or incentivise people to pursue the arts. Providing arts courses allow people to immerse themselves in something they're passionate about, and that isn't something Otago can place a dollar value on. Further, passionate students are often more productive and more successful than students who enroll in a course simply because of the often false promise of a job at the end. Reducing funding to arts programmes inevitably means firing lecturers and reducing opportunities that might have enabled and inspired people not only to learn but also to hypothesise new ideas about humanity. The arts allow us the opportunity to understand the society we live in. We should be encouraging more people to study them. We need people with fresh ideas and communication skills to bring our society's way of thinking into the future.