As flat-hunting season draws to a close, multiple reports have emerged of landlords signing their flats to new groups of students without the consent of current tenants. Continuing a sad trend of illegality, the repeated events have forced students who relied on keeping their flats for the new year into seeking a back-up plan.
Critic Te Ārohi spoke to students who had their flatting plans bulldozed after their landlords preemptively signed their flats to new tenants – right under their noses.
Scarlett* had this happen to her with her private landlord back in July, when he had texted each of her flatmates individually about their future plans, all of whom are graduating or had signed other flats – all except for Scarlett and another one of her flatmates. They made it clear that they wanted to re-sign via a phone call, where they were met with evasive language. Scarlett told Critic that she was explicitly told that they would get the last word.
Both flatties thought this verbal communication was enough to hold him off. However, at the end of the winter academic break, the landlord held viewings of the flat. He issued the current flatties a $150 New World voucher for the “inconvenience of the viewings.” It was “basically bribery,” Scarlett said. After this, he signed a new group to the house without telling either of them. Scarlett found out because her landlord signed the new lease in front of Scarlett’s flatties who weren’t re-signing.
There has still been no explicit communication from the landlord besides a cheeky wee text he sent to her a week after his secret signing asking her, “Have you got a flat sorted for next year?” Kind of like an ex asking you how you’re doing after they broke up with you. Scarlett ghosted this text (she ate).
Stories like Scarlett’s are sadly all too common in Studentville. This is despite the assurances of the Residential Tenancies Act which clearly states that landlords cannot sign new tenants for the following year unless the current tenants said they are leaving – notice that only has to be given at least 28 days before the end of the lease. For example, for leases ending on December 31 (like many in Dunedin) you only legally have to inform your landlord of your intentions of leaving your current flat on December 3. “It is the landlord's responsibility not to sign up other tenants without knowing if the current tenants are leaving,” the Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB) told Critic.
Multiple students reported having their flats signed to new people without their consent during the months of July and August – four to five months before the end of their leases. Maya* was one of these students. After reaching out to her landlord about the prospect of re-signing, she was pressured into re-signing immediately. Maya didn’t have a full group confirmed, acting under the assumption that she had until November to find people to take over the empty rooms. Her landlord gave her roughly a week and a half to find other people to sign, and then when they asked for an extra two days of time, he began to schedule viewings of the flat to other groups. All of this information was relayed to Maya’s flatmates who weren’t re-signing the flat. The landlord then advertised the flat online without consent and used the interest he received from other groups to pressure Maya even further.
When Maya and her group tried to communicate that they really should have till November, he said that they were wrong and flats were always signed around mid way through the year. While this is a feature of Dunedin flatting culture, it (legally) doesn’t have to be like this.
Critic spoke to one person whose flatting group experienced the exact same phenomenon – they found out that their landlord had re-signed a group when they had asked to re-sign their lease. However the group did not want to comment further out of fear of having their bond taken if they spoke out. Landlords legally can't take money out of your bond for speaking out against them, but the sentiment is clear. Students are scared of standing up to their landlords because of the potential consequences, or often don’t think it’s even worth it to go to court because of how time-consuming it would be.
When asked about whether they considered pursuing legal action, both Scarlett and Maya said that they had, but ultimately decided against it. They expressed fear of potential repercussions on their reputation, or that they would go to tribunal and they would rule in the landlord’s favour. “Landlords have so many rights right now,” Scarlett emphasised. “And if I did [go to the tribunal], I don’t know if there would even be a good outcome.” Maya did go to OUSA Student Support for advice and they said that her group may have a claim. But she hasn’t pursued any legal action because the tribunal is “notoriously fickle” and she needed a good reference for future flats.
CAB told Critic that tenants “should challenge the notice at the Tenancy Tribunal” if they think their landlord doesn’t have a good reason to end a tenancy, or if they haven’t followed “due process.” When asked about what tenants can do to protect themselves, CAB emphasised the importance of knowing your rights and standing up for yourself. Every year, CAB receives complaints of landlords harassing their tenants to make up their mind on next year’s flatting decision – something that happened to both Scarlett and Maya, many others in Dunedin, and probably you, too. CAB strongly advises students to remind their landlord that they only legally need 28 days notice of their decision to stay, or not.
If you experience problems with your landlord like this one, contact OUSA Student Support or the Citizens Advice Bureau for legal advice and support. 2025 is the year of knowing your rights and standing on business.
*Names changed.