Debatable: Would you still love me if I was a worm?
Columns

Debatable: Would you still love me if I was a worm?

Debatable is a column written by the Otago University Debating Society. The Debating Society welcomes new members and meets at the Business School every Tuesday at 6pm.

For

Yes, of course I would. Is that even a question? I’d even build you a little worm house with lots of dirt and food so you could live the rest of your worm life happily, because I love you.

There are many practical and fickle reasons why it would make my life harder to continue loving you as a worm. But I don’t care. This worm, deep down, is still the person I fell in love with. You’ve always been kind of quirky, and this is just you taking your manic-pixie-dream-girl persona to the next level. 

Love is supposed to be unconditional and true love should be able to last through anything. I would still love you if you got really sick and I had to quit uni to nurse you back to health, or if you got scammed out of all your money and I had to pay your rent (but your dad could probably cover that). Why should it be any different if you turned into a worm? 

Love isn’t all about appearance and it would be incredibly shallow to say otherwise. Even if your outside appearance changed, I still love the real you – what’s on the inside. Didn’t we all learn from Beauty and the Beast that we should look past the fact that our partner is an animal and love them anyway (that’s totally the message of Beauty and the Beast right)? We’d find ways to adjust to the new you and we’d make it work. 

Think about it like this: love is the most powerful emotion in the world. In pretty much every movie, song, artwork and poem, love wins. Love triumphs over hate and good wins out over evil. As The Beatles said, “Love is all you need.” What’s really important is that you’re together with the ones you love. You being a worm might be the biggest challenge we’ve faced in our relationship, but we’d get through it – together. Because that’s what love is all about.

 

Against

Look babe, I love you. You know that. But a worm? Come on. Every relationship has limits and boundaries, things that partners fundamentally disagree over, like kids, marriage, money – or interspecies relationships. I really thought we were on the same page with everything, but I just can’t love you as a worm. I’m sorry.

It’s simply impractical to have a worm girlfriend. You know that I would never hurt you on purpose, but if you were a worm I would always be worried that I was going to squish you while you were in my pocket, or accidentally step on you when I'm in a rush, or mistake you for a noodle in my ramen. If we tried to go on a cute beach date (because the weather has been really nice in Dunedin lately) you’d get eaten by a seagull! 

I also couldn’t talk to you anymore. Communication is the foundation of any good relationship, and I need to be able to discuss things with you if we’re going to continue as a couple. Plus, it would get a bit boring telling you about my day but you can’t say anything back because you’re a worm. Let’s just be realistic.

And lastly, it would just be a little weird. You know I’m a little scared of bugs, and you always have to squash the spiders in the bathroom for me, so it would be really hard to not be scared of you as a worm. 

You know our love is forever – but forever has to end sometime, it seems. Even unconditional love has conditions, and I have to love you enough to let you go. Others may argue that love is enduring and can last through any trial, but I believe that even love has limitations. It doesn’t make what we had any less beautiful, but it does make it over. You’ve changed, and you’re not the same person I fell in love with… you’re not even a person anymore. Sorry babe, it’s over.


Warning: Undefined variable $more in /container/application/public/article.php on line 194

Fatal error: Uncaught TypeError: mysqli_num_rows(): Argument #1 ($result) must be of type mysqli_result, null given in /container/application/public/admin/config.php:132 Stack trace: #0 /container/application/public/admin/config.php(132): mysqli_num_rows(NULL) #1 /container/application/public/article.php(194): mnr(NULL) #2 /container/application/public/index.php(30): include('/container/appl...') #3 {main} thrown in /container/application/public/admin/config.php on line 132