Dundas Fence Collapse Sparks Feud
News

Dundas Fence Collapse Sparks Feud

In an incident leaving four flats and their landlords at each other’s throats (or at least slightly more passive aggressive than usual), a large fence in a Dundas Street flatting complex of four has collapsed over their driveway. Or perhaps been pulled down? Given some of the flats are owned by different landlords, a sort of “he said she said” situation has arisen – and Critic Te Ārohi got caught in the middle trying to make sense of it all.

Taylor*, a tenant at Flat 3, told Critic that the entire thing started a few weeks ago when the boys at Flat 1 were hosting a party in their backyard – one with a “pissing corner” that leaked into the driveway: “There was basically a huge puddle of piss on our driveway.” Taylor heard from one of his friends attending the party that someone was pushed into the fence, causing it to take on a “wonky angle” and making the driveway a bottleneck. 

A week later, and on the eve of Southern Sounds, Flat 1 and 2 were having some drinks. As Taylor’s mate was leaving at midnight, they said the fence “wasn’t looking too good.” Upon going outside, Taylor and his flat found the fence “fully collapsed.” 

Flat 2 told Critic Te Ārohi that their landlord said to file the police report so that they could get the insurance. They dutifully did so upon discovering the damage the following morning. Flat 1 was reportedly unfussed about the situation when Flat 2 confronted them about it – seemingly having “no idea what happened.” Flat 4 and Flat 5 have remained uninvolved in the situation. 

While Cait* from Flat 1 could understand people assuming it was them who caused the fence to fall over, she told Critic, “We don’t actually know if it was people from my party [...] We’re still unsure if it was us or the boys next door. That’s where the current conflict is. [It’s a dispute] between our landlord and their landlord.” Cait shrugged, “I’m sorry – I’m not that strong to pull on that fence.”

Cait’s flatmate Anna* chimed in, saying, “With the structure of the fence, all the supports would be facing the boys’ property. It had a couple of screws in some places, but most of it was [resting on those supports].” They confirmed that they had noticed it gradually getting worse over the past few weeks. 

A Police spokesperson, speaking to the report filed by Flat 2, said, “Police inspected the fence [...] and found the posts to be rotten. On that basis, we’re unable to conclude if the fence was wilfully damaged [...] Police have relayed this to the person who contacted us about the fence and the matter is now between them and their landlord.” The plot thickens.

Allegedly, the boys at Flat 1 then went to talk to the girls over at Flat 2 following the fence’s collapse. Flat 1 asked Flat 2 why the girls were telling people the boys had pushed over the fence, denying doing so. “And we were like, ‘No we actually didn’t,’” said Cait. “We just said we didn’t know who pushed it over. It could’ve been someone off the street for all we fucking know.” The boys apparently got “real aggro” at Cait’s flatmate, but left a bit calmer after some clarifications. 

Rolling her eyes, Cait revealed to us that two of the Flat 1 boys were actually at her party. Allegedly, Flat 1 had told their landlord they’d spent the night in preparation for Southern Sounds. “I have a video of one of them on the pole,” she told us. Riot. 

“The funny thing is that those boys seem to have a thing for almost fully naked cooking. And [the removal of the fence] means that there are glass doors fully open to the street. I was so nervous [walking past], I thought it was ‘an apron and nothing else’ situation,” Anna told us worriedly. 

When asked for comment about the fence, Finn* from Flat 1 told us that while at Flat 2’s party they were informed that “some tall dude just pulled [our] fence down trying to climb it. I told my other flatmate and went and had a look and half the fence was hanging down. I filed a police report straight away and people kept pulling it down and sitting on it.” 

He explained that over ten members from the party held at Flat 2 pulled the fence down. While Flat 2 was standing and videoing this all going down, someone (now confirmed to be from Flat 3 told them that it was Flat 1 that did it, “when we were all standing watching.”

Furthermore, the boys denied any knowledge of the fence getting gradually worse before the eventual collapse. “We had the bro’s 21st last semester but there’s bins and bushes in the way [of the fence],” Finn explained.  

As a final comment, Finn revealed, “My flatmate's mum owns the property, so why would we break it?” That is a damning point. According to Finn, the fence actually isn’t their property but instead belongs to the Flats at 2, 3, and 4 – so they don’t have to pay for the damage, no matter who actually pulled the fence down. 

Critic Te Ārohi went out to investigate and we came back empty handed. Who pulled this fence down? In this instance, we fucked around and didn’t find out. Maybe it’s a mystery better left unsolved – we’ll leave that for you to decide.

*Names changed. Flat numbers scrambled.

 

Warning: Undefined variable $more in /container/application/public/article.php on line 194

Fatal error: Uncaught TypeError: mysqli_num_rows(): Argument #1 ($result) must be of type mysqli_result, null given in /container/application/public/admin/config.php:132 Stack trace: #0 /container/application/public/admin/config.php(132): mysqli_num_rows(NULL) #1 /container/application/public/article.php(194): mnr(NULL) #2 /container/application/public/index.php(30): include('/container/appl...') #3 {main} thrown in /container/application/public/admin/config.php on line 132