Critic’s Ultimate Guide to Peanut Butter
Culture

Critic’s Ultimate Guide to Peanut Butter

from Issue 18 ()

By

peanut butterfoodculture

My heart genuinely goes out to those unfortunate enough to be cursed with a nut allergy - I’m sorry.

That does, however, mean more peanut butter for me. You don’t die and I get more PB all to myself - there can be no loser.

I thought this week I’d shake it up a bit as an ode to my raging addiction - adding fuel to the fire, if you will.

I hereby present to you this definitive review of peanut butters according to yours truly.

 

Nut Brothers Smooth and Slightly Salted

I was never a smooth fan, but this is runnier than your Sunday morning aftermath, which gets a no from me, dawg.

taste: not even peanutty

texture: way too runny

price: $5.99

crunchiness: ugh

overall: 1/10

 

Kraft Smooth

For me, this PB is akin to my first puff of a marlboro red - the single source that began my addiction

taste: tastes like childhood

texture: how I remember play-dough

price: $4.00

crunchiness: non-existent – who wants smooth?! WHO?!

overall: 4/10 only for nostalgic purposes

 

Homebrand Crunchy

Like a lass from the Deep South; does the job, cheap date, spreads like a charm - just a bit pasty

taste: meh

texture: a bit too pasty

price: $2.50

crunchiness: a bit few and far between

overall: 5/10

 

Pic’s Crunchy

Pic’s undoubtedly carries the name, but for me it’s the equivalent of a Karen Walker runaway girl necklace - basic and overpriced.

taste: “true blue” peanut taste

texture: not oily enough

price: $6.50

crunchiness: pretty bloody good

overall: 6/10

 

Fix and Fogg Honey

This is the classy, delicate sample. Approach with caution or you’ll be in too deep.

taste: perfect salty/sweet

texture: like an angel

price: $8.99

crunchiness: crunchy AF

overall: 7/10

 

Fix + Fogg Smoke and Fire

Perhaps better than crack, however let down by price. Texture is second-to-none. In a satay burger would, to take the words out of my father’s mouth, “make your pants poke out front”.

taste: smoky + chili bite

texture: fucking spot on

price: $8.99

crunchiness: again, spot on

overall: 8/10

 

Pam’s Finest

The loveable folk at Pam’s must’ve brainstormed “how do we put crunchy peanut butter on steroids?” and came up with this beautiful, beautiful concoction

taste: roasted peanuts and happiness

texture: oily and thick (where my sleazy emoji at?)

price: $4.99

crunchiness: on steroids

overall: 9/10

More Culture from Issue 18

Browse the Critic Archives