David Clark
In my role as an MP, my preferred Presidential Candidate is the one the United States public elects. I believe in the value of democracy.
For reasons of electoral mathematics, I believe the winner can only be Hillary Clinton. Demographic changes over time have stacked the odds against any Republican Presidential candidate winning, regardless of their merits.
The US Electoral College system places a disproportionate amount of influence on swing states for the final electoral outcome. Over time, those ‘swing states’ have become more and more Democrat, without an offsetting swing to the Republican Party elsewhere. As things currently stand, in order for a Republican to win, a Democratic Candidate would have to perform extraordinarily poorly.
On demographics alone, even the previous Republican President George W. Bush shouldn’t have taken the White House. His success, it is said, owes a great deal to the poor performance of his opponent. Since that time, demographic trends have continued to shift in favour of the Democrats.
Political alignment between parties in different countries is never perfect. My own values, and those of my party align most naturally with the Democrats. I like Hillary Clinton’s ease with people of different races, ages, genders and creeds.
Donald Trump’s dislike for those who are different to him does not sit comfortably with me. There are parallels in New Zealand. Trump’s rhetoric reminds me of Don Brash’s infamous Orewa speech and the ugly Kiwi vs Iwi billboard campaign produced by the National Party in 2005. Not all of National’s members are so extreme, but the National Party has long enjoyed its sister-party relationship with the Republicans. Indeed, the blogger Whale Oil is reported to have derived his ‘dirty politics’ from Republican Tea Party contacts.
Unfortunately, numerous junk polls (or polls that are poorly described) paint the current US presidential race as a close-run thing. It is certainly one way to sell newspapers! Popular opinion of the leading candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump is not so far apart, but when likely Electoral College results are projected, the race immediately looks one-sided.
Of course, Republicans could win if they succeeded in broadening their appeal and managed to grow support amongst ethnic minorities, women and young people. At this stage, in this race, that looks unlikely.
Michael Woodhouse
Like many others I have keenly followed the fascinating spectacle that is the 2016 United States Presidential election. It has taken many twists and turns that commentators did not see coming. However, the circus that is the primary and now Presidential campaign has sadly taken away from the key facts and issues America is facing. It’s hard to pick the real policies from the media frenzy around Mexican walls, health scares and Mrs Trump’s modelling shots.
It’s not appropriate for a member of a foreign Government to say who should be elected President. We would rightly be pretty scathing if the shoe was on the other foot and an American politician was offering a view on who should lead New Zealand. That choice is absolutely a matter for the American people. Both main candidates are pitching their attributes and attacking the shortcomings of the other. Politics in America does appear to have a much sharper attack strategy. Whether that is ultimately effective or simply leads to more voters being turned off politics is a question presently being debated by political commentators. I favour the view that it is indeed turning voters off and it is bad for democracy in the long run.
I’m surprised that Trump has made it this far. The reflections on why that is will go on for years. He has portrayed himself as anti-establishment but that is contestable. Clinton has more political experience but that includes some negative issues along the way herself (such as the handling of her classified emails!). It is noteworthy that both candidates are heading for the dubious distinction of having the lowest approval ratings of any candidates for office in America’s history.
Campaigning in the 21st century is also undergoing massive change and I watch with interest how polling, message management and fundraising are all evolving through this campaign.
America needs a leader who is able to find solutions to domestic social and financial challenges while focusing on complicated global issues including trade, the movement of people and terrorism, while at the same time providing calm and measured leadership. The first woman President? An anti-establishment self-styled master negotiator that builds walls not bridges? The answer will be a matter for the American people but will have massive implications for the world. I for one will be glued to the TV on November 9.