Dear Ethel,
Our landlord is blaming us for damaging the carpet and telling us we need to pay $2,500 for new carpet or we won’t get our bond back at the end of the year. Can he do that? We have contributed a couple of little stains to the carpet but it was already shit when we moved in and it certainly doesn’t look much worse. I don’t see why we should have to pay for an entirely new carpet.
Stainley.
Hi Stainley,
There are some pretty dodgy landlords around there, that’s for sure! You are quite right. If you haven’t damaged the carpet to the extent that it needs replacing, it is unreasonable for the landlord to charge you for new carpet. That’s called ‘betterment’ and landlords aren’t supposed to do it. They can only charge you a reasonable cost to repair or replace something of similar condition. If the carpet was manky when you moved in, maybe just a professional spot clean of those couple of stains is all you need.
According to the Residential Tenancies Act, properties need to be left in a ‘reasonable’ state, which is of course a very subjective term, but doesn’t mean they need to be cleaned to a professional standard. This is where it is quite useful if you took photographs when you moved in and filled that property condition report out accurately. If you have, there’s the evidence you need to disagree with the landlord if they’re pulling a fast one.
Don’t be harassed into signing the bond form if you disagree with it and NEVER sign a blank bond form! If you do, you can say goodbye to your chances of getting your bond back. If you can’t agree with the landlord about what bond should be returned, ring the agency that holds bond money on 0800 737 666, give them your details, and tell them you want the bond held in dispute.
Please drop in and have a chat to one of the friendly advocates at OUSA Student Support, 5 Ethel B. They can help you work out the best way to get what you are owed back at the end of the tenancy and are expert at helping resolve any other tenancy issues. They’ll even have a chat to the landlord on your behalf if that makes life easier for you
Whole lotta love,
-Ethel xox