Homo-geneous
Culture

Homo-geneous

I don’t even let Georgie get a word out.
“It happened again.” They blink, trying to catch up with what I said.
“What happened again?”
“It. It happened again.”
Georgie sighs, “You really have to be more clear.”
“She had been fucking Clare the whole time.” My voice is filled with a specific, petty vitriol. 
“Who had? Aroha?” Georgie’s brow furrows as they begin to put the pieces together. 
I breathe in deeply, processing what I just learnt. “Yes. Apparently, basically, the entire time we were having sex, she was also having sex with Clare and didn’t tell me.” 
“Fuck, dude. I’m sorry.” Georgie's face fills with genuine sympathy.
“She was meant to be my rebound from Clare!” I whinge. 
“Now, I don’t mean to be a prick in your time of need, but you two were just sleeping together, right?”
“Mhmmm…”
“So she could technically sleep with whoever she wanted, right?”
“Mhmmmmmmm…” 
“Does she know you had sex with me after you and Clare split up?”
“Well…no.”
Georgie rolls their eyes. 
“And didn’t you meet Aroha through Clare?”
“Yeah…” I admit. 
Georgie sighs, “I get it, dude, I really do. But I don’t think you quite have the right to be this upset.”
“No! The issue isn’t that she slept with someone else. It’s fucking – look she can do what she wants. But it’s the principle of the matter! She was having sex with my ex, as my rebound!” My head falls down onto the table, into my arms. 

I know I sound ridiculous, I know I do. I can hear every Instagram slideshow about ‘communicating boundaries’ and ‘free-love’ raging in my head, but they get overridden by my internal five-year-old self screaming “Mine! Mine! Mine!” I’m not even sure I want to date Aroha. She’s lovely, but the actuality of dating her feels so far removed from the point. 


 

The exhausting fact is: I have been here before. Georgie has been here before. Two years ago I was dating a girl named Alice when I spotted someone else in a tutorial. She had a shaved head and a carabiner hung from patched cargo pants. I was drawn like a dumb lesbian moth to a flame. The semester was drawing to a close by the time I dragged up the courage to approach her.
“Hi, sorry, I just wanted to say you look really cool.” She did look really cool, leaning against the wall like James Dean, waiting for the tutorial door to open. 
“Hey, thanks. I’m Alice.” She stuck her hand out for me to shake.
“That’s my girlfriend's name!” 
She laughed, “Don’t mix us up.”

We started hanging out, chatting, sending each other little lesbian memes: “can this be us <3” next to a picture of two women in pretty dresses frolicking in a field. Eventually, I introduced her to my Alice, and girlfriend Alice raved afterwards about how cute the new Alice was. The private chatting became a threeway group chat, which became a three-way relationship. I was so happy. I began to scoff at the idea of monogamy: “Don’t people understand? It’s not natural to just be with one person.” 

But what I didn’t realise is how jealousy controlled my version of the relationship, the version which only involved me. I demanded what I thought it should look like – becoming upset if it didn’t. I didn’t like the Alices hanging out without me. My heart would physically ache. I needed to maintain this image of us as a three in my head. My Alice(s). 

They both dumped me on the same day. And then stayed together. When I would spy them on campus right after the breakup, walking hand in hand and laughing (at me, my paranoia whispered) I learned the meaning of feeling your stomach drop. The nausea was constant. They were rubbing their relationship in my face on purpose, I convinced myself. 

A summer-long hometown hiatus over the break was what I needed to snap out of it and come back to my (sane) self. To reach out and apologise. While I can happily say I am friends with both Alices now, it didn’t come easy for me. I swore off dating for at least a year – a romantic sabbatical, if you will. That was before the Alices introduced me to Clare. 

Sweet, empathetic, emotional Clare. We had an intense relationship, hardly leaving each other's rooms; planning our future wedding, children’s names, house decor. After the complete heartbreak with the Alices, I craved monogamous stability like a drug. I felt so proud of myself, I had won. I wasn’t going to be thirty-five on a singles cruise around the Caribbean. No, Clare and I would be drinking matcha in our garden, as our daughter Josephine (Clare’s grandmother's name) plays with our pet corgi under our kōwhai tree. 

Until I woke up one day and realised I was suffocating under the weight of our imagined future. I watched friends plan solo backpacking trips around Vietnam and began to doubt if it was time to settle down. Clare hated travelling. I doubled down on our relationship planning and watched Clare’s face light up as our plans together got more and more elaborate. I started hinting that I might propose, and she giggled at the idea of getting married after less than six months of dating. Like a precious porcelain doll, I squeezed our relationship so tight I cracked it. I broke up with her over the phone so I didn’t have to watch her face fall. 


Clare and I stayed friends after the break up, slowly unravelling the knots to figure out what our friendship would be like. Two months ago, she introduced me to Aroha at a party. I woke up the next morning in Aroha’s bed. And the morning after that. 


 

Georgie's big, brown, dog-like eyes stare at me. They can see the past few years fueling my reaction to finding out that Aroha and Clare are sleeping together. 
“Have you considered it’s maybe time to stop sleeping with your exes’ friends?” they ask, their voice laden with leather-thick patience. 
“What do you mean?” I reply into my arms, my voice muffled.
“Why don’t you do it like straight people do? I don’t know. Try dating apps, maybe? Isn’t there one just for lesbians.” I make some small noise of disapproval. “Come on! Let’s at least give it a try, where’s your phone?” Georgie starts rifling around in my bag. Knowing they won’t give up, I emerge from the arm cave and grab my phone off them.

I actually had downloaded Her a few months ago on a whim, but never made an account. After spending too long picking somewhat acceptable photos for my profile (Georgie vetoed just uploading a singular photo of myself taken right then) I officially entered the world of online dating. 
“Alright, first profile.” I spin the phone around to show Georgie, it reads:
Hi! I’m Melissa! Me and my boyfriend are looking for…
“Nope.” Georgie and I say in sync with my swipe to the next person.
Grace
Virgo
Love marvel movies, dogs and surfing 
Looking for long term relationships ONLY do not message for hook-ups

“She looks cute,” I say, “I’m not a huge Marvel fan but for her…” 
Georgie frowns. 
“What is it?” I ask. 
Georgie pauses. “I hooked up with her last week.”
“She’s that Grace? Georgie no.” Georgie gives an apologetic shrug.
 
We swipe through fewer than ten more people, striking nary a fancy, before the app won’t let me swipe anymore. 
“Is this like Tinder where you have to pay to swipe more kind of thing?” I ask, confused. 
“No, I think the app ran out of lesbians,” Georgie replies.
“What do you mean? That’s all the lesbians on this app in Dunedin? There was like, ten, max.”
“I think so, dude.” Again, that sympathetic look. I sigh again and check the time. 
“Shit, I have to go: my first tut of the semester starts, like, now.” I start gathering up my things.
“I’m sorry about Clare and Aroha, and I’m sorry there’s apparently a lesbian shortage in Ōtepoti,” Georgie says.
“It’s not your fault. I’ll see you later, I really have to run.” 

When I arrive at my tutorial, they’re already in the middle of a discussion. I take the last seat across from someone I have never seen before. Her Macbook has two stickers on it, gothic looking moths in the colours of the lesbian and trans flags. 
“Hi!” I say, out of breath. “I like your stickers.”
“Aw thanks, my friend back in Denmark did them!” she replies. She has a cute Danish accent, and I can see her slightly crooked teeth when she smiles. 
“Oh, are you from Denmark?” I ask.
She gives a little nod and her hair falls in front of her face. “Yeah, I’m an exchange student.”
“How have you been finding Dunedin?” I ask. 
“Oh, uh, nice from what I have seen, but I’m too nervous to look around by myself. I don’t really know anyone yet.” 
“Oh really? Well, I could show you around. Here, let me give you my phone number.”

Author's note: This story was inspired by actual examples from the queer dating scene in Ōtepoti Dunedin, though taken from the sapphic dating scene (as it’s what I am most familiar with). Every relationship scenario described actually happened to someone, though (luckily) not all to one person. 


Warning: Undefined variable $more in /container/application/public/article.php on line 194

Fatal error: Uncaught TypeError: mysqli_num_rows(): Argument #1 ($result) must be of type mysqli_result, null given in /container/application/public/admin/config.php:132 Stack trace: #0 /container/application/public/admin/config.php(132): mysqli_num_rows(NULL) #1 /container/application/public/article.php(194): mnr(NULL) #2 /container/application/public/index.php(30): include('/container/appl...') #3 {main} thrown in /container/application/public/admin/config.php on line 132