In honour of this being the last issue of 2024, here’s a supercut of Critic’s year. As you’ll see, Critic Te Ārohi is many things.
Critic is the magazine. It’s every Monday being like Christmas Day, rushing to the stands and holding tangible proof of your hard work; looking around and seeing students holding it too. Being told how gorgeous the magazine is this year and gushing about how talented the design team is. It’s Jakira’s uncanny ability to nail every male student stereotype. Evie’s skill with Photoshop being so good a Uni staff member asked me whether I just happened to have a Bob Ross costume lying around.
Critic is the office. It’s finding a Corona bottle bong in a drawer, ice skates under the printer table, and a folder of former editors’ lawsuits. Newcomers’ eyes widening as they come in the door and witness the chaos (a napping Sam on the couch included). It’s adding to the amalgamation of Critic clutter: bejewelled Critic tracksuit, bespoke ‘Let Her Cook’ apron, and condom pinboard.
Critic is the couch – this year at least. It’s Grant Robertson telling you the couch you spent hours hand-painting has been there since he was OUSA President. Carting it all over North Dunedin and hearing bottle caps clatter inside. A Castle St photoshoot and police asking if you’re planning on burning it. Laughing it off, but wishing that you could.
Critic is the reviews. It’s fanning out and sneaking into halls to review their food (not Aquinas’). Hugh and Iris being accused of subterfuge at Hayward and running back to the office to write about how their food was a bit shit anyway. Gryffin being persecuted by the ‘Mond, forgiven months later at Ski Club’s Cheese Toastie by a Salmond fresher drunk on home-brewed ginger beer. It’s sore bellies and greasy fingers after eight rounds of fish and chips. The dreaded kebab review drip hand and crowding around the radioactive turnip in Ellie’s one.
Critic is the anonymity. It’s spotting Boba Ket on campus, giving him a nod and wondering how many people have worked out who their favourite drug reviewer is. It’s students wanting to be anonymous despite the fact that they’re just commenting on an article about a new roof.
Critic is the letters. Angry ones, adoring ones. Ones pointing out yet another crossword error and putting the ‘days without a crossword error’ counter back to zero. Ones addressed to ‘Mrs Critic’ from a giggling Jordan in a squeaky office chair. Your inbox pinging five times in a row and suspense building as they wait for you to read what they’ve cooked up.
Critic is the humour. It’s laughing out loud when you come across a joke in someone’s draft article and commenting “nice one” in the Google doc. Every culture article Lotto touched turning to gold. It’s loudly consulting the office over what an appropriate simile would be for something students find disappointing, but fitting for Sam’s voice (answer: a wet toilet seat).
Critic is the scandal. Calling your parents to warn them to please not read the next issue of the magazine – it might frighten them. Wondering about what future employers will think when they Google your name. Looking through the archives and realising it could be much worse.
Critic is Proper Journalism. Having a movie marathon of Palestine documentaries to educate yourselves on the issue, meeting with experts and debating amongst yourselves the term “institutional neutrality” and what the role of journalism is in all this. Calling the same media law professors for advice and learning what the term ‘contempt in court’ means. Dropping a story; the fallout wouldn’t be worth it.
Critic is the freedom. It’s realising you, within the bounds of the law, can do whatever you want. Making yourselves reality TV producers for a dating competition. Hanna typing notes of dating students’ conversations while being pushed on the ice on a bear named ‘Pickles’. Organising a photo shoot of Exec pretending to smoke a cone out of the office-dwelling cone bong named Terry and justifying to concerned OUSA staff why it’s cool.
Critic is the free shit. It’s pitching a review just so you’ll get tickets to an event, and then piecing together an article based on an assortment of incoherent voice notes, messages, and a foggy memory. Planet Media giving you tickets to the museum’s After Dark events and refusing to ride the slippery pig – even for journalism.
Critic is the socials. It’s the video team hitting the Link to ask students whether the Uni should turn campus grass into a dairy farm. Accidentally overexposing almost every single video and yet again losing the fluffy thing that goes on the mic. The same ketchup intro. Battling with U-Bar’s Instagram for coverage of the Pint Night line.
Critic is The hypoCRITICals. It’s thinking Hugh was kidding when he said he was forming a band and then singing along to ‘Trainspotting’ at their first Pint Night gig. Being inspired by Lady Gaga’s ‘Little Monsters’ and coining the term ‘Critters’ for their fan base; it spreading to the name of Critic staff.
Critic is the print nights, one every week. It’s sponsored Subway every second Wednesday, munched over office beers (paid for by me, the office sugar mommy). Excitedly telling everyone that Burger Fuel has FINALLY agreed to sponsor not one print night, but two. Getting out the office scales to weigh Madeline’s heart-shaped carabiners and working out how many you’d need to make a lesbian. Not making it through the evening without Palmy high school horror stories being brought up at least once, or someone saying, “That’s a story!”
Critic is the Pint Night tally. It’s Molly proclaiming Wednesday to be the BEST DAY solely because of this. It’s stickering everyone there and wondering how someone got one on the ceiling. Hugh in his Pint Night pants waddling back to the office with three stolen glasses stuffed in them and proudly adding it to the whiteboard tally: 11 overall.
Critic is the impromptu bar crawls. Splitting the G at The Bog, seeing Jono off to the ER after falling off a chair, and then slamming pickleback shots at The Craic (the only Octagon bar that sells them). Saying, “We should do this more often,” and taking it back the next morning when it’s time to lock back into the grind.
Critic is the smell. Opening all the windows after print night to let out the aroma of old sandwiches, Hugh’s two-minute noodle dishes, Speight’s Summit Ultra bottles, and the Bubblemint Extra gum you’re still trying to get rid of.
Critic is the cursed designer computer. Evie battling it on print days, patiently – then impatiently – waiting for it to reboot after InDesign crashed it again. Watching the print night time tally drop after she gets a new one.
Critic is the Friday morning meetings. It’s Sam polishing off a half-drunk Woodstock at 10am to a chorus of “I love it”, coined by Hugh. The meetings taking over an hour of shouting ideas over one another; running out of room on the whiteboard and ink in the pens.
Critic is an onslaught of pitches. It’s pitches at parties, OUSA lunch, Pint Night, Carousel. It’s your head bursting with ideas, ones that overflow into your notes app when you wake up at 4am, hoping to get back to sleep before the content machine whirs back into motion. Failing, sighing, and making a meme for your friend who’s running for SOULS Prez.
Critic is the tea. News tips sent from the flatmate of a friend who heard you work for Critic. Madam Prez parking up in the office with a grin and saying, “You didn’t hear this from me, but…” and spilling the latest Uni or OUSA drama. Getting a tip off from the ODT that the Countdown rats might be back and wondering whether the Breakfast Show will invite you to comment on whether it’s students’ fault again.
Critic is the group chat. It’s endlessly filled with gossip, memes, invites and hot takes, and is almost definitely muted by some. It’s getting tipsy on an Emersons’s tasting tray (the first of the summer), spamming the group chat by giving everyone nicknames, and hoping Hugh knows that when you call him ‘Forrest Gump’ you’re referring to his tendency to run everywhere.
Critic is the influence. It’s watching inside jokes seep into the student zeitgeist and overhearing someone use the term BNOC (Big Name on Campus) or “sheatha”. It’s spotting walls of centrefolds and Critic covers at flat parties: the Wednesday night march, Sarah’s Campus Creatures, Mikey ripping a cone, and Bachelor Joel Tebbs holding out a (fake) rose. It’s an in-office argument over which $4 lunch side is better, samosas or onion bhajis, turning into a last-minute sub-in Debatable column.
Critic is the hustle. It’s no one being properly compensated for the work they put into the magazine. It’s calling it a “labour of love” and meaning it, but also wishing Iris didn’t have to pick up night shifts at Countdown outside of feature writing and her studies.
Critic is the burnout. It’s non-stop content creation and wanting to press pause sometimes. It’s watching the pinboard of magazine covers fill up, counting down the number of issues left to go before the next break, saying how crazy it is how fast the year has gone.
Critic takes a village. It’s watching a fledgling group of writers, illustrators, and content creators become a team; doing stupid shit, covering important issues, writing from the heart, and guzzling cans of Monster in-between. It’s starting the year wondering how on earth you’ll fill 26 48-page magazines with content and ending up with a longer list of pitches than space to put it all. It’s writing this editorial by trawling through the year’s issues and group chat messages, and struggling to whittle it down because so much has happened, and you can’t quite believe how much we’ve all achieved.
Critic is procrastination; the Critters’ of their studies by spending more time cooking up content in the office and it’s yours, by reading this long as fuck editorial. There’s a whole magazine of puzzles in store. Procrastinate some more, why don’t you?